News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by drhowarddrfine on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:13AM (#430514)
No one wants to install yet another unused technology (Silverlight) for an unknown new product.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by stormideas on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:34AM (#430548)
I took the decision to develop using Silverlight becuase I've got a strong background in using the Microsoft stack for development, wanted to get in on the ground floor with a new technology and follow it as it matures and becuase I wanted to (try!) to produce a richer user experience within the browser.

As I said, I understand that this is going to be a limiting factor in some regards, but I couldn't have built what I did in any other technology (that's not to say that someone else couldn't have, just for my particular circumstances).

I'm hopeful that as Silverlight adoption increases this will become less of a problem, I'm also hopeful that colaab may act as a showcase for my Silverlight abilities and lead to further contract work, which in turn can help to fund product development.

Thanks for the feedback!

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by mattmaroon on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:20AM (#430609)
Silverlight will be bundled into all versions of Windows from now on so you won't have to worry about adoption.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:23AM (#430618)
Will that work in firefox/safari/opera on windows?

Also, the web isn't composed of windows machines. It's a mishmash of a billion different devices. The vast majority of which, know html, javascript, and not much else. Seems a bad idea to only write for a small subset of them.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by Angostura on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:49AM (#430677)
Well, I'm a Mac user running Safari. Do I mind installing a free plug-in to get access to an interesting app? No.

I don't see where you (necessarily) get "small subset" from.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @12:15PM (#430731)
You don't mind potentially making safari crash more? You don't mind adding to complexity, disk space used, memory usage, potential vulnerabilities?

I do. The less "installed" software I have to go wrong, the better.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by Angostura on Monday January 12, 2009 @03:24PM (#431069)
I don't mind making Safari 'potentially crash more' - I only mind if it actually does crash more. Since Safari crashes are very few and far between, and haven't noticeably increased since I installed Silverlight some time ago, this potential problem isn't high on my list of priorities.

I suppose I can always go back to Lynx if these things really bother me too much.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by cosmo7 on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:52AM (#430683)
I've used Silverlight on Firefox (Vista, Windows 7) with no problems, not even having to restart the browser.

Silverlight is actually pretty good; it's a much easier experience for developers than Flash/Flex. You might hate Microsoft, but you shouldn't hate the tech.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by chaostheory on Monday January 12, 2009 @01:02PM (#430815)
it's hard not to hate the tech when historically MS makes their stuff ignore standards and evolve into something for Windows only.

Adobe, while not perfect itself, has been committed to keeping Flash cross platform. This makes Flash harder to hate than Silverlight despite the high cost of developer tools

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by mattmaroon on Monday January 12, 2009 @07:32PM (#431403)
IE is still 70% of traffic. So, if you write something in Silverlight, and IE maintains that, you're going to work in 70% + however many non-IE clients have Silverlight or are willing to get it.

That will be most everyone. People will do just about anything you ask them to. The prevalence of phishing has proven that. They'll put their online banking creds into any site that has bankofamerica somewhere in the domain name. They'll buy Viagra from an anonymous email through a Costa Rican pharmacy. They'll most certainly click the button that says "Install Silverlight from Microsoft to watch the video".

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by anamax on Monday January 12, 2009 @06:11PM (#431298)
If using Silverlight helps you do things that would have been harder otherwise, great.

But the other reasons are silly unless someone is paying you to increase Silverlight usage.

The difference between a biz and a hobby is that biz try hard to avoid doing things that don't help the bottom line.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by ttrashh on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:50AM (#430574)
Where do you live? I'll hire you ;)
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by andr on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:38AM (#430553)
It takes a few startups to jump in and push Silverlight into popularity. IMHO, it is a better and more open RIA technology than Flash, so I'm happy to see it used! (Although, you don't have to use it everywhere. The signup form didn't need it, for example).
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by mattmaroon on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:21AM (#430612)
It only takes MS bundling it to make it popular on the client end.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by stormideas on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:42AM (#430562)
Aha, yes. I got a bit carried away there. Currently redeveloping in ASP.NET MVC as a more standard web form!
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by halo on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:12AM (#430594)
>IMHO, it is a better and more open RIA technology than Flash

A lesser evil is still an evil.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by andr on Monday January 12, 2009 @04:34PM (#431183)
What does that even mean?
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by halo on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @10:19AM (#432097)
Silverlight being better than Flash doesn't logically conclude to making Silverlight a good idea and deserving of support. A lesser evil is still an evil.

I consider the fact that Flash is pretty terrible a feature, as at least is helps discourage people from only using it in places where it's absolutely essential. I firmly believe RIAs are a fundamentally bad idea and the quicker they are replaced with open standards the better.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:37AM (#430550)
Interestingly, I have silverlight installed on my macbook (Until later today probably when I uninstall it).

The reason being, earlier this month I bought an xbox360 (There is no choice, be stupid and spend a ton on a ps3 with its ridiculous bluray, or be stupid and spend less on an xbo360).... I bought the lips game, and went to lips.com to see what songs you can buy. It requires silverlight... for a list of songs. I installed it reluctantly, and in the most hideously badly rendered font you can imagine, it said "Song list coming soon".

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by pclark on Monday January 12, 2009 @10:16AM (#430521)
well I just did, so erm, yeah.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:22AM (#430616)
I believe in this case, "no one" = most people. You apparently aren't most people.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by pclark on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:45AM (#430664)
so if you found a great application that perfectly matched your needs, you wouldn't use it purely because it required installing software on your computer?
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by staunch on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:49AM (#430678)
The real scenario is: Two companies make similar software that fulfills your need. One requires a download and the other doesn't. Who wins?
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by pclark on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:50AM (#430680)
the one thats cheaper
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by staunch on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:53AM (#430684)
Take "similar software" to mean all things being roughly equivalent, including price. Jeez.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @12:20PM (#430736)
That's also untrue. If one was cheaper, but required me to install some desktop software, I'd happily pay the extra to have the better solution.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by cmos on Monday January 12, 2009 @02:34PM (#430975)
I'm pretty sure I had to download silverlight to watch netflix movies on my Mac.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by stormideas on Monday January 12, 2009 @02:55PM (#431020)
Netflix are using Silverlight for their streaming service, see http://netflix.mediaroom.com/index.php?s=43&item=288 for details.
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by staunch on Tuesday January 13, 2009 @06:47PM (#432930)
Not a good example. Netflix would have chosen Flash probably if it wasn't for a special deal with Microsoft. They traded something in exchange for choosing an inferior solution (inferior in that it requires a download).
Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @12:18PM (#430734)
Yes. I'm betting against installable software.

The whole point of a collaboration type app, is that you can use it from anywhere - your laptop, desktop, iphone, nokia, netbook, internet cafe, library, wii, etc etc

Requiring a user install some software negates the whole point for me.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by stormideas on Monday January 12, 2009 @12:25PM (#430749)
I'm also betting against installable software (Silverlight plugins excepted!). You just need to look at Joost's traffic since they went web-based rather than desktop client:

http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/01/08/joost-has-a-heartbeat/

I'm hopefull that over the coming months / years Microsoft manage to get Silverlight out there and available on as many platforms as possible, allowing me to write applications that can take advantage of that reach.

In the meantime the aim is to start building up enough user numbers to create a viable business, I've got very low overheads and no debt so hopefully that can come from the existing Silverlight install base + people who are willing to install it if they think the application will do a job for them.

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by axod on Monday January 12, 2009 @12:57PM (#430801)
Sure, what I could see of the app, and design looked very good. So congrats on that.

Good luck with it :)

Re:Ask HN: Review my startup, colaab - A Silverlight 2 RIA f... by Angostura on Monday January 12, 2009 @11:51AM (#430681)
I believe in this case "most people" = some people.