News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by citricsquid on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @03:58PM (#4292714)
Hmm, I currently have 3 x 24" Samsung monitors and I've been considering the Samsung MD230X6 (6 x 23", 1920 x 1080) but the cost (around $4,000) vs. the $1000 cost of getting 3 x 27" (2560 x 1440) means I'm tempted to try out these "korean" monitors.

My main concern is why are they so cheap. The article mentions that they're displays that companies didn't deem fit to sell, does that mean these are displays that were due to be destroyed and someone is just selling them on, or are they purchased in bulk at a big discount and then being resold? I figure all that matters is if they work and is only $1,000 but I would be much more comfortable purchasing if I knew exactly what their story was.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by jsz0 on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:39PM (#4292892)
My understanding is with these 'B stock' parts the big guys will reject an entire batch / production run when the quality drops below a certain threshold. So these companies are probably salvaging the parts and either testing them or just passing the risk onto the consumer.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by caw on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @05:58PM (#4293312)
Some of these are also extremely barebones setups. On one of the models I've read about there's no on screen display, and only 1 input. There's sometimes buttons on the frame but they don't do anything besides power.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by jrockway on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @06:33PM (#4293441)
That's true of almost every big computer monitor. My HP ZR30w has a couple display port inputs, and the 30" Dells around here have a single DVI connector. Neither have OSDs or support any resolution other than their native.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by pilsetnieks on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @07:16PM (#4293567)
Dell U2711 has every kind of input known to man (well, the currently popular ones, anyway), has a decent OSD, and supports every common resolution starting from 640x840. The 30" from the same line is no different.

It's probably just your particular Dell models.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by jrockway on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @09:11PM (#4293894)
That is quite strange, since I've never seen a 30" monitor with any "extra" features, nor have I read a review of one. I assumed it simply wasn't done.

I was very surprised when I got a 30" monitor with more than one input.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by richiezc on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @11:42PM (#4294309)
the 30" dells you see are the 3007, it just has a dual link DVI input and no OSD. All the newer models 3008 and 3011 have a plethora of inputs: 2x DVI 1x DP 1x HDMI 1x VGA etc
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by moe on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @07:29PM (#4293598)
That's interesting.

My 27" Dell is covered in ports (5 inputs of all kinds, USB, CFCard, SDCard, you name it...) and has a pretty fancy OSD to go with the 5 physical buttons and 6 LEDs.

Granted, I don't actually use any of the ports other than DVI and USB, so it has always seemed a bit overkill to me.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by Strom on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @06:29PM (#4293426)
If you would have read the article you're commenting on, you would know that the buttons do work. It was just a case of Jeff Atwood (unintentionally) spreading lies.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by frio on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @07:31PM (#4293602)
Some do; some don't. Source: both of my flatmates have bought these screens; the buttons don't work on any of them (and nor do any but the DVI inputs). It's not like it really matters (after seeing these things I'm saving my pennies to grab a couple myself :)!), but the quality and functionality does differ from manufacturer to manufacturer (and from batch to batch internally - 2 of the 3 can overclock to a 120Hz refresh rate, the other can't).
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by mariusmg on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:22PM (#4292812)
They're being sold at a price which guarantees a (probably good) profit. To compete on that market you basically need a name. Rather than trying to invest lots of money in marketing and try to "compete" with LG/Samsung/etc those guys prefer to sell them "cheaper" for a profit.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by ars on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:39PM (#4292898)
You may like the Asus PA248Q. IPS, 24" 1920 x 1200, for $339.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by dtf on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:55PM (#4292985)
I bought a PA238Q a while back, and I use it now as my second monitor. It has incredibly bad persistence... like 20 to 30 seconds of afterimage when I move a window full of text out of the way. Plus the backlight bleed on a black screen is pretty bad.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by ars on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @05:15PM (#4293092)
The PA248Q is a completely different monitor from the PA238Q.

Also, try adjusting the Trace Free function.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by dtf on Thursday July 26, 2012 @04:22AM (#4294996)
Yeah, you wouldn't think so though, given the one-digit difference in name and the way they place it right next to the PA248Q in their marketing materials. That's marketing departments for you, I guess.

Thanks for the tip on Trace Free. It does something for sure.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by ars on Thursday July 26, 2012 @05:39AM (#4295182)
You are not the only person to get confused by ASUS names, so I quite sympathize.

Someone I know nearly bought what they thought was a great deal on an IPS screen only to be off by a single character.

It was VS228H-P vs VS229H-P

Who names these things?

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by samstave on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:13PM (#4292790)
>why are they so cheap

Maybe they are made by slaves in North Korea underthe work exchange program they have...

EDIT: downvoted, but I was being serious... Maybe they are using labor such as that to make these. I dont know I cant think of another reason they are so cheap - unless they see an opportunity to steal the market by dropping margins and getting these to go in high volume ove rthe next months/year...

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by Tsagadai on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @09:35PM (#4293969)
Kaesong Industrial Region area is run by Hyundai Asan (Hyundai is a big group of companies and Asan is not really connected to the Motors side). Kaesong mostly produces low-end, low-tech manufactured goods (think toothbrushes and plastic toys). Hyundai Asan is not run by idiots and there is no way they would put anything in North Korea that would allow North Korea to mass produce high-end, techncial goods like IPS displays. Some manufacturing is done by Chinese companies near the northern DPRK border but it is mainly stuff that requires human machines (labour is cheaper in North Korea than China!). Think, textiles and basket weaving. Power is even imported from China there and North Korea provides almost nothing to businesses except access to a limited labour supply.

Your post is conspiratorial and wrong. I know people who have worked at Kaesong (note that Kaesong has also been mostly closed for the last 3 years). Wages may be extremely low but anything that gets more food and money into North Korea while remaining outside the control of the government is a good thing. People can't fight tyranny when they are fighting to not starve to death.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by fusiongyro on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @05:18PM (#4293110)
It's not a question to be tossed aside, but I don't think the evidence would bear it. For one thing, nothing made in DPRK is going to be sold through South Korea. They're at war still, not trading and communicating with each other.

Secondly, while DPRK has a lot of people in labor camps, they're starving and their education level is comparable to 4th grade. I don't think you can get exacting standards of quality out of starved forced laborers, but even if you could, you'd still be dealing with the complete lack of a supply chain in North Korea. There are plenty of countries in the area with established supply chains and populations experienced at making these kinds of things, but DPRK isn't one of them.

Third, there just isn't a lot coming out of DPRK in the first place. I've heard of paper flowers made in their labor camps being exported to China and Japan, but in general the trade situation is pretty much a trickle.

It's possible, and there are certainly people around better informed than me, but it doesn't sound like the best or most plausible explanation to me.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by quant18 on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @10:18PM (#4294071)
Quite a number of South Korean companies have set up shop in Kaesong Industrial Park, right over the DMZ in North Korea. There's 100+ factories employing more than 40,000 workers. There's buses going across to South Korea every day, though obviously they get cut off in times of tension. I don't think LG does anything directly at Kaesong, but there's certainly other electronics manufacturing going on there: 13 firms in total produced $59 million of electronics at Kaesong in 2010. Of some relevance to this discussion, Magic Micro has been making lamp assemblies for LCD monitors there since 2006. In short, it's not just canvas sacks and artificial flowers coming out of labour camps. http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34093.pdf

No doubt, in any supply chain, the highest value-added steps are not occuring in Kaesong. As pointed out by others, labour costs can't explain the difference of hundreds of dollars on these monitors and so samstave's guess is likely wrong (though I don't think he deserves to be downvoted into oblivion). But companies don't decide to locate at Kaesong for cost reasons anyway; rather, they're there for nationalistic reasons about promoting reunification. The factories there apparently don't even break even in the absence of South Korean government subsidies, and the future of those subsidies is uncertain: http://koreajoongangdaily.joinsmsn.com/news/article/article....

(Another slightly more complex point is that companies manufacturing products at Kaesong likely have to accept lower margins on them --- exporting them runs into sanctions issues in many countries, meaning they have to be sold in the domestic market --- but I doubt that's what's going on here to make these monitors so cheap either).

For those who are interested in this kind of stuff, the blog http://www.nkeconwatch.com/ makes good reading

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by fusiongyro on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @11:32PM (#4294282)
Absolutely fantastic info, thanks!
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by wisty on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @08:23PM (#4293742)
NK is doing some textiles work for South Korea. Textiles is always one of the first things industrialising countries do, because it's only labor intensive.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by moonchrome on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:32PM (#4292854)
How likely is it that low skilled manual labor is the highest cost factor in high tech manufacturing of things like monitors.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by Lagged2Death on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:36PM (#4292878)
Well, look at it this way: Where are such things generally made, and why are they generally made there?
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by dangrossman on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:44PM (#4292933)
> Compared to the cost of buying chips or making sure that you have a plant that can turn out thousands of these things a day or being able to get strengthened glass cut exactly right within, you know, two days of this thing being due, that’s what’s important. Labor is almost insignificant. What is really important are supply chains and flexibility of factories. You want to be able to be located right next to the plant that makes the screws so that when you need a small change to that screw factory, you can go next door and say, “Give it to me in six hours,” and they can say, “Here you go.” Because if that factory was in another state or on another continent, it would take two weeks. It’s the flexibility within the Chinese manufacturing system, that’s what you can do in Asia that you can’t do in the United States.

-- Charles Duhigg, the NYT reporter who wrote the iEconomy piece on Apple’s supply chain and the reason the tech giant doesn’t produce its devices in the U.S.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by Lagged2Death on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @11:25PM (#4294254)
I'm familiar with this line of reasoning, but I find it unsatisfying and I suspect it's really more of an apologia for American corporate power than a sound history.

Manufacturing was absolutely galloping into China before this sort of tight inter-company integration was even a gleam in anyone's eye, and there's no obvious reason such integration couldn't have developed elsewhere -- except for the labor issues.

The integration that's now heralded as the reason for moving manufacturing to China seems self-evidently a product of such movements to me.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by dangrossman on Thursday July 26, 2012 @01:16AM (#4294531)
It doesn't seem far-fetched to imagine that manufacturing initially moved to China because of the cheap labor, but that it's stayed there because of the supply chain advantages. Labor in China isn't cheap as it once was, scrutiny of conditions is heightened, and domestic labor isn't as expensive as it once was either.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by maratd on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:51PM (#4292958)
> why are they generally made there?

Because every dollar counts, especially in massive quantities. But don't kid yourself, the difference between manufacturing in volume in China vs US is just a few dollars per unit. Certainly not enough to explain a difference in price of hundreds of dollars.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by gph on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:48PM (#4292949)
That's not really pertinent. The point is that the difference between using slave labor or using the abundant low-skilled cheap labor force is minimal. It might possibly swing the price of the product by tens of dollars, but there's no way it would swing the price by hundreds. Labor is already one of the cheapest expenses in manufacturing, going to slavery isn't going to change it that much if at all.
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by jrockway on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @06:35PM (#4293447)
How much labor is involved in making a monitor? The expensive part is the panel, and they are buying those from Samsung or LG.

Apple and Dell probably sell 27" and 30" monitors at a premium because they don't move many units, and the people that need them have the money to buy them. Some Korean company realized they could sell the same panels on eBay for $300 and still make a profit, so they did.

Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by brador on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:27PM (#4292825)
I'm not the downvoter, but since we can't know either way, is it of significance when making a purchasing decision?
Re:Those budget 27" IPS displays from Korea are for real by samstave on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @04:30PM (#4292839)
No, but the question by the OP was "how" are they doing this... I was speculating.