News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by matrix87 on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @10:44PM (#42707074)
> Learning how to co-exist with people who aren't like you is a universally valuable experience, especially for people who would fashion themselves as "not average."

If those people have worse habits, are less motivated, less educated, less cultured, what is there to gain from it?

Seems like there's only something to lose from adjusting to their shittiness. Like Harrison Bergeron

And seeing the state of California trying to push math classes later because of "equity", seeing public schools dissolving gifted programs, it makes me think that privatization is the only way forward instead of trying to make amends with the current progressive stupidity

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by woodruffw on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @11:07PM (#42707204)
> If those people have worse habits, are less motivated, less educated, less cultured, what is there to gain from it?

This is prejudice in the most basic sense: you literally don't know any of these things about the people you're surrounded by in a society. The person who rides the bus next to you could be a couch potato, or a talented artist, or something entirely different that simply isn't legible to you.

I don't know anything about California's math classes. I'm saying that, on a basic level, anybody who thinks this way about people they don't know is demonstrating the exact traits they're smugly claiming to be above.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by r3trohack3r on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @11:36PM (#42707351)
I feel like you and the parents post are compatible views of the world, that could be simultaneously held in the same brain without dissonance.

Reading your comment, it seems to focus on the individual. “The person” you know nothing about.

The parent comment seems to be Bayesian, the probability of “the person” being something.

I do think it’s possible to simultaneously believe that:

* every single person you meet in every possible circumstance might be an exceptional human

* your are more likely to encounter exceptional humans in specific circumstances and you can optimize for that

I believe this holds true regardless of your definition of exceptional.

A (maybe) obvious example: if you believe exceptional humans want to grow their own food and live on communes, you probably don’t want to live in the financial district of Manhattan. That would be a bad way to optimize for finding people who share your values.

Similarly you’re unlikely to find a thriving software developer community in Springfield Illinois. If you go to Springfield and assume everyone you meet can’t program, you’re going to be wrong - there are good programmers there. But if you want to live around people who know how to code, you don’t move to Springfield Illinois.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by svnt on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:25AM (#42708647)
I feel like you both got and missed the point, and it relies on your misuse of exceptional that doesn’t escape the original discussion:

Society needs and has exceptional people living in communes, in the financial district, in software development communities, and yes even in Springfield, Illinois.

Sharing your values or not does generally not correlate with exceptional.

If you are just looking for someone in your field to learn a trade from, well, great, but that is hardly the intent of primary education.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by philipwhiuk on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:52AM (#42710730)
> you can optimize for that

I think that this is the core problem - you can't.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by r3trohack3r on Saturday January 18, 2025 @08:21PM (#42752824)
Pretty sure you can.

You try your thesis. I’ll try mine.

We will see where the other’s grand kids end up.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by philipwhiuk on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:54AM (#42710760)
> But if you want to live around people who know how to code, you don’t move to Springfield Illinois.

And if you want to find the best mathematician you stay in academic circles. But the best mathematician of your era might be in a random district in India. So you shouldn't immediately exclude everywhere else, or your 'optimisation' may be a relatively low local maximum.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by programjames on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @07:54PM (#42719547)
It is impossible for an individual to do this search themself, so you have to have some global sorting. Top-down approaches include math competitions and national testing. More federated approaches include just... moving to communities where the average is closer to you.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by dijksterhuis on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:35AM (#42707663)
> If those people have worse habits, are less motivated, less educated, less cultured, what is there to gain from it?

learning how to be patient and tolerant regarding situations / people / things i do not like or think of as “beneath me”.

tends to lead to better decision making as one can respond, rather than knee jerk react to everything.

edit — also, i tend to find i can learn a lot more useful lessons from beginners.

in the beginners mind there are a lot of possibilities. in the expert’s mind (especially self proclaimed ones) there are few possibilities.

children are a great example of this.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by watwut on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:17AM (#42708235)
Well, one reason is that your assumption that they are all or mostly inferior is wrong.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:33AM (#42708334)
Suppose you have a kid that you have reason to believe is at the 90th percentile. This isn't uncommon; it's one in ten kids.

The average kid at the average school is at the 50th percentile. Moreover, the speed of the class isn't even the speed of the average kid because then the 40th and 20th percentile kids would get left behind. To get out of this you'd need a school with a gifted program and enough 90th percentile kids to fill it, and many of them don't have one.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by dijksterhuis on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:01AM (#42708867)
the 90th percentile of what?

sport?

english lit?

maths?

music?

socialising?

being the mother hen?

being a jock?

teaching everyone else things in the library?

class clown?

being the wacky one?

skateboarding?

acting?

rebelling?

looking after someone who has just been picked on by all the other kids?

schools introduce us to a wide range of children who are representative of the people we’re going to have to deal with later on in life.

not saying there aren’t alternatives.

but specialising for only the 90th percentile of one thing seems like a way to isolate someone later in life because they may not have learned how to deal with people who aren’t in the 90th percentile of that one thing.

and i say that as someone who hated my time at school and has struggled with the repercussions in later life.

i still learned a lot near the classroom tho.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:45PM (#42715207)
> the 90th percentile of what?

It could be the 90th percentile of science and the 60th percentile of literature and the 40th percentile of music. But if they throw you in with the 50th percentile kids in all cases then you're being held back in science and literature and you're holding back the other kids in music.

> schools introduce us to a wide range of children who are representative of the people we’re going to have to deal with later on in life.

This is why home school families come together so their kids can socialize with one another.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by defrost on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:56AM (#42708478)
Which seems to be an argument to move the child to a school with a gifted program rather than homeschool.

Many homes also lack numerous gifted children and specialist programs.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @03:15AM (#42708576)
> Which seems to be an argument to move the child to a school with a gifted program rather than homeschool.

What if there isn't one within a reasonable distance, or your locality doesn't have school choice?

> Many homes also lack numerous gifted children and specialist programs.

The issue is that you need the absence of children who would hold back the class, not necessarily that you need the presence of other gifted children except insofar as you need to fill out the class, which is not an issue when the class size is one.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by defrost on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:21AM (#42708979)
There are boarding schools, schools of the air, etc. Serious parents can move house for catchments, etc.

I grew some 1,500km north of the nearest city and got by .. still managed to hook up with Terrence Tao and Paul Erdős when I got to university and ran a math club. When one of my kids was ready for high school we got a house in the catchment of the only public school with an aviation program so they could build and fly a light aircraft.

> The issue is that you need the absence of children who would hold back the class,

I enjoyed going to school with hunter gathers in the Kimberley .. I don't feel they held me back, I did get to learn how to fish, to hunt, to swear in several languages.

Despite a lot fighting at high school, on and off the fooball field, I managed to pick up enough abstract algebra to work on CAYLEY/MAGMA which cracked a few quantum encryption candidates recently, enough linear algebra and calculas to author a geophysical processing suite, etc.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @02:04PM (#42715497)
> There are boarding schools, schools of the air, etc. Serious parents can move house for catchments, etc.

Those all sound expensive. Not everyone can afford that.

> I enjoyed going to school with hunter gathers in the Kimberley .. I don't feel they held me back, I did get to learn how to fish, to hunt, to swear in several languages.

Is this something you'd expect to experience in the median US public school?

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by ndriscoll on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @05:12PM (#42717876)
I did learn how to swear in several languages in US public school. I'd expect that's somewhat universal.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by taeric on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:12PM (#42713780)
I find your statistic mistake rather amusing in light of the point you are making. :D

Distributions aren't all normal, for one. And skill levels are often quantized in a way that majority of people will be above a 50% level on it.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:28PM (#42714980)
You're being pedantic. Average in common usage means "middle" as much as "arithmetic mean", and it doesn't really matter to the point whether the mean is above or below the median because all that is necessary to the point is for the 50th percentile to be below the 90th.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by taeric on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:44PM (#42715191)
Ish? Even the common usage of "middle" doesn't necessarily describe where the average student is with regards to any skill they are learning in school. You can argue that we are using a common usage of "average" here, akin to how many fingers does the average human have. But, in a discussion on education, I confess leaning to pedantry seems rather apropos?

My gripe here is the parent post is an appeal to how "average" students are quite bad. But, there is no substantiation to that point. It is, instead, taken as a given in what is essentially a culture war talking point.

It would help if I wasn't exposed to so many parents that are convinced their kids are somehow gifted among gifted kids.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:57PM (#42715377)
> My gripe here is the parent post is an appeal to how "average" students are quite bad. But, there is no substantiation to that point. It is, instead, taken as a given in what is essentially a culture war talking point.

The point isn't that average is bad, it's that your kid probably isn't exactly average.

You could also want to home school them if they're below average, to keep them from getting left behind. The way a lot of public schools treat kids with developmental disabilities is sadly a lot like the way corporations treat cost centers.

> It would help if I wasn't exposed to so many parents that are convinced their kids are somehow gifted among gifted kids.

Everyone thinks they're above average. Around half of them are right.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by taeric on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @04:22PM (#42717201)
I have yet to see this line pushed by anyone that doesn't view dysfunctional classrooms as indicative of what the average student would do. So, fair that I am maybe letting my experience there color my thoughts here.

And I'm somewhat sympathetic to the idea of homeschooling not being an automatic terrible thing. Sold a Story went a long way to convincing me that some really bad choices were made in how to teach reading.

My main nitpick is that that wity quip at the end is not even wrong. Not all values are population weighted, such that you can certainly have some skills where over half of the population is over what you would call average ability.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by jkolio on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:44PM (#42714324)
As someone who was in the 90th percentile, I can confirm that it wasn't a universal quality about my entire being. I got to be in higher-level courses where I excelled. Those are generally available, even in public school systems.

And just because I was good at math and writing didn't mean that I "deserved" to be in some separate system where I got the "best" of everything (with diminishing returns). When I eventually encountered people who were afforded just such a deal ("elite" private school in a wealthy area), they were far less impressive than the top college-level facilities they enjoyed as grade schoolers; it seemed like a waste of money that could have been put to more efficient use, as far as society writ large might be concerned.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @01:41PM (#42715155)
Who is talking about "deserved" or anything like that? Parents want their kids to excel, if they think they can provide that themselves better than what the school is offering then they make the best choice available to them.

> When I eventually encountered people who were afforded just such a deal ("elite" private school in a wealthy area), they were far less impressive than the top college-level facilities they enjoyed as grade schoolers

This is exactly the argument in favor of home schooling. If you just throw money at it but pay little attention to it then you get a beautiful campus with expensive landscaping and not necessarily the highest quality education, because it's easier for parents to judge the quality of the facilities than the quality of the instruction. Whereas if you actually care and you want something done right you have to do it yourself.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by jkolio on Friday January 17, 2025 @11:52AM (#42740140)
Hoity-toity campuses are actually more efficient than every little prince getting his own personal tutor. The problem in both cases is that the parents of these children, as a class, demand the income and social infrastructure necessary to get their children this education, at everyone else's expense.

At some point, the masses say, "No." They realize that they're never getting a seat at that particular table, and turn from fighting over the charity spots to attempts at dismantling their exploitation. From there, you either get a robust public school system that provides a decent education for everyone, or a police state.

Suffice it to say, no one parent's dreams for their kids should come at the expense of another's.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by crabbone on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @09:26AM (#42711108)
> what is there to gain from it?

Humility.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by programjames on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:02PM (#42719624)
Humility is only considered a virtue because the vast majority of people rank their abilities too high. The GP is coming from an assumption that the person is ranked higher than those around them; humbling such a person makes the rankings even more inaccurate.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by crabbone on Thursday January 16, 2025 @08:15AM (#42724676)
This is not why humility is considered a virtue. That's not at all how virtues work. In general, in ethics, there are schools of thought that try to derive ethics from the idea that particular behavior is beneficial to someone / a group in a short term / long term etc. or based on virtues, the transcendental rules that are beyond questioning. These rules don't have to have any tangible benefits, there can be no proof through experimentation that establishes that the rule is right or wrong. Usually, such rules are given through some extra-human authority (a divine revelation, a dream etc.)

People who build their ethics on virtues might believe that, for example, being brave is a virtue. And so, regardless of the consequences, they will aspire to be brave. Similarly, people who believe in virtues will see humility as worth pursuing regardless of whether it makes one better off, long term or short term. It's just good to be humble. End of story.

The reasoning behind non-virtue ethics is usually complicated and subject to debate. It also usually shows that rules derived through such reasoning could contradict the desirable outcomes (that we intuitively find desirable). One of the particularly dangerous and undesirable such outcomes is the belief in moral relativism that opens a door to justifying a lot of actions we'd intuitively find repugnant.

Virtue ethics avoids moral relativism simply by not trying to base ethics in experimentation. Which is why some philosophers find it an appealing approach.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by programjames on Thursday January 16, 2025 @02:47PM (#42729964)
I consider phrases like

> It's just good to be humble. End of story.

to be axiomatic declarations. My issue with these kind of axioms is they're not really necessary. You can get everything useful by only considering things that are good for somebody. Now, we don't live in a perfectly informed and rational society, so it can be good (for society) to indoctrinate everyone with this axiom. But, as with all axioms, not everyone will believe in them. So, if I'm told,

"You need to be more humble, it's a virtue,"

that's begging the question! I need some external reason to either adopt the axiom or humility. Society as a whole seems to have adopted this axiom, but why is that? There was probably an evolution of axioms, where ones that didn't work got rejected, while ones that mostly worked got inculcated. I think most people overestimate their abilities, which would lead to fighting over positional goods. I think the role of the humility axiom is to prevent such fighting, but it comes with drawbacks.

Since the Enlightenment, most wealth has been created by thinking really hard. This means you really want to rank people near the top accurately, so you can give them resources to go and create their ideas. The axiom of humility regresses everyone toward the mean—which is great when the GDP is measured in bushels, but not so great when it is measured in transistors.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by matrix87 on Thursday January 16, 2025 @08:17PM (#42733003)
Humility is relative. Humility in front of actual experts is good. It has to be earned

Becoming humble in front of people who suck is learning the wrong life lesson

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by __loam on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:52AM (#42713440)
I hate this fucking site lol
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by gm678 on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:15PM (#42713825)
> Homo sum, humani nihil a me alienum puto.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by jkolio on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @12:34PM (#42714130)
When my car broke down in the middle of a DoorDash run, I walked to a nearby park and sat next to a homeless guy who was about my age. He was deaf; we talked via text on our phones about how we'd ended up on the same bench, and I shared some of my food. I learned from him how resilient someone can be, even under incredibly unfair circumstances, but more importantly, he got something to eat.

It's not all about you.

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by programjames on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @07:58PM (#42719583)
Exactly. It's not all about you. It's best for the community to encourage education, and dragging down students who actually care about education does the opposite.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by jkolio on Friday January 17, 2025 @12:00PM (#42740311)
Your selfishness is not equal to my desire for common prosperity. If anything, lone wolf-ism is what drags us down (no matter how proficient the wolf thinks he is). We live in a society.
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by matrix87 on Friday January 17, 2025 @04:48PM (#42743623)
> lone wolf-ism is what drags us down

with respect to what metric? economic growth? that's probably not true, lone wolfism is what drives people to develop expertise in the first place

if the metric is community or "sustainability" or something else, is pursuing that metric in the place of economic growth sustainable long term?

Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by matrix87 on Thursday January 16, 2025 @08:03PM (#42732911)
You and the homeless guy aren't peers, you just did a nice thing. You're not going to classes with him or working alongside him
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by jkolio on Friday January 17, 2025 @11:54AM (#42740203)
I was (and remain) a few bad breaks from his situation. I'm not responsible for his state, but we absolutely are peers (i.e., same age, facing the same broad socioeconomic environment).
Re:Why are tech people suddenly so into homeschooling? by programjames on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @07:51PM (#42719505)
> If those people have worse habits, are less motivated, less educated, less cultured, what is there to gain from it?

The appearance of humility^[0]? I don't really see what there is to gain either.

[0]: Autobiography of Benjamin Franklin, Section II, Paragraph 9