News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by input_sh on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:11AM (#42930072)
Would you consider for example Firefox' completely-local translations a success?

Directly funded by Horizon, made by a consortium of 4 European universities, now a part of Firefox?

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by murderfs on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:18AM (#42930119)
They paid three million euros to integrate existing open source software into Firefox?!
Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by bayindirh on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:25AM (#42930167)
No, EU funded Bergamot and HPLT projects. Integration came much later, but again as a part of Bergamot project.

[0]: https://browser.mt/

[1]: https://hplt-project.org/

[2]: https://github.com/mozilla/translations?tab=readme-ov-file#a...

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by shinryuu on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:40AM (#42930283)
Very grateful for those translations. Use them a lot!
Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by closewith on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:46AM (#42930331)
7 languages and a feature nobody to a rounding error uses? No, I don't consider that to be a research, economic, or technical success.

Honestly, I'm not sure if you posted this is support of Horizon or against? The Horizon budget for 2021-2027 is €95.5 billion or ~€15 billion per annum. If a headline "success" is an unfinished implementation of translation in Firefox of a translation engine (Marian) built by the Microsoft Translator team, then it's safe to say Horizon is an unqualified failure.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by Vinnl on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:10AM (#42930509)
I don't have the numbers at hand or know if they're even public somewhere, but telemetry shows that Firefox Translations is used a lot. Definitely on the list of successful new Firefox features.

(I'm a Mozilla employee, but I have not worked on Firefox Translations.)

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by e2le on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:38AM (#42931575)
>I don't have the numbers at hand

Is this it?

https://glam.telemetry.mozilla.org/fog/probe/translations_re...*

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by Vinnl on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:47AM (#42945784)
Hmm, I'm not sure, but I'm not sure how to read that page either. That graph has a lot more variability than I'd expect though.
Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by closewith on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:29AM (#42930638)
What is a lot?

Before integration, it had ~490 users as an extension, vs ~800,000 for To Google Translate, the number one option.

Offline translation has to be manually enabled per language in Settings.

Frankly I don't believe there's any meaningful usage until I see the numbers.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by e2le on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:03AM (#42931292)
>enabled per language in Settings.

Do they? I tried opening a French government site[1] and received the Firefox pop-up offering to translate the page. I did not have to enable anything in settings neither is the French language model downloaded. It seems translations are enabled by default.

[1]: https://www.elysee.fr/

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by closewith on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:16AM (#42931373)
I stand corrected on this point, the language packs now auto-download.

It's still a niche feature only partially built by a Horizon project (it was almost entirely built by commercial entities - MS and Mozilla) in a niche browser.

It's an indictment of the Horizon programme that this is considered the pre-eminent success story.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by VagabundoP on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:31AM (#42932055)
Its actually helped me a twice the last two weeks and I would browse mostly English language sites and I imagine it would be great if English wasn't your first language.

I didn't even know it was a new Firefox feature but I thought it was cool.

Well done EU.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by lxgr on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:35AM (#42934644)
You really can't win with some people.

If the EU invests into research and development of a feature that a US tech company already offers (as a proprietary, closed-source service), it's needless duplication and a futile effort in catching up.

Yet if it doesn't, that's admitting defeat in the face of competitors and the wrong move as well.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by closewith on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @12:06PM (#42935289)
> If the EU invests into research and development of a feature that a US tech company already offers (as a proprietary, closed-source service), it's needless duplication and a futile effort in catching up.

The example we're talking about is powered by a Marian, developed and open-sourced by a US multinational, Microsoft.

The Horizon project was to use that to create a Firefox plugin, which they did.

Another US multinational, Mozilla, later integrated into Firefox.

Firefox has 4.55% market share in Europe.

> Yet if it doesn't, that's admitting defeat in the face of competitors and the wrong move as well.

You are presenting a false and frankly bad faith dichotomy.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by Vinnl on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:49AM (#42945802)
I believe to the order of millions of translations per day, but again, I don't remember where to view this, so might not be correct. But it's definitely orders of magnitude larger than 100s of users.

(And indeed, as a sibling comment points out, the feature is suggested to users in context, which of course massively helps with discoverability, so it's no surprise to me that it's used way more often than the extension.)

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by devit on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @06:53AM (#42931221)
Huh? Most Firefox users presumably use it, and anyway it's obviously essential and extremely useful functionality.

And the really important languages for EU/US audiences are, in order, English, Chinese, Spanish, Japanese, Portuguese, German, Italian, which is, guess what, 7 languages...

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by closewith on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:10AM (#42931347)
> Huh? Most Firefox users presumably use it, and anyway it's obviously essential and extremely useful functionality.

~~Only Firefox users who explicitly enable offline translation per langauge in Settings use this feature~~, which will be a tiny minority of users in a browser with a tiny (~2.5%) market share.

I'm wrong, the language packs now auto-download.

> And the really important languages for EU/US audiences are, in order, English, Chinese, Spanish, Japanese, Portuguese, German, Italian, which is, guess what, 7 languages...

Well, those weren't the seven languages supported by the Bergamot project when it ended. Only two of your seven were supported: Bulgarian, Czech, English, Estonian, French, Polish, and Spanish.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by input_sh on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:33AM (#42930669)
Where did you get 7 languages from? It's like 30 right now, with new ones being added regularly.

What's unfinished about it?

And Marian also received 6 grants via Horizon, in cooperation with the exact same universities (the one in Edinburgh being the main one), so I'm not sure what's your point?

And did I try to list every success or one tangible example, as the parent asked?

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by closewith on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:36AM (#42930686)
> Where did you get 7 languages from?

The Horizon/Bergamot project ended with seven languages. Anything thereafter was added separately.

> What's unfinished about it?

The project ended with an unfinished implementation.

> And Marian was also funded by Horizon, also in cooperation with the exact same universities, so I'm not sure what's your point?

No, Marian was funded by MS.

You are revising history extraordinarily to make the most unimpressive project appear better than it was. If Bergamot achieved all its goals and was the exemplar of Horizon, Horizon would be a complete failure.

As it was, the project limped over the line unfinished to be picked up by Mozilla.

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by alecmev on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:12PM (#42938793)
Can you, please, share a source for the claims you make about Marian? Specifically, "developed and open-sourced by a US multinational, Microsoft" and "funded by MS" (from two other comments by you)?

It does look like Microsoft is (was) funding the project, and employs one of the authors as head of research at Microsoft Translator, which is great, but all the "seed" funding and actual research happened in EU. Microsoft hired the author only in 2018 [1], while the earliest EU grant was allocated in 2015 [2], and the main paper they published says "it has mainly been developed at the Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznan and at the University of Edinburgh" [3].

[1] https://www.linkedin.com/in/junczys/

[2] https://github.com/marian-nmt/marian#acknowledgements

[3] https://aclanthology.org/P18-4020.pdf

Re:Open Euro LLM: Open LLMs for Transparent AI in Europe by CrimsonRain on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:23AM (#42932687)
Depends on how much money has been spent.

Also money will be better spent with one common language instead of wasting so much time, resources and inconveniencing people with so many languages in this area.