News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by bongoman42 on Monday February 03, 2025 @02:34PM (#42921885)
Interesting data in the article though nothing unexpected for people who follow this space. Some notable points:

> The other thing that interests you is the like ratio, or the openness, among 100 profiles that the user sees, how many of them does he like? (The median for men is 26% and for women is 4%.)

>The like ratio of a girl is almost independent of the profiles she sees. For example, if a girl has a like ratio of 5% and you remove 50% of the profiles, even if you remove only the profiles she will not like, her like ratio will still be 5% (you can do that by removing very unattractive people for a guy that is very attractive, for example). It is funny to observe, but it seems like a girl has internal reasoning on a dating app, and they know they can only like x% of profiles whatever she sees (of course, it doesn't work if you show only ugly people).

And lastly:

>Whats interesting is that the more attractive the guys were ranked by girls the more they were looking for something not serious.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by marinmania on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:31PM (#42939971)
I have a theory for the swiping behavior of women. When they swipe right, it will most likely be a match, and they mentally don't want more than X active conversations at a time. This strikes me as rational and reasonable.

For men, most swipes will not be a match, so less reason to ever think about swiping left to maintain a certain swipe pecentage.

Just a theory!

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by mettamage on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:37PM (#42940061)
> they mentally don't want more than X active conversations at a time

This is true. My cap was at 50 conversations at the same time. After that, my brain got fried (male here).

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:38PM (#42941648)
My cap was maybe 5. Seems I have less capacity.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by mettamage on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:49AM (#42946724)
To be fair, I was crazily driven and treated it like a job. Intimacy is crazy important to me

Edit: interesting that I got at least 3 downvotes for that comment. I don't mind, genuinely. It's just interesting. Different world views and all that

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:25AM (#42949783)
People will downvote you for stating a truth they don’t like.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by globular-toast on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:46PM (#42940192)
Another theory: when you swipe and don't get a match, that could be considered a rejection and women are worse at handling rejection (probably due to never having to learn to deal with it). Men, on the other hand, have to learn to accept rejection so little is felt when almost all swipes don't match.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by d4mi3n on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:08PM (#42942664)
Most people (all sexes and genders) are bad at handling rejection, period. It’s why online dating is popular in general—a rejection over a digital medium is a lot less intimidating and less confrontational than the same in person.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by DiggyJohnson on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:56PM (#42943986)
The rate and experience of rejection does not seem to be symmetrical across the sexes by a significant degree. Of course nobody likes rejection, but this point doesn’t really advance the discussion.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by swores on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:23AM (#42946526)
They were responding to "women are worse at handling rejection", and if they disagree with that (as I do too) then it is advancing the conversation to say so, even though it doesn't advance a part of the conversation that specifically explains dating app use.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by dgfitz on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @06:26PM (#42956854)
Men handle rejection poorly, I’ve seen it, as I’m sure we all have. Weeping, drinking, wallowing in self-pity. It can get bad.

Women handle rejection with anger, resentment, and vitriol towards the rejecting party. So much so that I’ve seen people get married and divorced because the man was basically bullied into sticking around, and she left in the end anyways. Happens all the fucking time.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by knighthack on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:40AM (#42946660)
You are spewing politically-correct BS, in saying "...Most people (all sexes and genders) are bad at handling rejection, period.".

Women are worse at handling rejection, hands down - it's a gendered-thing, not the same across genders.

For instance, in terms of relationships in real life (since we're discussing dating), most women do not approach men first; men are usually first to be rejected. Some women even shame men for supposedly being scared to approach them, instead of they themselves making the move first. There are so many videos showing how infantile and childish women become when they are rejected; especially the more beautiful they are.

Men are taught early to accept rejection as a natural part of life; there are of course men who react poorly when being rejected, but in comparison (since the thread is talking about women accepting rejection)? Women are definitely poorer in handling rejection.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by wutwutwat on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @08:48AM (#42948431)
I bet the ladies love you.

Question: do you and the other incels hate women together, like sitting in a circle, or do you perform your hate in solitude?

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by knighthack on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:48AM (#42950199)
Congratulations on your shaming ad-hominem language. Your lack of any genuine counterpoint reveals your men-hating nature by your remarks, which deserve no further response.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by wutwutwat on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:53AM (#42950281)
Me calling out you for your distorted view of women === I hate men?

Solid logic. 100%. Probably the same logic that resulted in your wack determination about rejection.

PS. I'm a man. One who doesn't hate women. Or men. Not in general. I am able to hate individuals though, and their gender plays little into it, while their sweeping generalizations and hateful pseudo facts often do.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by DiggyJohnson on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:27PM (#42951976)
Read the guidelines and in general don’t call people an “incel” because they disagree with you.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by wutwutwat on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:14PM (#42954474)
That's not why I called them an incel. I called them an incel for spouting a hateful opinion as fact that makes women out to be inferior, you know, the thing incels are known for doing.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by DiggyJohnson on Thursday February 06, 2025 @06:57PM (#42967749)
You should essentially never call someone an incel if you want to be taken seriously. Second, it’s obviously against the HN guidelines.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by wutwutwat on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:31PM (#42978265)
Yet, my comment remains left intact. Sometimes inaction says just as much as action...
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by orangecat on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @02:46PM (#42954060)
most women do not approach men first; men are usually first to be rejected

This is true, but from what I've seen it's not because women are particularly scared of rejection, it's because they use men's approaches as a filter. That is, they want men to be confident enough to approach them, and charismatic enough to do it well.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by yieldcrv on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:30AM (#42946574)
Women complain about the poor quality of conversations they encounter

We should do a study on that itself, because I think guys are having quality conversations, pulling teeth with an entitled beautiful woman they are prioritizing, and everyone else is waiting for the guy to lead and there is no bandwidth left! so guys spread themselves too thin to procedurally lead every new conversation after accumulating matches

while girls are particular on the matches

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:29AM (#42949870)
“ Women complain about the poor quality of conversations they encounter”

From my experience in online dating there are a lot of women who expect the guy to do everything. He needs to approach and then also carry the conversation. Out of maybe 10 initial messages I received from women there was maybe 1 that was more than “Hi”.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by yieldcrv on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @02:37PM (#42953922)
yeah, old Bumble never worked for me. I was attractive enough to be matched with but not prioritized for women to start the conversation.

It was very validating to know that Bumble dropped their one unique value add because women were afraid to approach and werent doing it enough

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by carabiner on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:35PM (#42940033)
This one is classic:

> Girls would say, red flag if a guy has shirtless pictures and then liking profiles where guys were shirtless.

This is surprising:

> In our case we had even acquisition in terms of male/female, but the retention of girls is lower than that of men, so you end up with 66% men and 34% women.

2:1 men to woman is a far better ratio than what most people claim (5:1 is usually thrown around with no evidence).

These points will ruffle feathers:

> But I think dating apps can currently be used at each women and men advantage, it is just necessary to have the right strategy:

> For girls you need to lower your standards and force you to go on a date with guys that you dont have the flame for (it is actually very hard to do that for a girl, very very hard)

> For guys, you need to pay a photograph (to get liked) and pay the premium plan (so that your profile is shown to other users). If you think a dating app has no incentive to show paying users to girls, then you didnt read this article ^^

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by bawolff on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:27PM (#42941521)
> For girls you need to lower your standards and force you to go on a date with guys that you dont have the flame for (it is actually very hard to do that for a girl, very very hard)

I kind of didn't understand the logic behind how he got there. According to the article women get more matches then they know what to do with. Why would lowering your standards in such an environment be a good strategy?

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by srjek on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:57PM (#42941881)
The article is a bit a of jumble of thoughts, but I believe that advice is aimed at girls who aren't liking and therefore not matching. Some lines that mention this particular grouping:

> Only 50% of girls sent 10 likes in their account lifespan.

> 10% of girls that finish the onboarding never send any pass or like, ...

> We have plenty of girls that can scroll through 300 profiles and not like anyone and deleting their account saying "I dont like anyone" well

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by carabiner on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:31PM (#42942280)
Lowering your standards will find guys who aren't just interested in sex. The problem is that most women want the same (small proportion of) men. He said that the more matches a man gets, the more likely he'll just want sex and not a relationship. So you go for the less desired men and you find better quality matches, if you are looking for more than casual relations.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by bawolff on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:31PM (#42942881)
It does seem like there are a lot of hidden assumptions here. Is the man who gets less matches really more likely to want a relationship rather than sex, or is he faking that opinion because he doesn't think he has options and thinks lying will get him more matches.

My assumption would be someone who changes their mind on what they want based on availability of choices would probably not be a good relationship partner.

So would lowering your standards really get you more "quality" matches, or just get people more willing to lie about what they want because they are more desperate?

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by itronitron on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @01:14AM (#42944554)
Presumably, men who get less matches would have more sex when they are in a relationship versus when they are not in one.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by wavemode on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @02:50AM (#42945315)
You're thinking about it wrong. Any guy you meet who struggles with women is generally going to be looking for a long-term relationship. Starving men don't toss fish back into the water.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by modo_mario on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:44AM (#42945766)
>Is the man who gets less matches really more likely to want a relationship rather than sex, or is he faking that opinion because he doesn't think he has options and thinks lying will get him more matches.

I'd say more likely down the line there's not a huge difference between the popular and unpopular men regarding what they aim for but the men who get a ton of matches and gravitate towards a fixed relationship are more likely to be out of the dating market.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by GuB-42 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @07:25AM (#42947519)
It can be explained with simple statistics.

Let's say 50% of men want casual sex, 50% want a stable relationship, regardless of their desirability.

Let's say that the 10% most desirable men get 10 "conclusive" matches a month, the others get 1 per month.

Let's say that for men who are in for casual sex stay on the platform for 1 year, those who are in for a long term relationship stay for as long as they need to.

Let's say that 1 in 10 matches can lead to a long term relationship, if desired.

The result is that on average all men who is in for casual sex will stay for 1 year, attractive men who are in for a long term relationship will be there for 1 month and less attractive men who are in for a long term relationship will be there for 10 months.

So with a 50/50 long-term/casual split, and by taking into account how long they stay you will have:

- 51.2% of less attractive men who want casual sex

- 42.7% of less attractive men who want a long term relationship

- 5.7% of attractive men who want casual sex

- 0.4% of attractive men who want a long term relationship

The result is that if an attractive man is still on the platform, there is 92% chance that he is in for casual sex.

Of course, plenty of assumptions here, but the general idea is that attractive men looking for a long term relationship won't stay long, and those who remain are more likely interested in casual sex, whereas it is more balanced for less attractive men.

Of course, it also works for women.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by bawolff on Thursday February 06, 2025 @02:32PM (#42965686)
I think the obvious conclusion to that is that dating apps are only good for hookups, and anyone who wants a real relationship would be best served by going elsewhere where the signal to noise ratio is higher and not skewed in this fashion.

Interestingly though you are basically describing a lemons market. However we don't usually advise people buying used cars to go for the crap-looking car.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by stevage on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:38AM (#42944288)
Because if you only like the hot guys, you only match with guys that everyone else likes too, and who just want sex.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by Ray20 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @04:25AM (#42946086)
There is simply no incentive for such behavior. The person always hopes for the best (the hot guy will choose me over all those who like him). And what about the worst case? Sex with hot guys? Sounds like a very solid strategy to me.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by stevage on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @06:39AM (#42947127)
Not if their goal is a serious relationship, it's a terrible strategy.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by FireBeyond on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @09:54PM (#42958451)
> 2:1 men to woman is a far better ratio than what most people claim (5:1 is usually thrown around with no evidence).

Hah, check out this claim 3 women to every 2 men. Of course there's no mention of what site/app it is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38059778

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by HeckFeck on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @06:34PM (#42940875)
I can corroborate this.

When I was using dating apps I kept a spreadsheet to track the response to like ratio, and indeed, the amount of women who liked me back in any given month was exactly 5% of those whom I liked.

Much as I wish that ratio was higher, data is data. The Tinder style matchmaking will always bring out this behaviour.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @07:42PM (#42941700)
I didn’t run the numbers but I also quickly figured that the only chance to make progress is to like a lot of profiles. For a while i liked only profiles which i thought are a really good fit but got no responses. Turns out spamming works better. Once a woman likes you back, then you can take a closer look.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by novia on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:36PM (#42942349)
People like you are why dating apps suck for women and why women leave them :)
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by iczero on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @08:48PM (#42942447)
have you considered that dating apps suck for literally everyone and everybody should leave them?
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by Gunax on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @09:37PM (#42942950)
Your comment really tells a lot a out your personality. And it's not a good look.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:34AM (#42944262)
No worries. My method worked and I am off the market.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by novia on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @12:32PM (#42952065)
But the method doesn't die with you. Now when someone gets a like it is meaningless.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @01:45PM (#42953197)
What's the alternative? Complain that you never get a match? The recommendation to only contact people you think are a perfect match and then send a customized message doesn't work.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by novia on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @01:50PM (#42953284)
When people match with me, then read my profile, get mad about what's in my profile, send me a message expressing said anger, and then unmatch, it's a big waste of time. And that's actually the best case scenario. Worst case they don't read the profile at all and keep stringing me along.

The first time I joined a dating website I got a like from a person who I would have thought was way out of my league. I was really confused. Am I actually super hot and didn't know?

No. It's that EVERYONE on dating sites is playing this stupid game that wastes women's time. Some people are doing it with spamming likes, other people are doing it with more active gamification and pretending they have beliefs they don't actually hold. This is why most of the women left on dating apps are bots trying to direct you to their onlyfans.

If I didn't know the game men are playing, that first interaction and subsequent interactions on dating websites would have given me an inflated sense of importance, like, damn, maybe I've actually been dating below my league this whole time? I think that's where this article gets the impression that women only like 5% even if all the contenders shown are attractive.

Like seriously, I'm angry enough about this that I want dating apps to have something that's the opposite of a super like, where you can pay them money to penalize people not using the apps in a genuine manner.

Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by rqtwteye on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @04:48PM (#42955712)
Seems these apps are not healthy for your mental state.
Re:The Reality of Dating Apps by novia on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:34PM (#42958727)
I haven't used them in years. I've been dating in real life.