This.
Microsoft today is still one of the world's biggest companies, with a lot of talented people and considerable inlets into practically every home and office in the developed world. Apple of yesterday grew to eclipse Microsoft in a matter of years--there's no reason Microsoft can't pull off a similar reversal with the right maneuvering of its own considerable resources.
When Apple bought NeXT, Steve Jobs had a tight cadre of very talented people who he trusted greatly. It was basically his invasion force. Apple at that point was in crisis, and wasn't particularly big. Market cap: $2 billion. Revenue $7 billion, down from $11 billion two years before. Employees, 9,300. They were doing basically one thing, selling computers, and they were obviously fucking it up.
Microsoft is much larger ($250 billion market cap, 92,000 employees), and they're still fat and sassy on their monopoly rents from Windows and Office. Few there feel any reason to change. The company is so much larger than Apple was that just getting a handle on it is a massive task. Actually turning it around is a very tall order.
Even though Apple was much smaller, it was something like 7 years before things really started to take off. Even if somebody could turn Microsoft around as quickly, how will they get the board and the investors to sit still for such a long period? Jobs could do it because Apple was his baby and Jobs was Jobs. But who has the mojo to do it with Microsoft?
A much more likely path is the one Yahoo is on: slow decline plus musical CEOs as a variety of highly paid people rearrange deck chairs over and over.
I guess at IBM is was obvious things had to change - it might take a while before MS gets to that point.
Also, talking about what Microsoft might do in the future, doesn't magically erase the financial and business criticism of the past. If anything, past performance is a better indicator than "if XYZ can turn around, so can we". Momentum is huge.
As for Microsoft having "positions in all the right places". They have an amazingly strong position in two massive markets. Again, lost decade refers to growth and decline, and unfortunately for Microsoft, neither of these markets is seeing nearly as much growth as other markets. No one is saying that Microsoft isn't making a fortune on desktop and enterprise sales, they are saying that they are failing to capture key markets, such as mobile and tablets. In some markets, like internet or entertainment, their market share isn't horrible, but it's costing them a fortune.
In short, Microsoft's stock price is horrible. If Microsoft thinks the stock is undervalued, they should be buying it back. They are insignificant in a number of important markets, and in those markets where they are a player (but not a leader), they tend to be losing massive amounts of money.
I think that to say that Microsoft has the chance to retake Apple with the direction they're taking misses the core reason why Apple has become so big. Apple didn't build their company back up through competition, but through creation. That's not a statement saying that Apple was in their own bubble and not taking massive amounts of inspiration from others. It is saying that they as a company defined the market, leaving companies like Microsoft at a step behind no matter what. It's like Apple joining the gaming console market. Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony would have way too much of a lead to make it easy, and if they focus on developed markets they are going to be constantly fighting to keep up instead of pushing the fight forward.
So's IBM, but who, today, decides not to enter a field because they fear IBM will crush them like MSFT crushed Netscape?
BTW, who has MSFT crushed recently?
Would you happen to have any data to support this? In my world, Microsoft dominates both ends, by a very large margin.
Microsoft has positions in all the right places. They were in tablets, phones, and other devices early. However, the execution was poor. They did have a good shot at emerging tech markets and they still do.
Microsoft still dominates business/enterprise. Apple, the consumer end.
Microsoft is just being displaced. They have a limited time to respond before it really starts to erode their profits.