News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by aimazon on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:40PM (#42626465)
Fact checkers are the technocratic solution, they're a panel of experts to Community Note's jury of our peers. Fact checkers are a much better product feature than community notes if we want a feature that best serves people who care about facts. That's not our world, though. People don't care about facts, we are humans, our lives are lived based on vibes. The average person would rather listen to their idiot friend's uneducated thoughts about transgender women in sport than listen to a lecture from an expert. Community notes is probably a better feature for the real world, but it's still junk, "effective" is not a label the feature deserves, because the majority of misinformation on X goes un-noted.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mhh__ on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:15PM (#42626909)
"People don't care about facts" is such an asinine reactionary way of thinking about macro dynamics in the world. It has no predictive power at all.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by aredox on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:16PM (#42627599)
Americans don't care about facts.

There's a reason why you have Creationists at the highest levels of government.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by _DeadFred_ on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:24PM (#42627699)
Unnecessary attacks like this don't help your cause and part of what has driven the other side to the point they are at.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mindslight on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:41PM (#42630654)
Do you mean that OP is incorrect, or just impertinent? Just because you have to use a light touch does not mean your friend does not have a Problem. (And I'm speaking as an American)
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by aredox on Sunday January 12, 2025 @07:15PM (#42678490)
"Look at what you made me do"

No, you never had any moral backbone and you are just looking at the first excuse to behave like the psycho you have always been.

The only other possible explanation is that you are stuck at the psychological maturity of a small child, throwing a destructive tantrum any time anyone opposes you.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mhh__ on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:38PM (#42629065)
Europeans are just as silly but mistake failure for sincerity. As a sad fantasist I'm immensely fond of Anglo culture but many brits are totally misaligned and insane.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by aimazon on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:33PM (#42627086)
We don’t. People are social. We care about what the people in our community think, whether it’s factually accurate or not is inconsequential. Those of us wasting our lives arguing on the internet in the pursuit of truth are a tiny minority of atypical people. People yearn for the warm embrace of affirmation, not the cold hard truth challenging them at every turn.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by encoderer on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:31PM (#42627791)
You have too many abstractions between you and understanding other people.

Most people in your country are actually not that different from you.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by HappMacDonald on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:56PM (#42627354)
Well first you've got to define what is meant by "facts". Most people presume the word refers to some kind of community consensus, and then they immediately gatekeep what counts as the "community" among which the consensus is shared.

However the basis for fact is precisely predictive power, so it's actually more like the battle between science and superstition. Information that can directly empower a person is not necessarily information that will help them to feel more comfortable or confirm their biases.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by intended on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:08PM (#42627478)
It’s true. Fact checking was found to scarcely impact misinfo.

I’m in the field and I am thinking of how to work without focusing on truth, because that’s how most humans work!

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by cryptonector on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:33PM (#42627089)
It resembles Objectivism. "The facts are the facts and you should see them the same way I do or else!!"
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by kergonath on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:57PM (#42628114)
More like “the facts are the facts and reality does not care if you don’t believe in it”. It’s a special kind of nihilism to want to stick it to the universe and insist on one’s own alternative reality like an overgrown angry teenager edgelord.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by cryptonector on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:43PM (#42628586)
Ayn Rand was pretty insistent that we should be able to objectively ascertain the facts. Objectivism failed precisely because we're not really all that rational, and because apart from the irrational part of us there's also the fact that we can manipulate perception and gaslight others. If you're a newcomer to a pair of groups that vehemently disagree as to the facts you might soon find that you have to make a choice yourself as to which group to join, and suddenly you have to deal with social pressures not just facts. Do you want to be in the in-group or in the out-group? Can you deal with the shaming that goes with being in the out-group? Etc.

It's all so tedious, but this is what we humans are like.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by freshpots on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:01PM (#42629263)
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by jimbokun on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @05:23PM (#42628402)
Do you have some kind of analysis demonstrating Facebook fact checkers are more accurate than X’s Community Notes?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by voskresenie on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @07:35PM (#42629530)
Breaking: Leading Fact Checkers Investigate, Find Leading Fact Checkers More Accurate Than Community Notes.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:33PM (#42630936)
Indeed, how to fact check the fact checkers?

If we could have legitimate fact checking that really works, then I guess we wouldn't need any politics at all.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ad_hockey on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:31AM (#42632239)
> Indeed, how to fact check the fact checkers?

Like any other work, it can be reviewed by supervisors within the company and/or the client (Meta). If a sample of an employee's work shows that they often hide content that isn't factually false, they are performing their job poorly. If Meta doesn't like the job the company is doing, the contract can be cancelled.

> If we could have legitimate fact checking that really works, then I guess we wouldn't need any politics at all.

You absolutely need both. Politics is about which decisions to make within the context of shared facts. The amount of the US national debt, the number of people caught crossing the border illegally in 2024, or the number of people sleeping on the streets in San Francisco are all matters of fact. What to do about them is politics.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:55AM (#42632610)
It are also facts that many politicians are corrupt and are fooling us. But they arranged it nicely so that they aren't being fact checked.

And the ones in power and with money can decide who the fact checkers will be. And the ones in power and with money can help and support each other. Because we want to keep the money inside the family, to protect the facts you know.

When you grow up you start to understand that you can't trust all authority all the time.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ad_hockey on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:05AM (#42632682)
I was answering your question. You asked how fact checkers can be fact checked and the answer is like any other job. Fact checking isn't magic, and it's existed for a long time. It's basically what newspaper sub-editors do.

> When you grow up you start to understand that you can't trust all authority all the time.

I think you know I'm not arguing for this. Don't misrepresent my position, please.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:33AM (#42632815)
Well I think what you are calling fact checking is actually journalism.

The concept of fact checking is a very recent movement, with the idea that we could filter out the "fake news" on the internet, which is also a recent concept.

But it turned out that the so called "fake news" wans't always so fake, and that the fact checkers weren't always so factual.

So it turns out that you can't trust any group to determine what the facts are for the rest of the people.

You can fact-check for yourself, but don't put your "facts" on other people like they're real facts. Leave other people in their respect, and let them think for themselves. You can of course share your knowledge, but you should let the other person ultimately decide what they believe for themselves.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ad_hockey on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @05:52AM (#42632903)
It sounds like you are disagreeing with the concept of facts, but facts do exist. If someone claims that a politician said a particular thing in a speech yesterday, and the politician gave no speech yesterday, then the claim is factually false. It's not a matter of respect or disrespect to say so, and it doesn't matter what you choose to believe on that topic.

> The concept of fact checking is a very recent movement, with the idea that we could filter out the "fake news" on the internet, which is also a recent concept.

Again, this is not accurate. Look at the job sub-editors have been doing for a century or more. Their main role is to save the newspaper from getting sued or looking silly by striking out or questioning any claim that can't be proven to be true, or corroborated by multiple sources. Fact checking is not a new discipline.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:03AM (#42632962)
Well it has a lot to do also with the way you say things, how you interpret the words. Maybe the politician did give some kind of speech, but maybe it wasn't an official speech. There's always more to the story, and multiple ways of interpreting things.

Of course some facts are less flexible than others. Like most people wouldn't argue whether a football is round. Although it matters if you're talking about an American football or a soccer football. So context also matters, and that can be confusing sometimes.

So the facts that the fact checkers were called in to tackle, were so flexible that it turns out it's not doable in a secure way.

And newspapers also don't always have the correct facts. Often things in the newspapers are wrong. And no they are not always being sued for that.

Again, you can fact-check for yourself, that is totally fine, and I would even encourage it. Then you make up your own mind and you are more independent and less shapable by others.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Friday January 10, 2025 @10:59PM (#42663169)
Hey, some news came out that might give you an insight to why the fact checking might not always work:

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/01/10/mark-zuckerberg-says-biden-p...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ad_hockey on Saturday January 11, 2025 @06:24AM (#42665136)
I sort of don't want to get into specific moderation examples, especially with Covid, because so many aspects of Covid are contentious. I'd just point out that this example has nothing to do with third party fact checkers, it was direct influence from a government on Meta; that can and will still happen even with Zuckerberg's policy changes. In fact I'd argue it will be even more likely now. If Meta had a robust policy on fact checking and removal of harmful content, that would be a weapon to push back on government interference.

It's also not necessary for third party fact checking to "always work" to have value, there will be some level of false positive rate that's still acceptable. Even with something like Covid, there is unambiguously false information with probably harmful consequences ("you can cure Covid by drinking a bottle of bleach", for example) that would be worth taking down by fact checkers.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Saturday January 11, 2025 @08:01AM (#42665572)
If fact checking doesn't necessarily "always work", then you should not call it fact checking. That is already a great reason why Community Notes are better.

And, don't you see the connection? If the government can tell Facebook to censor content, they can also tell them what facts to publish.

Community Notes is from the community, not from Facebook, so not directly influencable by the government. The government could of course tell Facebook to censor certain Community Notes, but the community would notice. With the fact checkers, which are in the hands of Facebook, the community doesn't know.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ad_hockey on Sunday January 12, 2025 @07:05AM (#42672976)
> If fact checking doesn't necessarily "always work", then you should not call it fact checking. That is already a great reason why Community Notes are better.

You can still call it fact checking, just as you can still call air travel by that name even though a very small percentage of planes crash. Suppose the fact checkers had a 0.1% false positive rate and a 0% false negative rate. For every 1,000 pieces of reported content they review which should be left up, they take one down, and they never leave anything up that should be taken down. Wouldn't we say that the system, broadly speaking, works and has value? Even though it doesn't always work?

Do you think Community Notes will "always work"?

> Community Notes is from the community, not from Facebook, so not directly influencable by the government.

It wouldn't work like this. Meta still own the platform, profit from it, and are responsible for it.

Governments will always want to talk to Meta about the material they host, because Facebook reaches millions of people. Sometimes the governments will have a valid case, like when material on Facebook can be linked to inciting genocide[1]. And sometimes they won't, and will be trying to pressurise Facebook for political or self-serving reasons. The point is, those governments will not simply be satisfied and go away if Meta throw their hands in the air and say "Sorry, but we fired the fact checkers and have no control over the material on our platform. It's up to the community, talk to them."

If Meta are trying to solve the government interference problem, the solution is to strengthen their fact checking and moderation systems. Then they'd be able to push back and say that actually no, they are confident that the content on Facebook is appropriate and can credibly stand by it. Abdicating responsibility is just going to get them into more trouble.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohingya_genocide#Facebook_con...

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by gitaarik on Sunday January 12, 2025 @03:24PM (#42676585)
Well as long as we can't guarantee that fact checking is so secure with such a low error rate, we shouldn't call it fact checking.

That's already a great reason why Community Notes are better, just because of the name.

Aside from that, if the community is making notes, and the government censors or modifies it, the community would be able to find it out. With an internal fact checking department, the community wouldn't know.

Of course the government will still try to take as much control as they can. So this news should also make us aware of the fact that such huge global networks are not a safe place anyway for independent thinking.