Hint: I might need to google the authors of the study, I don't need to google Richard Feynman...
And, to be honest, there's a reason why there are memes about physicists' competence in other fields, like https://xkcd.com/793/.
I'm very aware of the "spherical cow" joke about physicists, but this isn't a "random celebrity".
Seriously, if you are at all interested in physics - read the lectures and they will, with 100% certainty, deepen your understanding. Even on the most fundamental topics. For instance my entire worldview around the conversation laws changed thanks to those lectures, which in turn ties directly into the nature of energy.
[1] - https://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/info/popular_misconc...
In support of 793 however, he didn't do well with bureaucracy so I'd not listen to his advice on how to run something that favored rigorous rule following even when the rules don't make sense**.
* https://www.commoncraft.com/honor-richard-feynman-great-expl...
** https://laurakornish.com/2019/04/no-joking-matter-feynman-on...
My friend that is the textbook definition of celebrity status.
To use such word with regard to one of the most talented and innovative physicists of the 20th century debases the entire conversation.
If my eyes rolled back any further in my head I could look into the past.
But you've proven your own point: you know him because he's known but because you're actually familiar with his work.
So again: textbook celebrity worship masquerading as intellectualism.
I cannot parse your statement, either there are some missing words, or some problem with your English.
Anyway, from my previous comment, you couldn't have any idea about how I got to know Feynman and his work. I haven't mentioned it at all.
FYI, I got acquainted with his work in 1996 when I enrolled into the university. I was studying maths, my dormitory roommate was studying theoretical physics, and he had several Feynman's books that were very interesting to me, though I must admit that sometimes the underlying apparatus was really complicated for an 18 y.o. greenhorn. But the principles were clear enough.
Let's see
1. The personal experiences of a guy with no formal training in pedagogy or education
2. A research paper in nature written by expert education economists
Hmmmmmmmm
0. The Kardashians
The distance between 0 and 1 is vast compared to the distance between 1 and 2. Feynman was a professor and also beloved for his ability to bridge across the academic to pragmatic divide that is the subject of this paper.
I should, perhaps, have used:
0. Average person
It's amazing how deep the celebrity worship goes. No he's famous for being a mathematical physicist (his Nobel is in physics not education). He was actually a very mediocre educator - you can read his own assessments of his success/failure in teaching the "famous" intro courses.
Or you can ask literally any physics major that's actually had to use those books (they are horrible for actually learning from).
Just because a particular department or field of study exists in academia does not magically give them the imprimatur you think it does.
* Btw, I know for a fact that a few of them are not "education economists"
I'm glad we've arrived at Fox News level takes. At least we can all admit what we are here.
Unfortunately it destroyed your argument.
Nobody's quoting Feynman "as a counterpoint to actual authorities". Feynman's excerpt provides first-hand testimony from a teacher on the front lines that fully validates what the study found.
The paper's abstract ends, "These findings highlight the importance of educational curricula that bridge the gap between intuitive and formal maths." The Feynman excerpt is about the issues caused by a lack of practica in education and how they should be resolved.
The paper's authors wrote, "These findings call for a maths pedagogy that explicitly addresses these translational challenges through curricula that connect abstract maths symbols and concepts to intuitively meaningful contexts and problems." And provide 2 examples of Randomized Control Trials of math courses in Brazil and India respectively that address the challenges successfully.
Even if you remove Feynman's name, it's still interesting that a Theoretical Physics professor and educator wrote clearly about a very similar issue they encountered over 60 years before the paper in question was published.
Edit: hn is just as anti-intellectual as any other place these days but y'all style yourselves as intelligentsia because your celebrities are special.
I'll repeat: check out the qualifications of the authors of this study and compare them to Feynman's on this subject. Any reasonable person would conclude that comparing them is exactly like comparing Kim Kardashian and Feynman's on QED.