I think it is no longer relevant. How much of the needs are met is decided by the social media now.
I personally know people making life altering decisions based on the fake news. Their world is detached from the reality in such a way, that they don't believe their own eyes.
People now see a world mostly thought the screen of their phone.
> I think that is no longer relevant.
Try reading some of the NYT's long-running coverage, about how life has gone down, down, downhill for "the other half" of America, over the past half-ish century.
Or read some of the backstory on the 1994 Contract with American/Republican Revolution, and think about why huge numbers American voters - most of whom had historically voted democratic - were so unhappy that they switched to the Republicans.
Or check out some of the US Govt's stuff on that - say, https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/republicans/2019... (2019)
Things were going to hell, for a whole lotta Americans, long before there were smart phones.
My point is that it is the natural consequence of people losing the ability to agree on what is actually going on.
When you lose grip on reality, you lose the ability to make any meaningful change.
"Things are going okay for me, and mine, and the folks I care about". Which is all about PoV, not some objective facts.
And when people are really hurting and angry - their words and actions will be all about voicing their painful emotions and acting accordingly. Not ivory-tower truths.
Have things improved? If not, perhaps they need to consider another tactic than voting for Republicans.
During the downhill slide, the Romans tried to codify loads of their previously unwritten rules - about how gov't officials were chosen, what they were allowed to do, etc. That really didn't help.
[0] "The Soviet Collapse: Grain and Oil By Yegor Gaidar" https://tamilnation.org/intframe/070419collapse_of_soviet_un...
Hitler was a really smart guy, young and energetic at this time, evil yes, but he definitely had plans, not sure the USA has one right now though...
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025
[1]https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jan/08/trump-projec...
[2]https://www.afge.org/article/new-trump-administration-packed...
I find it hard to imagine Hitler behaving in the same way. I'm sure he took advise, but yeah, seemed very hands on and strategic and idealistic.
Edit: Just reading the section there on nuclear proliferation, man, we're not going to make it are we? Right wing people think Biden was going to start WW3, I can't thin k of a better way to provoke even our allies than going through with that plan.
I think the lesson that gets lost with Hitler analogies is that authoritarianism, when it arises, does so in a unique cultural context. I can see Trump kind of being a figurehead and patsy for the more organized and directed forces around him, depending on how well he can be manipulated. History doesn't have to repeat but it can rhyme.
It's like this nonsense with Greenland and Canada. It should be too ridiculous to take seriously, and yeah it probably won't come to anything, because Trump and Musk talk shit all the time, but then we live in a time where the most potent political force in the Western world started as a 4chan shitpost and Elon Musk is basically co-President who knows what the parameters of reality even are anymore?
I'm sure there is one. It is just that the Zaphod-like (though devoid of his sense of style) two-headed mess that is President Shart and Rabid Lapdog Musk are doing a good job of being a distraction from the people with the plan.
If the people really believe in a system of government, then you don't need any words-on-paper constitutions or laws or stuff.
If the people have really lost faith in the system (generally because it repeatedly failed to meet their basic needs), then all the pieces of paper and fancy-looking buildings and robed officials in the world don't count for shit.