News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @09:13AM (#42821758)
> First and foremost, their statement about community on their homepage spoke to me

This is the part of the excitement around Gleam that gives me pause. When the biggest draw is the heavily-moderated community [0], it seems almost more a political project than it does a technical one. That's not a bad thing in and of itself—goodness knows we need less toxicity in the world—but I get very nervous around a technical project that has gotten very comfortable with silencing dissent and enforcing "good vibes". I think of dang's bio quote:

> Conflict is essential to human life, whether between different aspects of oneself, between oneself and the environment, between different individuals or between different groups. It follows that the aim of healthy living is not the direct elimination of conflict, which is possible only by forcible suppression of one or other of its antagonistic components, but the toleration of it—the capacity to bear the tensions of doubt and of unsatisfied need and the willingness to hold judgement in suspense until finer and finer solutions can be discovered which integrate more and more the claims of both sides. It is the psychologist's job to make possible the acceptance of such an idea so that the richness of the varieties of experience, whether within the unit of the single personality or in the wider unit of the group, can come to expression. [1]

Marion Milner, 'The Toleration of Conflict', Occupational Psychology, 17, 1, January 1943

[0] The lead dev has been known to tell people off in DMs for reacting with negative emoji to their discord comments (and remove the negative reactions with admin powers!): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41413735

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dang

Re:My Impressions of Gleam by brink on Saturday January 25, 2025 @09:44AM (#42821908)
Isn't it funny that people who constantly feel the need to tell the world how kind they are, actually aren't that kind?
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by laurent_du on Saturday January 25, 2025 @02:07PM (#42823764)
It stops being funny when you realize the root cause of this posturing is mental health issues. These people are unwell.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by okkdev on Saturday January 25, 2025 @10:37AM (#42822225)
Not tolerating intolerance shouldn't be political.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @10:48AM (#42822300)
As many are fond of saying these days, everything is political, whether it tries to or not. But what makes me say this is a political project more than a technical one is that consistently, as in TFA, the thing people say draws them to Gleam is this statement on the home page.

And again: lpil has explicitly said that they're not stopping with intolerance, they enforce "good vibes". That's what I'm worried about on a practical level: I don't believe you can build a healthy technical community that solves real problems on that foundation.

I very well might be wrong, and I believe that that's the point of this political experiment. But I also think it's important to emphasize that that's what this is: a political experiment, not just a programming language.

Re:My Impressions of Gleam by okkdev on Sunday January 26, 2025 @02:58AM (#42828542)
I really think you read too much into this. It's a programming language by people who don't want to deal with shitty people. There's more than enough healthy language design discussion going on if you are worried about that.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by DemocracyFTW2 on Saturday January 25, 2025 @12:42PM (#42823174)
This is an automated message. Your SocialScore has been downgraded 1.75% for using two negations in a single sentence. Please be more positive in the future. Thank you.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by surgical_fire on Saturday January 25, 2025 @12:47PM (#42823221)
Pending definitions of intolerance.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by hellcow on Saturday January 25, 2025 @09:54AM (#42821956)
I'm more interested in the language after hearing this. There's plenty of negativity in the world, I don't need more of it in a niche programmer forum of enthusiasts. It reminds me of MINASWAN from Ruby.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @10:05AM (#42822014)
MINASWAN is a cultural thing, not a code of conduct. It's not enforced by Matz from on high in such heavy-handed ways, it's just the way that the Ruby community rolls.

That said, if this interests you, that's great! Like I said, there's nothing wrong with a project that is primarily political in nature. I'm just highly skeptical that such a project can achieve good technical outcomes in the long run once the admins get accustomed to suppressing negative reactions under a vague "good vibes" policy.

I could be wrong, and that's exactly what political projects are often designed to do: to prove a political point. But if you're not interested in a political project and are instead looking for a strongly typed BEAM language, you might be better off just waiting for Elixir to finish its types.

Re:My Impressions of Gleam by garyrob on Saturday January 25, 2025 @09:49AM (#42821934)
Just gotta say that's an excellent quote from dang, who I never heard of before.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @09:53AM (#42821952)
Hah, fair enough. Proper citation added.
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by beepbooptheory on Saturday January 25, 2025 @01:02PM (#42823301)
I guess I just don't understand how you want to draw the line from the need for tolerance in itself to the necessary prescription that quiescence is the only way to be if you want to get things done. Is not taking some kind of stand precisely integrating and accepting conflict?

Like is anything purely technical? I dont think so, and the most insidious politics are the ones that are left unspoken but allowed to direct the endeavor at hand. To dream of or push for something purely "technical" or "apolitical" is simply to be guilty of the same thing your quote is getting at, but from the other direction. Instead of squashing dissent, you simply poof it out existence, you make it taboo to even talk about. How does that then become tolerance? How does it operate necessarily to help us? It is in fact no less an imposition, and is no less a political operation in the communities where this kind of view operates.

Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @02:46PM (#42824144)
Okay, replying now to what you actually meant (my other comment assumed that you were saying that Gleam advocates for tolerance, I didn't realize it was a reference to the quote):

I said nothing about quiescence. I said nothing against taking a stand. My opposition is to the idea that the way forward for conflict management is to purge it and pretend it isn't happening. That's what happened in the case I linked to—a member of the community expressed disapproval of admin actions and had their disapproval removed by the moderator and received a rather passive aggressive response in a DM. That's an inappropriate way to moderate that does not lead to healthy conflict management.

Taking a stand would be publicly engaging with the criticism, not purging it and engaging with the critic in a private message.

I'm much less concerned about the US-politics-centric commentary on the main page (though there are problems with that, like making people not in the US feel excluded) than I am with a broader trend in many open source projects (this one being one of several I've seen) of "protecting" their community from anything that remotely resembles toxicity, even when those things are well meaning criticism of the way that things are being run.

And no, I wouldn't say that anything is purely technical—but some things are political in service to the technical, and other things are political first. Gleam strikes me as a project that is firmly political first, based on the lead dev's actions and the community's discussion (this article literally places the project's political stance as "first and foremost"!). As I say, that's not a bad thing, but I'm skeptical that it will work out in the long run on a technical level to prioritize the politics over all else, especially when the approach to politics is one that shuts down conflict rather than cultivating and curating it.

Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @01:24PM (#42823442)
> to draw the line from the need for tolerance in itself to the necessary prescription that quiescence is the only way to be if you want to get things done

I'm not talking about tolerance, I'm talking about the lead dev actively shutting down negative reactions to their comments and justifying it under the banner of "good vibes". If the lead dev can't deal gracefully with criticism, that's going to be a problem.

Too many people in this thread are treating criticism of this pattern of silencing dissent for not "vibing" right as though the critic is implicitly endorsing letting Nazis roam free. There's a middle ground between "good vibes only" and "fascists welcome" that lpil has explicitly said he's not interested in pursuing.

Re:My Impressions of Gleam by beepbooptheory on Saturday January 25, 2025 @02:21PM (#42823904)
Its totally fine and reasonable if this is just about how this particular person carries themselves, about them being a bad admin or whatever! It just then feels a little at odds with sweeping, principled profundity of the initial comment. Like why invoke the quote and all that at first if you're not actually standing by it now?
Re:My Impressions of Gleam by lolinder on Saturday January 25, 2025 @02:35PM (#42824050)
I don't know where you get that I'm not standing by it—the quote isn't about tolerance, it's about engaging with difficult concepts and conflicts rather than dodging them. I didn't even realize your talking about tolerance was supposed to be engaging with the quote until this follow up.

I guess "toleration" and "tolerance" do share a root, but the latter is so watered down at this point that I honestly didn't even connect them, so I misunderstood your comment to be about something very different than it was. I'm going back now to reread it to see if I can understand your point better.

Edit: rather than deepening this subthread further, I posted a separate reply to your original comment based on my new understanding of your point.