News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:53AM (#42622962)
> And why aren't you considering the countervailing harm to society of centralized moderation?

Are there reproducible studies showing that? What is the effect size?

(These objections go both ways!)

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mike_hearn on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:27AM (#42624200)
Arguably they don't go both ways. The distinction is action vs inaction. If someone wants action from someone else, they need to argue the case for that action. Arguing for not doing something on the other hand is never necessary.

To see why, consider that the space of possible actions someone could not take is infinite. If there's an expectation that someone do a ton of research and work to argue for why they are not doing something, then the amount of work they would have to do is thus also infinite. This way lies madness, which is why in reality the default outcome that results from not acting is always taken as a given.

Sometimes this reality is obfuscated by activists. They find some group of people who are just doing their thing, and demand that those people do some extra things (usually some costly things). The arguments they make for this are weak, but when the targeted people say they'd rather not do those extra things the activists demand their targets argue for not doing what the activists want to whatever level of effort (or greater) they themselves made. This can be an effective bullying tactic but isn't legitimate: it's on those who want action to argue the case for it, not those who don't to argue against.

Digital platforms like social networks default to uncensored. If the operators do nothing, then by the way they are built content is allowed. It takes additional work to categorize posts and block certain kinds of content. So the default outcome is free speech. If someone wants someone else to do work to suppress that, then it's on them to prove that it's truly necessary and that the benefits outweigh the harms. But that doesn't cut both ways; it's not required for other people to take on the argument for free speech. That's the default outcome so it just wins by default if the other side can't prove their case to a sufficiently convincing level.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:58AM (#42624588)
Choosing not to act is an action. The choice not to moderate certain content is a choice to permit certain content.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mike_hearn on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @12:51PM (#42625196)
Not acting is, by definition, not an action.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:12PM (#42625421)
I see someone drowning. I have a life ring. I choose not to throw it to them. They drown. Did I act?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duty_(criminal_law)

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mike_hearn on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:28PM (#42625630)
No! First sentence:

> Duty (criminal law), is an obligation to act under which failure to act (omission), results in criminal liability

You failed to act, which is why a law is sometimes required to compel action. However, saving a drowning person isn't something that triggers such a legal obligation in the USA unless you're the person who actually pushed someone into the water in the first place.

I don't get why this thread is getting so long or so abstract. The principles here are straightforward. Facebook don't actually have to care about what arguments activists make, but even if they did, it's on activists to win the argument for what they want. You don't get to automatically have your own way unless someone sits down and does a randomized controlled trial showing that you're wrong - and this is independent of what domain we're talking about.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:56PM (#42625932)
> I don't get why this thread is getting so long or so abstract

Activists use abstraction to attempt to overcome settled understandings and norms. Of course there is a distinction between action and inaction—as you recognize it’s even a legally significant distinction. The very existence of that norm is the reason anyone would say “inaction is really a form of action.”

It’s like how the notion of “antiracism” is an effort to reframe race neutrality as a form of racism.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @02:05PM (#42626027)
But we're not talking about only the legal obligations. Plenty would argue that a person with a life ring and a drowning person in front of them have a moral imperative to act; the court of public opinion would be certainly negative about a video of someone casually watching the person die while holding the means to save them, even if you can't criminally prosecute.

In this particular case, changing the rules (and making the blog post explaining those changes!) is pretty clearly an action.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:28PM (#42627037)
Here, the law flows from the moral judgment that there’s a fundamental distinction between action and inaction. Otherwise, you’d be morally culpable for not basically enslaving ourself to helping whenever happens to be the poorest.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:01PM (#42627394)
In my example, you'd be comfortable morally with "inaction"?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by hollerith on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @12:53PM (#42625208)
Sure, but not choosing is a choice.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by mike_hearn on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:05PM (#42625342)
That's not really how language works. If not choosing to do something is a choice, then today we have all made an infinite number of choices. Nobody would ever express themselves that way.

But even if you want to play word games, choices and actions aren't the same thing. Choosing to act is quantitively different from choosing not to act because it involves a different level of effort. It's wrong to assume that they are morally equal.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by hollerith on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:16PM (#42625460)
>then today we have all made an infinite number of choices

The way I like to think about it is that once a choice has risen to the level of conscious awareness, it is an illusion that a person can just decline to choose.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by Timon3 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:06PM (#42628806)
This seems to be presuming that there is some clear delineation between acting and not acting, but going through some daily occurrences it's difficult for me to find an objective line, mostly because there are choices one could make that allow one to call something inaction while it requires active action.

Say for example I'm passing by a beggar on my way to work. Before deciding whether I give them money, I can first decide to ignore or not ignore them. From a basic human perspective I want to say hello and be friendly (and I choose to do this), but it does make me feel worse if I decline than if I had ignored them, exactly because it makes it feel like a choice. But if I ignore them, can I call passing by without giving them money less of a choice? I only moved my choice up one level in the tree of all possible decisions I can make.

Or, moving it to the example of the drowning man: imagine you're holding out your arm to see how long you can do it, and see the life ring flying towards you. If you choose not to act, it'll hang on your arm, and the person will drown. Is it nevertheless inaction on your part?

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by rayiner on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:16AM (#42623221)
There’s lots of mainstream media content I think is psychologically harmful and should be suppressed, such as content normalizing adultery. But I’m quite content to live in a society where the social norm favors people saying what they want and the burden is on the opponents of that to produce strong evidence of harm.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by myvoiceismypass on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:50AM (#42623671)
Which studies have you read that show the psychological harm of seeing adulterous content?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:26AM (#42623339)
Convenient that only your debate opponents need provide reproducible studies that meet your standards.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by layer8 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:27AM (#42624197)
No, this is the “presumed innocent until proven guilty” principle.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by threatofrain on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @12:13PM (#42624750)
But all we see are two proponents in a civil trial. Shouldn't the standard be the well known western standard "preponderance of evidence"?

Though personally preponderance of evidence seems to be a shitty standard too because I might be listening to two awful theories and be forced to conclude one is the winner. Theories should rise above a minimum threshold to even consider sniffing at before we consider one as superior over the other.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by layer8 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:48PM (#42625830)
I agree that there needs to be a better standard than just “more likely than not”. Freedom of expression is a fundamental good, and there should be clear evidence of harm outweighing that good, before curtailing it.

Regarding my previous comment, my intent was to point out the GP comment’s position (because the parent’s comment seemed to be beside the point), not necessarily to endorse it.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:50AM (#42624480)
Why does that principle not apply to “moderation is bad”?
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by n4r9 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:46AM (#42623620)
Right. The challenge for free speech absolutists is to demonstrate that free speech takes priority over moderating hate speech, adult content, highly addictive media etc... . That demonstration needs to evidence-based and framed in terms of short and long term social harms/impact. Simply saying "censorship hasn't gone well for some countries" or "having a free speech zone is extremely important to the future of civilization" is not enough.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by nradov on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:32AM (#42624264)
No, that's not how this works. By default everything permitted. The entire burden of evidence rests on those who want bans or restrictions.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by n4r9 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:39AM (#42624349)
Hmm. Who decides "how this works"?

Consider hate speech. There is a clear short-term benefit of moderation: reducing the harms to marginalised people from being exposed to threats to their person, identity, and way of life. In the face of this benefit, the absolute free speech advocate must provide a counter-argument for why free speech overrides that harm-reduction.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by logicchains on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:12PM (#42625419)
>reducing the harms to marginalised people from being exposed to threats to their person, identity, and way of life

This only makes sense if you use a recent definition of "harm" created by censorship advocates that's divorced from the traditional meaning. In criminal law, harm traditionally (and still does in America) mean actually physically harming someone's body or making threats to do so. Censorship advocates are the ones making the claim that mere words should also constitute harm, so the onus is on them to justify why they want to change the meaning of the word like that.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by ceejayoz on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:31PM (#42625666)
> In criminal law, harm traditionally (and still does in America) mean actually physically harming someone's body or making threats to do so.

Fraud can be criminal, without bodily harm or threats.

Verbal child abuse can be criminal, without bodily harm or threats.

There are lots of criminal harms not covered by your claimed definition in the American legal system.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by n4r9 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:17PM (#42626939)
Yes, here I am using "harm" in the common sense of physical or mental/psychological suffering.
Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zahlman on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:20PM (#42630198)
>In the face of this benefit, the absolute free speech advocate must provide a counter-argument for why free speech overrides that harm-reduction.

Why are you not the one who must provide an argument for why this "reduction of harm" overrides the benefit of freedom of speech?

Further, a very large fraction of what I have seen classified as "hate speech" simply cannot reasonably be argued to constitute any kind of threat.

Finally: what do you mean by "identity"? When I have seen this term used by opponents of "hate speech", it generally seems to refer to something like a person's self-image. I cannot understand how this can in principle be "threatened", nor how it could constitute harm to learn that someone else sees you differently from how you see yourself.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by n4r9 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:10AM (#42633795)
> why this "reduction of harm" overrides the benefit of freedom of speech

There are some strong arguments for harm reduction being a more fundamental human value than freedom of speech. Firstly, the modern conception of freedom of speech is often seen to be grounded in libertarian thought, in particular the works of Bentham and Mill. Yet Mill himself explicitly stated that these freedoms should be limited in the case where they cause harm to others; freedom of speech has historically been seen as lower priority to harm reduction. Secondly, there are in fact two competing interpretations for "freedom of speech": on one hand the equality of access to a public forum, on the other hand the ability to say whatever you want. I say "competing" because in a public forum without moderation, the tendency is for loud and offensive voices to drown out the discourse, effectively leaving marginalised people without a voice. This is especially potent in modern social media. Thirdly, history suggests that it's problematic for ideological values to trump the basic tenet of harm reduction. We see this for example in the Catholic church's refusal to support abortion rights or the use of condoms to prevent AIDs. If we don't ultimately assess the long-term social impact of a "core moral value" in terms of harm and flourishing, then we risk entrapping ourselves in an ideological morass.

> what do you mean by "identity"? ... I cannot understand how this can in principle be "threatened"

As an example, homophobic comments are an attack on the sexual identity of homosexual people. It sends a message that they are unacceptable to society due to their inherent preferences, and that they should not express themselves as they naturally wish to. This causes psychological suffering.

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by zahlman on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:16PM (#42630184)
>The challenge for free speech absolutists is to demonstrate that free speech takes priority over

Why? And how, in principle? Why is the burden of evidence not on others - and equally, how, in principle, could they furnish evidence?

The entire point is that freedom of speech is a core moral value; they have weighed the potential harms and come out against censorship, because they consider censorship to be inherently harmful. There is no objective way to compare different kinds of harm to each other; each individual's moral values are what they are.

When a free speech absolutist argues that freedom of speech is more important than whatever goal the censor has in mind, that argument is of fundamentally the same kind as the censor's argument, just with opposite polarity. When the censor says that "hate speech" needs to be prohibited, that, too, is based on a relative weighing of values and purported rights (i.e. freedom from hearing it).

Re:More Speech and Fewer Mistakes by emtel on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @11:35PM (#42630953)
You’re presuming that the debate has to be carried out according to utilitarian rules (do benefits of free speech outweigh harms caused by certain speech). But why should it be?