News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by wiseowise on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:01AM (#43099777)
> soon to be dead set of patterns.

Dozens of threads of people praising how performant and easy uv is, how it builds on standards and current tooling instead of inventing new incompatible set of crap, and every time one comment pops up with “akshually my mix of conda, pyenv, pipx, poetry can already do that in record time of 5 minutes, why do you need uv? Its going to be dead soon”.

Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by noodletheworld on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:18AM (#43099848)
So what?

If someone doesn’t want to use it, or doesn’t like it, or is, quite reasonably skeptical that “this time it’ll be different!” … let them be.

If it’s good, it’ll stand on its own despite the criticism.

If it can’t survive with some people disliking and criticising it is, it deserves to die.

Right? Live and let live. We don’t have to all agree all the time about everything.

uv is great. So use it if you want to.

And if you don’t, that’s okay too.

Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by hiAndrewQuinn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @05:54AM (#43100769)
Naive take. https://gwern.net/holy-war counsels that, in fact, becoming the One True Package Manager for a very popular programming language is an extremely valuable thing to aim towards. This is even outside of the fact that `uv` is backed by a profit-seeking company (cf https://astral.sh/about). I'm all for people choosing what works best for them, but I'm also staunchly pro-arguing over it.
Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by noodletheworld on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @08:04AM (#43101675)
> becoming the One True Package Manager for a very popular programming language is an extremely valuable thing

For companies. Which is why when random people start acting like it’s important, you have to wonder why it’s important to them.

For example, being a corporate shill. Or so deep in coolaid you can’t allow alternative opinions? Hm?

It’s called an echo chamber.

Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by og_kalu on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @08:36AM (#43101988)
Why on earth would it be only important for companies?
Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by hiAndrewQuinn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @09:45AM (#43102659)
>Which is why when random people start acting like it’s important, you have to wonder why it’s important to them.

I don't use uv because I don't currently trust that it will be maintained on the timescales I care about. I stick with pip and venv, because I expect they will still be around 10 years from now, because they have much deeper pools of interested people to draw contributors and maintainers from, because - wait for it - they are really popular. Your theory about random people being corporate shills for anything they keep an eye on the popularity of can be explained much more parsimoniously like that.

Re:A year of uv: pros, cons, and should you migrate by tway1231789 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @08:02AM (#43101653)
To be fair here: conda was praised as the solution to everything by many when it was new. It did have its own standards of course. Now most people hate it.

Every packaging PEP is also hailed as the solution to everything, only to be superseded by a new and incompatible PEP within two years.