News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by geuis on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:37PM (#42670459)
Ok I'm getting tired of this habit of deep linking to apps. The apps either override existing web pages featuring the same content, or there's a web redirect to an app I might have installed but am not signed into. So in multiple cases, it's difficult to just read whatever the information is.

Web pages are universally accessible. Everyone has a browser on their device of choice. The web is 35 years old. Access to information is a solved problem.

Guess I'm just complaining. There are just so many links being submitted to HN these days that require accounts or specific apps installed. Feels like there should be a rule around this.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by hipadev23 on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:39PM (#42670472)
The link works fine for me? Not logged in nor do I have bluesky. Loads in chrome, I can see the 3 images, and quite a few comments beneath their post
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by dbetteridge on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:41PM (#42670479)
Nah totally agreed, pet peeve of mine is trying to open a link in my browser to a website and my phone decides it knows better and insists on redirecting me to "The App" (which I've never installed and don't want, so it sends me to download it)
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by esperent on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:51PM (#42670543)
I don't have the bsky app, nor am I logged in on my phone's browser, and this opened fine for me. No app redirects.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by 0x38B on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:13PM (#42670656)
If you’re on iOS, long-pressing on the bsky.app link in Safari and choosing “open” will open the link in Safari and remember your choice; the same works for YouTube links, etc.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by isatty on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:41PM (#42670480)
What is being deeplinked? I was able to read the page and click on the pictures all in my browser (iOS safari).
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by hombre_fatal on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:49PM (#42670528)
They mean how the phone lets apps handle browser urls instead of just opening the url in the browser.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by ludwik on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:11PM (#42670646)
That’s not deep linking (i.e., something set up by the person posting the link). It’s simply the specific device being configured to handle regular web links differently.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by geuis on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:20PM (#42670701)
I know what you're referring to. However there's no ability on iOS to control this behavior.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by jdiff on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:59PM (#42670920)
There is but it's not intuitive. Long press on a link and you can open it without it being sent away and apparently this sticks.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by dillydogg on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:45PM (#42670507)
I think this must be a setting on your device to open links in the app.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by jeffbee on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:41PM (#42670481)
What are you even talking about? It is literally a website.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by geuis on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:53PM (#42670554)
I have the Bluesky app installed but I'm not logged in. So the website link is also being treated as an app deep link. It opens the app instead of just opening the website.

I don't have a lot of familiarity with app deep links, but my understanding is that originally deep links required a special non-domain to be registered that was separate from a normal web url.

Somewhere that's changed over the years and now regular web links like this default to opening in apps if the user has them installed.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by mr_mitm on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:09PM (#42670634)
There is no such thing as a deep link. If you don't like how your client device handles links, re-configure it or, if that's not possible, use a different device. The problem here is on your end.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by ludwik on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:01PM (#42670593)
But that's not OP deep linking to an app - it's just a normal website URL. It's you having your user agent configured to launch an app for this particular domain. Nothing that OP can do about that.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by lucb1e on Saturday January 11, 2025 @10:31PM (#42671077)
> my understanding is that originally deep links required a special non-domain to be registered that was separate from a normal web url.

You might be thinking of protocol handlers, like oacon:// to open something in software installed to handle that (in this case, launching openarena to connect directly from a dpmaster mirror with such application links included). I don't think they were called deep links back then, just different protocols, like http in http://example.org is a protocol that your browser is configured to handle and ftp:// used to be as well

These are still in relatively common use today, but on mobile devices it has become the norm to hijack specific domain names or even a path (e.g. F-Droid will try to handle repositories on third-party domains for you by trying to hook¹ any URL that contains */fdroid/repo/* -- so far, this has always been useful to me, but I can see the flip side). This link hijacking is often a pain for me as anyone linking to any Google product will make my phone try to open some Play Services component, which is largely not functional. I can't get rid of the system component (e.g. replace it with microG) without installing a custom ROM, which I can't do without getting rid of half the device's special features (no point having this phone then), but I also don't want it pinging back to the mothership so... a pain it shall be

As for your problem, reset the app's settings and it'll re-prompt you the next time you click one of these links in which app these links should open. It should do that any time there is (newly) more than one app that can handle any given URL

¹ https://github.com/f-droid/fdroidclient/blob/be028d71c2a25b9...

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by dunham on Saturday January 11, 2025 @10:32PM (#42671079)
On iOS the app can ask to take over certain https urls. The web site also needs to have a special file to grant this access. Bluesky is choosing to do this to you. I used this for a login / reset flow about a decade ago, so it's been around for a while.

There also is the ability to register for a URL "scheme" (the bit that replaces "https"), which I believe is what you're thinking of and it does predate the https thing, but both have been around for a while. I'm guessing companies have just gotten more aggressive about using the https one.

Edit: and yes it is annoying, I've uninstalled the GitHub app because of this.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by lynndotpy on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:01PM (#42670599)
Is your device running iOS or iPadOS? This is default and non-configurable behavior. Even github.com will open in the GitHub app if you have it installed.

I understand the confusion (and frustration), but this is just a normal URL. The .app is just an ordinary TLD (but one of the newer ones.)

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by HelloImSteven on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:10PM (#42670643)
On Apple devices at least, this is a feature of Universal Links, which are generally more secure than deeplinks for various reasons [1]. Not sure you can disable it completely, but in some cases you can override it by long-pressing the link and choosing to open it in the browser.

[1] https://developer.apple.com/documentation/xcode/defining-a-c...

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by Gigachad on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:18PM (#42670691)
Remove the app then?

Having an app installed but logged out is such a rare case, and one that’s easily solved.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by jeffbee on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:57PM (#42670570)
I use Bluesky all the time and I have never installed the app on any platform. I suggest getting rid of it, if you're such a fan of the web.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by deadbabe on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:44PM (#42670491)
The nefarious thing is some people will tell you there’s nothing wrong with the link and gaslight you into thinking you’re crazy – because they don’t have the Bluesky app installed.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by mr_mitm on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:50PM (#42670538)
What is it that is supposed to be wrong with the link? .app is a regular TLD, the host name resolves to a regular IP address and there is a regular web server returning regular HTML.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by lynndotpy on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:57PM (#42670572)
On iOS and iPadOS, even github.com links will do this with the GitHub app installed.

We're complaining about a completely normal URL that links to a normal webpage. This is very, very silly.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by uoaei on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:04PM (#42670609)
What is the use of a Github app on iPhone or iPad? I guess I could see it useful for reviewing pull requests and making comments if it's urgent (it's not) or your main dev device is out of reach (it can wait)...
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by lynndotpy on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:19PM (#42670696)
I wanted to have a widget of my commit graph; it's nice to see the little squares filled up. When I clicked a github link and my screen started bouncing and sliding around, I was very displeased.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by nick__m on Saturday January 11, 2025 @10:15PM (#42670999)
There is nothing wrong with the link. The only thing wrong is your poor understanding of your user agent behavior !
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by Aurornis on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:48PM (#42670526)
> and gaslight you

I have the Bluesky app installed and did not see a pop-up. It’s not “gaslighting”. It’s people having different experiences due to different OSes and settings.

It’s amazing how meaningless the word gaslighting has become.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by jeffbee on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:45PM (#42670513)
You're saying the OP has configured their user agent to launch an app for this URL and somehow that's me gaslighting?
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by danparsonson on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:49PM (#42670532)
I imagine that's the joke they're making, yes
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by benreesman on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:10PM (#42670639)
I don’t know why you’re getting dogpiled over this, it’s a terrible experience of creeping non-consensual computation.

I had the official bsky app installed, but I ended up with Graysky at some point and just forgot about it, and somewhere along the way my browser vendor (Apple) and the app vendor (bsky) decided that I would probably tolerate this horseshit. Reddit pulls the same shit but that’s extra special because it’s broken, so it goes to the App Store screen for Reddit and you just can’t load it at all without a laptop.

If you’re one of the people arguing this is cool you’re ugly and stupid like people who disagree with Linus.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by jdiff on Saturday January 11, 2025 @10:02PM (#42670934)
Your device is misconfigured. That's not HN's fault, what has been posted is a completely ordinary link that would function in a perfectly ordinary way if you had configured your device properly.

This wouldn't even be CLOSED WONTFIX, there is literally nothing that anyone but you could do to fix this.

Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by yarg on Saturday January 11, 2025 @09:27PM (#42670741)
Because the problem is perfectly avoidable with very little technical understanding, and this is Hacker News.
Re:Adobe Lightroom's AI Remove feature added a Bitcoin to bi... by never_inline on Sunday January 12, 2025 @10:03AM (#42674034)
> non consensual computation

Gonna steal this one.