A more plausible explanation is that the Republicans were able to persuade many Americans that the economic problems caused by the pandemic were the fault of the Democrats. Blaming the other side for historical accident is a tried-and-true campaign strategy, and the pandemic provided a perfect opportunity to put it to use for 2024.
Wasn't one of the main points — perhaps the main point — of the article that the data is measured wrong?
> You act like they’re quoting abstract numbers which are meaningless compared to people’s “lived experience” but unemployment is a large part of people’s experience.
Yeah, and the article was in large part about how the unemployment measures in the data don't reflect what people’s lived experience of unemployment is. That's pretty much the definition of “abstract numbers which are meaningless”.
> Furthermore, inflation adjusted wages are up (with the highest gains in the lowest 50% of earners).
Again, that depends very much on how you measure inflation.
> If these statistics aren’t fully capturing people’s experiences, I’m sure every economist in the world would love to know what metrics are better.
That may be the reason the article suggested some new metrics. Honestly, did you even read it at all?
Supporting links as to why Politico would do something like this:
https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/01/06/axel-springer-politico-...
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/politico...
The fact is every unemplpyment metric you look at is at a historical low. So regardless of what they are or aren't capturing they are all better than they've been in decades. In relative terms the economy has been doing well.
The difference is two thing. In 2020 half the world shut down and it caused inflation. Our inflation was also much better handled than most of the developed world. And number two, there is a very strong echo chamber that wanted to convince they country the economy was bad, and they were successful.
I'll have to find the link, but there was a reputable poll right around the election that asked people in all the swing states how the economy was doing. They all rated it poorly. They then asked how the economy was doing in their state, they all rated it well.
Voters in every swing state saw up front with their own eyes the economy was doing well in their states and said so in the poll, but were sure the economy was doing poorly because of what they heard about all the other states. Mission accomplished for the echo-chamber.