News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by defrost on Thursday February 06, 2025 @06:49PM (#42967689)
> suburbia is supposedly better for kids even though they have nothing to do and rely on their parents to be driven to every activity.

That's a USofAian "suburb" .. not a well designed suburb.

There are many types of "dense", ranging from all skyscrapers, through (say) dense row housing with much open space, to big single house blocks everywhere (arguably the worst form).

Elsewhere in the world suburbs are surrounded by green belts and have embedded parks, footpaths and cycleways, shops, etc that are reachable without cars.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by mhandley on Thursday February 06, 2025 @07:35PM (#42968006)
I live in SW London. It's definitely suburbia, but the density is just about perfect, at least as I see it. Since about age 11 my kids were fairly free range - they could hang about outside with their friends (the street is very quiet, and there's a green space opposite), cycle to their friends, or use the frequent buses and trains, though we'd drive and pick them up if they were out late. Most weeks though, my car doesn't move Monday to Friday - I cycle to the station. There's plenty of green space around, and sailing and kayaking on the River Thames. But the good public transport and ability to cycle all around only really works because housing density is high. We have a four floor town house, so plenty of floor area but a fairly small garden. When we moved here, I thought it would be for just a few years, until we could afford somewhere with more land. Living previously in California, Massachusetts and elsewhere in the UK, it wasn't really my image of an ideal place. But we've been here 20 years and although I could afford to move anywhere now, I don't want to. I'm happy here. My neighbours are my friends, everyone knows everyone else, and I feel no need to try and impress anyone with how much land I have. Anyway, my point is that there probably is an optimal density for cities, and some European cities probably come close to that optimal.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Thursday February 06, 2025 @06:52PM (#42967712)
> That's a USofAian "suburb" .

Better to just say 'American', FYI. It's much clearer and the ambiguity you are trying to avoid doesn't exist.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by devilbunny on Thursday February 06, 2025 @10:58PM (#42969214)
I would guess some Latin American origins. They have a very persistent meme culture that is upset that, in English, when you say “American”, you mean “from the United States of America”. Whereas, at least in Spanish-speaking countries, they have a different mental model of the world’s landmasses and the entire western hemisphere is “America”. Not North or South as separate continents; it’s like being “European”. So, while in, say, Argentina, I might be careful to call myself “estadounidense” (my Spanish is poor, please forgive spelling and suffix errors), it’s really not an issue in our southern neighbor, which is the Estados Unidos Mexicanos (United Mexican States) so, “estadounidense” applies equally to them. And yes, I have spent time in Mexico City, and nobody got in my face for saying “soy Americano”. Most of the visitors are going to be from other parts of Mexico or from the US, with a significant minority of Canadians.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:50AM (#42969827)
> I would guess some Latin American origins.

It's generally white people thinking they are solving a problem, honestly. Even if some people don't like that 'America' tends to refer to the US rather than something general to the continent or one or both of the continents, it doesn't really matter - there is never any ambiguity. The contexts talking about something the US is doing vs the continents are pretty much always crystal clear.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by javier123454321 on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:45AM (#42973142)
> And yes, I have spent time in Mexico City, and nobody got in my face for saying “soy Americano”.

Oh but you can basically guarantee there's an inner eye roll everytime you call yourself Americano. Estadounidense works, as Estados Unidos Mexicanos is largely not in use, and Mexicano(a) is the prefered term.

It's not a different mental model, it's just a mis translation. In Spanish saying "soy Americano" translates to 'I am from the Americas'. That's why the preference is to just use Estadounidense. It effectively means that US people are wrong if they say 'soy Americano' in Spanish, and Latin Americans are wrong for saying 'I am American' is wrong in english.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by devilbunny on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:09PM (#42980021)
I can live with inner eye rolls when I fuck up their language if they can live with the inner eye rolls when they fuck up mine.

I'm even entirely open to gentle, friendly correction. I've gotten this in France; it was said with a smile, not a snarl, so I appreciated it.

Like I said, nobody got in my face about it.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by javier123454321 on Monday February 10, 2025 @02:48PM (#43004400)
You seem very worked up about this. Glad no one mentioned. Just letting you know it's a mistranslation.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by rmccue on Thursday February 06, 2025 @07:28PM (#42967960)
> That's a USofAian "suburb" .. not a well designed suburb.

If you don’t want to say “American”, you could use Usonian, a term coined by Lloyd Wright himself: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usonia

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by defrost on Thursday February 06, 2025 @07:35PM (#42968003)
I'm familiar with Wright's coinage, props for raising it!

I'm happy with US citizen, USian, USofAian, etc, I've used all of them since pre WWW Usenet days.

It's interesting how some like to regulate the language of others.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by scld on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:09PM (#42968180)
Society "regulating" the language of others is almost entirely how languages develop.

USofAian is almost unreadable and unrecognizable in text to the general public when compared with American.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by bombcar on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:14PM (#42968203)
And anyone else who might technically be called an American doesn’t want the name anyway.

“USian” could apply to Mexico as they’re the United States, too, and since they’re in America they could also be “USofAians”.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by defrost on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:18PM (#42968222)
> and since they’re in America they could also be “USofAians”.

That's a stretch, the country they live in is United Mexican States which doesn't abbreviate to USofA.

Mexico in short doesn't have the ambiguity of America.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Thursday February 06, 2025 @09:01PM (#42968475)
'America' doesn't have the ambiguity you talk of either, not in 99.99% of contexts.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by defrost on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:13PM (#42968197)
And yet in 40+ years I've yet to exchange text with anyone that didn't understand it.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Thursday February 06, 2025 @09:17PM (#42968569)
That you've been using it that long is pretty bizarre to me. I guess it was just a way to stand out? Express some personality with a bit of semantic flair? I get that.

And no, in answer to your deleted replies, I'm not American, just someone that doesn't like seeing ambiguity created unnecessarily or misinformation spread, but I see now you were doing it more for stylistic reasons.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by defrost on Thursday February 06, 2025 @10:20PM (#42968947)
> That you've been using it that long is pretty bizarre to me.

Obviously.

> I guess it was just a way to stand out?

No.

> Express some personality with a bit of semantic flair?

Again, no.

> I get that.

Do you have examples of semantic flair that you use to stand out?

> just someone that doesn't like seeing ambiguity created unnecessarily

What ambiguity? Which other citizens of which other country did you honestly think I was referring to?

> or misinformation spread,

What misinfomation? I honestly and in good faith have no idea what "misinformation" you are referring to.

> but I see now you were doing it more for stylistic reasons.

For the third time. No.

Stop trying to make your contextual PoV a thing Gretchen.

This is literally no more than a useful contraction of "United States of America citizen"

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:44AM (#42969799)
> Obviously.

Yup. Should be obvious most people would share my stance also.

> Again, no.

Hmm. So why, then?

> Do you have examples of semantic flair that you use to stand out?

I don't try to stand out by being contrarian or via other semantic scheming.

> What ambiguity?

> What misinfomation?

It's confusing to at the least ESL speakers who may think it is a reasonable way to refer to people from the US and it is misinformation to suggest it is.

> For the third time. No.

Hmm.

> Stop trying to make your contextual PoV a thing Gretchen.

Not sure what Gretchen refers to, but I was just trying to assume good faith and that was the only reason I could muster. I look forward to your clarification.

> This is literally no more than a useful contraction of "United States of America citizen"

It's not useful, though - it's harmful. It creates ambiguity where this is none, and tries to solve a problem that doesn't exist.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by defrost on Friday February 07, 2025 @12:56AM (#42969870)
> Should be obvious most people would share my stance also.

Yes. Most people like you share your point of view. Odd that.

> So why, then?

Check your hoistory, that appears to be the first time you haven't weighed in with nothing but your PoV, preconception, and desire to impose your conclusions as the motivations of others.

Congratulations. You're evolving.

> I don't try to stand out by being contrarian or via other semantic scheming.

But you assume others do? And that makes sense to you. Okay ...

> It's confusing to at the least ESL speakers ...

Is it? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42969214 suggest that not all ESL folk think that way.

> but I was just trying to assume good faith

There's been no sign of good faith and assuming the best from your comments since the first one (that appears edited) that patronisingly informed me that I should conform to your way of writing English.

> It's not useful, though - it's harmful.

Who is bleeding?

> It creates ambiguity

Again, what ambiguity? What country did you think that I was referring to?

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Friday February 07, 2025 @01:22AM (#42969982)
> Yes. Most people like you share your point of view. Odd that.

You seem to have modified my statement and then taken something other than intended. Allow me to clarify. I was referring to most people as in the vast majority of the English speaking population. Not simply people like me.

> Check your hoistory, that appears to be the first time you haven't weighed in with nothing but your PoV, preconception, and desire to impose your conclusions as the motivations of others.

> Congratulations. You're evolving.

This was the answer you gave in response to my asking why you chose to use an obscure less common less well known term to refer to people of the US. All you could do is insult me in response. This leads me to believe I was correct in my previous good faith assumption.

Also, having to check post history so you can attempt to discredit me instead of just answering a simple question says a lot.

> But you assume others do? And that makes sense to you. Okay ...

As I said, it was the only good faith assumption I could come up with as to why someone would chose to use an obscure less common less well known term to refer to people from the US.

> Is it?

Without a doubt, due to being significantly less used and recognized.

> There's been no sign of good faith and assuming the best from your comments since the first one (that appears edited) that patronisingly informed me that I should conform to your way of writing English.

It wasn't patronizing, it was informing you that that term is less common and tries to solve a problem that doesn't exist. My reply was a lost gamble taking the chance you were someone that ran into someone like spreading nonsense and having picked up a bad term/habit as a result, as opposed to being someone that just likes being contrarian and causes people to pick up said bad terms/habits.

> Who is bleeding?

Is drawing blood really what you limit your concept of harm to?

> Again, what ambiguity?

This was clarified in my previous reply, as were other answers to questions you repeated, but I'll repeat myself again here while continuing to assume good faith.

The ambiguity is in giving the impression that it's a valid term to refer to people from the US, when really it's not so it just creates undue confusion and ambiguity.

Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by scld on Monday February 10, 2025 @02:18PM (#43004057)
For what its worth, the top google result for USofAian is literally this thread.
Re:Frank Lloyd Wright's mile high skyscraper proposal (2021) by kennysoona on Thursday February 06, 2025 @08:55PM (#42968428)
> It's interesting how some like to regulate the language of others.

No one is trying to regulate anything lol, you're as free to use whatever non-standard terms or words you like, you can even use irregardless if it's your hearts desire to do so.

You just have to keep in mind that people using a silly term to make a silly point ultimately just end up making themselves look silly. Using a term like 'USofAian' is certainly a silly term since it tries to solve a problem that doesn't exist, and actually creates instances of the problem trying to be avoided.