Re:Semicolons; So Tricky
by coroxout on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @07:10AM
(#4290326)
I thought this was going to be yet another piece on the Javascript debate (perhaps a little unlikely from the New Yorker, but who knows?), instead of about punctuation in English.
Many here may be disappointed that it was the latter, but personally I found this a refreshing surprise. I've always liked semicolons but been a little afraid I may not be using them right.
Re:Semicolons; So Tricky
by pasbesoin on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @12:33PM
(#4291693)
Didn't read the article, but I think of them -- in English prose -- as being used to separate clauses that can stand (grammatically) as independent sentences, but which you choose to bind somewhat more closely together (by use of the semicolon) to identify a closer association within the broader hierarchy of its context. Often, and perhaps preferentially, the one clause leads -- logically, chronologically, etc. -- to the next.
A separate use is to separate list members when those individual members include sublists, subclauses, or other items that in turm use/include commas.
Once you move beyond prose -- poetry, code, etc. -- the "rules" loosen or change, requiring separate consideration of those contexts.
And of course, these latter uses can bleed back into prose; language is always transforming -- some would say, evolving.
Many here may be disappointed that it was the latter, but personally I found this a refreshing surprise. I've always liked semicolons but been a little afraid I may not be using them right.
A separate use is to separate list members when those individual members include sublists, subclauses, or other items that in turm use/include commas.
Once you move beyond prose -- poetry, code, etc. -- the "rules" loosen or change, requiring separate consideration of those contexts.
And of course, these latter uses can bleed back into prose; language is always transforming -- some would say, evolving.