Sure, if you ignore the simple fact that Twitter reached > 100M users when it had zero money transfer feature for the end users.
> And that's why decentralized, federated, or whatever social networks will never gain a large scale (>1 million or so) users
This is fine. If we have 500 decentralized social networks and 2 centralized social networks, it's awesome.
The decentralized networks will be harder for people to make money off of, but not impossible. That's also good. You can use the big soulless social networks for moneymaking, then return to the smaller ones for actual genuine social interaction.
> The governments of the world will never allow non-corporations to provide the money transfers necessary for people to "make a living" on such sites.
Before the Internet, we had money orders. You can still get them and cash them. In the 90's I used to order stuff via mail using money orders. It's riskier, but I'm not sure it's very much more riskier if you are dealing with someone you are following that has a group you are a member of. It is less convenient.
The feature no major western social media site has had is the one that make it worth it for the majority of users?
Seems like an extreme claim without any backing or logic behind it.
(This has nothing to do with politics or decentralization or anything else.)
I’m sure this will work out great.
And that's why decentralized, federated, or whatever social networks will never gain a large scale (>1 million or so) users. The governments of the world will never allow non-corporations to provide the money transfers necessary for people to "make a living" on such sites. That's not a bad thing, but it does mean tha "alternative" social media really needs to stop chasing these kinds of users.