News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by DamnInteresting on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:48PM (#43093531)
I own a Chevy Bolt EV, one of the less expensive EVs on the US market (after tax rebates, it was about $30k USD). I purchased it in May 2017, so I've had almost 8 years with this car.

I feel like a lot of these write ups overlook other advantages of EVs. Some of my favorite things about this car:

* It is very quiet, inside and out

* It is very torquey, moving instantly when I push the accelerator

* One-pedal driving is very pleasant

* Charging at home feels like an incredible luxury (which it is)

Occasionally I am required to drive my wife's Corolla, and despite being in good repair, it feels like driving an old jalopy; it vibrates constantly, it smells vaguely of exhaust, it moves forward on its own when I release the brakes, and it doesn't slow down much when I release the accelerator.

There is also the time factor. Stopping at the gas station costs time, oil changes cost time, etc. I had to refill the windshield washer fluid a few days ago, and the tires need to be rotated occasionally, but that's about it so far.

It is true that EVs depreciate quickly, but for someone like me, who intends to drive it until the wheels come off, that's of little concern. Also, due to the battery's thermal management, I have not observed any meaningful loss in average range yet (though I did receive the battery replacement recall a few years into my ownership, so the battery is only ~5 years old).

Your mileage may vary, as they say.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by variaga on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:03PM (#43093709)
I have a 1.5-year old VW id.4.

I cosign all of this (except the one-pedal driving - I prefer to leave mine in separate accel+brake mode), particularly the home charging - if you can get a home charger installed, it is a real game-changer. As compared to my previous (ICE) car, I never have to leave early because I'm low on gas & need to stop and fill up (or even have to go out of my way to fill up) and day-to-day I have less range anxiety with my EV because I always leave the house with a full charge.

After the one-time expense of getting a charger installed it's both cheaper and more pleasant to operate than my old ICE.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by the_gastropod on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:24PM (#43093911)
I don't have a garage, and the whole "getting a charger installed" thing was a bit of a deterrent for me getting an EV. But after getting one, I've realized Level 1 charging on a standard 110V outlet is more than sufficient for my needs. On the Bolt, you add ~4 miles per hour of charging. So if you drive, on average, under ~50 miles per day (which most Americans do), a level 1 charger should easily handle your needs.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by nomel on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:00PM (#43098072)
"Installing" a charger is just plugging it into the standard 240V outlet, maybe with a screw in the wall to hold it up. The cost is getting the outlet wired, with a possible upgrade to the panel. Some dishonest electricians have "charger installation" as a much higher price.

I went with a fancy Wallbox charger at first, which promptly burnt out and was a general connection disaster, replacing it with a more consistent $60 Amazon charger. They're glorified relays, with a pulse train (no computer required) that is used to set/modulate car side power draw [1].

[1] https://www.picoauto.com/library/automotive-guided-tests/cha...

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by natch on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:47PM (#43096637)
Generally speaking nobody needs a charger installed. A good three prong 110 outlet is sufficient. We found one single 110 outlet sufficient for two cars for two years with around town driving, having outside fast chargers as a backup if needed for longer trip days. One. And a 220 outlet is vastly, way beyond, sufficient for three cars. No charger. Just an outlet and a cable.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by gottorf on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @08:40PM (#43097553)
From what I've seen of EVs currently on the market, level 1 charging (standard 15-amp 120V outlet) adds 2-5 miles of range per hour. For a typical commuter who returns home at 6pm and leaves home at 7am, that allows for 13 hours or 26-65 miles of range charged overnight.

Apparently Americans drive an average of 42 miles a day[0], and I'd wager that EV owners tend to be in higher-density areas with shorter commutes, so that may be enough.

In my personal case, living in a small metro area in a state that's middle of the pack in terms of population density, my ideal would be a small EV for putzing around town (which is conservatively speaking 95% of the occasions that I get behind the wheel), and a larger gasoline car for road trips. Of course, everyone's mileage (heh) will vary.

[0]: https://www.axios.com/2024/03/24/average-commute-distance-us...

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by cozzyd on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:08PM (#43098121)
You can always rent a car for road trips. Yes it's not super cheap but cheaper than keeping another car around, depending on your rate of road trips. It's what I do (but I don't own any cars at all, so it's somewhat more expensive for me to rent since I need to purchase supplemental liability insurance).
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by natch on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:54AM (#43099041)
Why rent a car when your regular car is safer, cheaper, and more fun? I’ve never had to rent a car as an EV owner and I’ve covered a lot of ground in a lot of states.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:57PM (#43098048)
Would a plug-in hybrid be able to satisfy both needs?
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by chipsa on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @10:08PM (#43098123)
My wife drives a i3 Rex, which is a plugin hybrid. We’ve taken it on a 6 hour road trip before. It was doable, though I’ll admit it wasn’t the best hybrid for a road trip.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by coldtea on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:47AM (#43099700)
Wasn't the best?

People have been taking multi-day roadtrips with a Yugo or a Fiat Mini.

An i3 Rex for just a 6 hour road trip? Hell, i3 would tackle a 6 hour daily commute just fine...

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by natch on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:53AM (#43099026)
Even if a 110 won’t quite do it for some people’s amount of driving, 220 will generally provide more than enough. No charger unit installation needed in either case. So thanks for the wager, but the point stands.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by dzhiurgis on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:06PM (#43097732)
I've just found out there's a provider that gives out 3 hours of free power (3-6AM). I'll be installing faster charger soon - it will easily cover 60% of my usage.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by ern on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:56PM (#43096722)
I have a 240v wall outlet that charges at 1.5kW and it's more than adequate 95%+ of the time.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by nomel on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:53PM (#43098025)
240V is level 2 and should handle > 6kW. It's nice for the weekends, for a charge during lunch before heading out. I've done that maybe twice.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by ern on Friday February 21, 2025 @03:20AM (#43125292)
Depends on the country. Outside of North America, 240v is L1.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by ineedasername on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @09:48AM (#43102689)
All of this talk of having to stop for gas instead of charging passively at each place you go sounds really strange.

I really like EV’s, but the longer stop times for when you do need to recharge a bit when you’re out are reasonable balanced against faster gas station stops especially outside of higher density infrastructure suburban/urban areas. The above sorts of comments ring in my ears along these lines:

“Oh that 7 minutes of checking my email while I refill my tank was horrible. Leaving the house so much earlier if I hadn’t done it the day before was truly oppressive. And these days I luxuriate in those rare gifted 20 minutes of leisure when I choose to recharge my battery while on the go!”

The range-recharge vs. gas station stops argument really seems pretty evenly balanced unless you don’t live where there is much charging infrastructure.

Personally, my dream balance would be something that could go 50 miles on a charge but had an ICE tank that could take me 150-200 miles. That EV capacity would cover 95% of driving, and for most people I know without long commutes, and the other 5% would just mean I had to fuel up on both ends of a 3-4 hour drive instead of just once. Or every 3-4 hours instead of 6-8 of the extremely rare longer drives. Also for those, I’d have the 50mile EV range as backup for running out of gas, not to mention a massive mobile power bank to keep heat & phone battery going if I had a breakdown somewhere.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by asoneth on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @11:42AM (#43104163)
> “Oh that 7 minutes of checking my email while I refill my tank was horrible. Leaving the house so much earlier if I hadn’t done it the day before was truly oppressive. And these days I luxuriate in those rare gifted 20 minutes of leisure when I choose to recharge my battery while on the go!”

Please avoid strawman arguments.

If you're truly curious why some people prefer longer electric charging stops on road trips to shorter bi-weekly gas station stops:

Even when not strictly necessary for refueling, my family takes a ~10 minute break after every ~4 hours of driving to let everyone stretch and use a restroom. No one has objected to extending these stops to ~15 minutes when we take the EV. The primary inconvenience has been that it has constrained where we stop, as many of our old stops do not have charging infrastructure.

Whereas a refueling stop during a shorter trip (including running errands or during a daily commute) introduces an entirely new stop that serves no additional purpose.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by ineedasername on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:42PM (#43104948)
There is a difference between a straw man and satire presented in a clear tone that cannot be mistaken as a reconstruction of the other person’s statements.

A clearer straw man is the presentation of leaving a location a sparse few minutes earlier as significant cause and disproportionate offset of the also negligible time to pull a cable to a car to plug it in & briefly wrap & tuck it away when you leave.

I also clearly do understand that people may not mind a longer stop: I didn’t contradict that sentiment directly and otherwise expressly stated the opinion that each option seems to have somewhat equal offsetting considerations.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by asoneth on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:32PM (#43105582)
> There is a difference between a straw man and satire presented in a clear tone that cannot be mistaken as a reconstruction of the other person’s statements.

You are correct, my apologies. However, it's unclear to me how satire is any more useful a contribution to this discussion.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by ineedasername on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:32PM (#43107253)
I think there is potential for useful satire in nearly any conversation where teasing out nuances of opinion and meaning are also useful. It serves as a tool for highlighting and contrast by virtue of extremes or absurdity or surfacing of illogical reasoning.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by genewitch on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:31PM (#43109169)
I was fine with the comment you are complaining about. Not everything is factional
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by JackMorgan on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:21AM (#43138766)
As someone who takes several long road trips a year, it's wild to hear about only 10 minute breaks every four hours.

My wife and I often do at least a ten minute break every 90 minutes! The idea of just grinding on and on for hours feels like torture. My car forcing frequent stops to charge sounds great! I'd go for a nice walk, maybe find a local eatery.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by eckesicle on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:56PM (#43094996)
I’ve also got an EV and I love it.

I installed solar panels at home and the car is now pretty much completely free to drive during those summer months where I get enough sun to supply my house and the car. I think these panels had an ROI of around 4 years for me, which is crazy good.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by chad_c on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:52PM (#43096677)
What panels do you have? Do you have energy storage as well?
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by the_gastropod on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:56PM (#43093630)
I picked up a second-hand Bolt a few months ago, and couldn't agree more. It's such an underrated car. I paid $13k for a 2023 base model. Couldn't be happier with it.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by vannevar on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @06:55PM (#43096708)
The Bolt is far and away the best value EV on the used market, it's crazy that you can get a thermally managed battery and 250 miles of range for under $15k.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by vondur on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @07:05PM (#43096808)
I was looking at one; they are really cheap. I seen some 2 year old models for less than 20k with sub 40k miles. My wife ended up getting a new Subaru Outback so I took over her older Subaru Crosstrek Plugin Hybrid, which allows me to get to work on less than one charge.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by Marsymars on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @09:26PM (#43097865)
> it doesn't slow down much when I release the accelerator.

This is mostly personal preference. I’d preferentially have auto-regenerative-braking entirely disabled - I’ve already internalized a driving style with efficient coasting where auto-regen wastes more energy.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by DamnInteresting on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:12AM (#43098808)
> This is mostly personal preference

For sure! I basically went directly from manual transmission to EV, so I was already accustomed to using the drivetrain to slow the vehicle when not accelerating. For me, one-pedal EV driving feels like a natural progression from the manual lifestyle.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by justinrubek on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @09:45AM (#43102653)
I was a big coasting driver before having an EV. I will admit I miss it slightly for how it feels. However, I don't find this to be genuine. Regenerative braking wastes more energy? That doesn't really add up if you're doing it correctly.

Also, for every one of us coasting drivers there are many, many, many others that accelerate all the way to the light and slam on the breaks. I see it constantly and remember because it almost always slows down traffic.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by planckscnst on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @10:58AM (#43103500)
Yes, it feels wasteful compared to my previous driving, in specific circumstances. I drove a manual transmission and made it a goal to not touch the brakes at all for red lights (given acceptable traffic conditions - sometimes people would just be annoyed or confused if I did it every time). I'd see the light from far back, understand its timing, and how many cars were stopped behind it and gauge when I should disengage the clutch and coast. It frequently worked out that I was arriving at the stopped car in front of me just as they were starting to move forward. It feels particularly satisfying not to lose all your momentum just to have to accelerate again from a dead stop.

Overall, however, regenerative braking probably is better given the conditions don't always allow for this game.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by terribleperson on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:21PM (#43109062)
I think this is a solvable problem with a control alteration. There should be a zone right at the start of pushing down the accelerator pedal that is "don't brake without brake input, but don't accelerate"
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by Marsymars on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:57PM (#43109400)
> Regenerative braking wastes more energy?

Not regen braking per se, but the lack of ability to coast. Often it's optimally efficient to coast without any acceleration or braking before you brake.

i.e. Braking turns your kinetic energy into heat energy. Regenerative braking brings that penalty down by a lot (70%, or whatever), but efficiency-wise, you're still best off to minimize braking. (Insofar as minimizing braking isn't offset by travelling at a less efficient speed.)

To be clear, I'm not opposed to regenerative braking - I just don't like single-pedal driving.

Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by afiori on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:22PM (#43117508)
Another issue is that regenerative braking does not light up your braking indicator lights, so can be more dangerous
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by sliken on Monday February 24, 2025 @03:59PM (#43164871)
Teslas turn on the brake lights when regeneratively braking.
Re:Are Electric Cars That Much Cheaper to Operate Than ICE? by r00fus on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:29PM (#43104765)
Some Non-Tesla EVs support zero regen. In fact my Kia has steering wheel paddles so you can easily switch modes and it handles defaults nicely.