News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:13PM (#42979390)
Tried it for 3 months, noticed zero difference, and stopped.

Now, do you know anything new? No, because anecdotes don’t actually provide meaningful information, we don’t know why we did or didn’t improve. Or in my case if there was some minor benefit or minor harm because I didn’t pay close enough attention etc etc.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by meowkit on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:37PM (#42979530)
Anecdotal results are highly dependent on the provider.

The scientific method is supposed to allow someone with no credibility to provide signal through >process< and then gain credibility.

Anecdotes from >a credible< person are very meaningful as they are often a high indicator of signal. A social heuristic outside of rigorous research.

Your results as an anon? Basically useless. On HN? Slightly better than on reddit or facebook. Provide your methodology? Better still, and now youre approaching a research proposal.

The meta discussion around anecdata being useful or not is silly.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:08PM (#42979697)
If you want the protocol? Sure water temp 50-55f for 15 minutes 4-6 days a week (generally 5) for 3 months. Water chest height, arms generally above water.

How exactly does credibility matter here? Science is heavily reputation based because there’s so much at stake and so few experiments take place, but with anecdotal evidence I don’t see the credibility of individual datapoints mattering much.

I can’t tell if I minimally influenced my upper respiratory tract infection risk etc, all I can tell is the hassle wasn’t worth a benefit too small for me to notice. And that’s the issue, more than credibility if effect size was large enough to be noticeable to individuals you’d get extremely strong results from scientific studies. Conversely if it isn’t showing up as extremely effective in the literature that’s strong evidence individuals are misattributing their experiences.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by implmntatio on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:32PM (#42979829)
how often did you get sick? weight? what season did you do it in?

what was your goal in the first place?

> you’d get extremely strong results from scientific studies

check population health data in countries where cold exposure is traditional.

science is cool, scientists are just regular ol' people and enough regular ol' people do a lot to look good, to not be unemployed and having to write applications again, to get their tap on the head and or a nice bonus. **regular in their little slices under the bell curve

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by hsuduebc2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:01PM (#42979978)
It's strange to question the work of scientists in this way. Precisely because they are only human the studies are peer reviewed and the meta studies have the most explanatory value and weight.

Unless you are assuming there is some global conspiracy of scientists to have jobs the system it selfs manages it by it's transparency.

Simplifying it in a "check population health data in countries where cold exposure is traditional" way is exactly the wrong approach. How do you know what kind of diet, genome and culture they have? There are so many variables that the mere fact of whether one diverse group does something different than another doesn't really say anything. It's so difficult to try to isolate individual problems. That's why we have the scientists.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by d-k-blackthorn on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:47PM (#42980197)
Don’t both things have value, when measured on different axes?

I think it’s just a bit more gray.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by ninetyninenine on Saturday February 08, 2025 @03:49AM (#42981528)
You haven't heard of the replication crisis?
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by hsuduebc2 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @07:42AM (#42982574)
Not till now. Thanks. But as weird as it can sounds. The failing and iterationg over and over is integral part of science. Which includes method itself.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by ninetyninenine on Saturday February 08, 2025 @12:47PM (#42984624)
The "method" was never fixed. It was identified but we have no way of correcting it. A ton of science is still completely dubious.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Saturday February 08, 2025 @08:28AM (#42982820)
> check population health data in countries where cold exposure is traditional.

That tells you about those countries but very little about cold exposure specifically. One inherent difference is they lack a lot of tropical diseases because they aren’t in the tropics. You could still try and remove all those differences, but directly studying cold exposure itself is vastly more practical.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by yowayb on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:12PM (#42979717)
There are many things (I frankly don't think there's a more specific word for this) like diets and psychedelics where many of us (rigorously minded) are constantly seeking proofs within systems containing sufficient complexity to render conclusions nearly impossible.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by bcoates on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:50PM (#42979925)
Diet interventions aren't terribly hard to test, they just consistently tend to result in "as bad or worse than no intervention" (short of fixing the sort of malnutrition you rarely see in the contemporary developed world)

The rigorous result is right in front of us we just don't like the answer

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by implmntatio on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:33PM (#42979834)
> constantly seeking proofs within systems containing sufficient complexity to render conclusions nearly impossible

Language. Nothing is impossible.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by m3kw9 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:41PM (#42979868)
I tried it for 20 seconds that was it
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by hollerith on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:44PM (#42979887)
All five merchants who went to Opal City were never seen again, but don't let that stop you from going to Opal City because anecdotes don’t actually provide meaningful information.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by ambicapter on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:46PM (#42979897)
if cold plunges either killed people or revived them from the dead, this would be a great analogy.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:02PM (#42979983)
Another low stake option. 5 of your friends each say that restaurant A is horrible and restaurant B was great. You have to pick a restaurant. Are you going to throw dice because these are just anecdotes and don't matter?
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:28PM (#42980105)
Carful, now you’re leaving random antidotes.

A specific restaurant is an actual place so if someone describes the decor and prices yesterday it’s not going to be wildly different when you show up tomorrow.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @10:08AM (#42983411)
Is there a paper supporting that position of yours? I would like to see a study highlighting that restaurants are unlikely to change in time.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by hollerith on Saturday February 08, 2025 @10:39AM (#42983640)
I'm not eating anything till I see a peer-reviewed study demonstrating that the verbal reports about restaurant decor made by my family members or the guys I ride bikes with on weekends have any actual correlation with actual restaurant decor. Where is the hard, non-anecdotal evidence?
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @11:19AM (#42983981)
It also needs evaluation beyond subjective reports, as food taste is known to be highly prone to placebo. Until an objective device for evaluating the taste is found I believe it would be completely unscientific to take a bite or even smell the food since that is also known to affect taste.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:00PM (#42979972)
Should you also not ask for restaurant recommendations from people? These are also anecdotes.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:31PM (#42980117)
When someone records the height of a specific mountain we call that a measurement not an anecdote.

If I ask someone if this bar is good, and they say they went to a different unrelated bar and it sucked then I’m going to ignore that as a random anecdote.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @09:08AM (#42983034)
What about if someone says that they felt a sauna session was good for them, or cold plunge benefited their health, etc?
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Saturday February 08, 2025 @11:17AM (#42983963)
I know far too many aging hippies and their kids who believe all kinds of nonsense to really care what kind of health claims they’re making. I just tune out.

One guy was saying you can replace sleep with LSD. He changed his mind, but would you believe it or just do what I did smile nod and move on?

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @11:32AM (#42984099)
I wouldn't believe that, but there are plenty of other activities that I do because people have anecdotally reported that they benefitted from them. In this case I would use my internal judgment and intuition to decide based on benefits vs cost/risk. Does it seem unlikely to harm me, but many people have suggested they benefit from it? Sure, I will try it. I will see if I feel better or notice anything. If I don't, that's fine. If I do, I wouldn't necessarily know if it is beyond placebo or not, but I could keep doing it to see how it affects my life and if it keeps seemingly positive I can decide to keep doing it even though I don't have scientifically unquestionable truth that it is actually helping me. People have survived generations and found things that work without needing everything to be scientifically verified.
Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Saturday February 08, 2025 @02:48PM (#42985636)
When tested the overwhelming majority of things that “survived generations” didn’t work.

It’s amazing just how bad that stuff turned out to be. You personally can try whatever you feel like but the odds are just terrible that your going to find anything beyond mild pain relief and the risks can be go significantly beyond wasting time.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by mewpmewp2 on Saturday February 08, 2025 @06:03PM (#42986963)
How do you pick the set from where you are picking the "overwhelming majority"?

I would argue that most things we use daily now started out as anecdotes rather than science experiments. Most of the food we eat, etc. The buildings we live in, being in the nature, exercise, sleep, etc.

They were all anecdotally described before we were able to run proper science on them.

Re:Effects of cold-water immersion on health and wellbeing: ... by Retric on Saturday February 08, 2025 @07:50PM (#42987526)
> most things we use daily

Moving the goalposts a bit there, there’s no way in which wood’s utility depends on random peoples observations they can point to its actual use in a structure. We’re just talking about medicine here.

So the set includes all forms of historically practiced medicine from anywhere in the globe. From Chinese medicine to Voodoo, people did all kinds of things to dry to get better. Our ancestors didn’t use electronics, plastics, synthetic fibers, aluminum, etc which is a large fraction of what people interact with in a daily basis.

Western medicine kept a tiny fraction native from wound care via Honey to willow bark, the stuff that worked was either copied or refined when active ingredients were isolated. But when the actual useful techniques are under 1%, there’s hardly a reason for you to individually investigate people’s random claims.

Consider all of homeopathy is useless, for you to say test each individual treatment would be just as silly as individually testing each different prayer in faith healing.