News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by jsnell on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:05PM (#42613207)
> This is especially apparent when you're trying to calculate "how much time until my next meeting?", and your next meeting is at noon. If it's 11:55, you would usually mentally subtract and conclude: the meeting is in 5 minutes. That's how I always do it myself anyway! But the most probable estimate given the available information is actually 4'30"!

Ok. But what does it mean for a meeting to start at 12:00 when people don't have clocks that will accurately show 12:00? They'll only know when the time is 11:59:30 or 12:00:30, anything between is just going to be a guess. So it seems to me that the start times would just align to the half-minute offsets instead, and we'd be back exactly where we started but with more complexity.

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by FartyMcFarter on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:29PM (#42613559)
> If it's 11:55, you would usually mentally subtract and conclude: the meeting is in 5 minutes. That's how I always do it myself anyway! But the most probable estimate given the available information is actually 4'30"!

The way I like to think about it is "the meeting is in less than 5 minutes". Which is always correct since my reaction time to seeing the clock switching to 11:55 is greater than zero.

It could even be less than 4 minutes if it has already switched to 11:56 and I haven't had time to react to that change, but that's OK - my assessment that I have less than 5 minutes to get to the meeting is still correct.

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by timerol on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:51PM (#42613896)
If you care about starting a meeting to within better precision than a minute, use a clock that shows seconds. If I want to start a meeting at noon, I don't block off the minute display of my clock and wait for the 11 -> 12 transition to start the meeting.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by xattt on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:17PM (#42613381)
All broadcast studios are equipped with master clocks that show seconds to deal with this ambiguity.

You can look at your own watch and anticipate when program transitions in radio or TV are supposed to take place (usually the minute and 30 second marks). Also, get a sense when a host is filling time to get to the transition.

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by dylan604 on Monday January 06, 2025 @02:00PM (#42614049)
I've done a lot of work with hosts on various shows. One guy stood out more than others on being so natural on the vamp/stretch to fill the time. Starting at 5mins, we give one minute signals. Not once did it ever sound unnatural in trying to rush or filled with ums, uhs, or ahs. Others struggled with the rushing being most noticeable.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by xattt on Monday January 06, 2025 @08:31PM (#42618229)
> vamp

Thanks for teaching me a new term!

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by dylan604 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @09:42AM (#42622829)
I think it's every host's worst nightmare when they see it when reading the teleprompter. It's my worst nightmare when watching local news feeds where they are clearly off prompter or vamping.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by mb5 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @06:39AM (#42621442)
Jonathan Agnew has a similar story about the late, great Australian cricket commentator Richie Benaud, although filling ~52 seconds rather than 5 minutes.

https://youtu.be/FsmtFZQJbHU

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by ycombinatrix on Friday January 10, 2025 @12:32AM (#42652846)
Well now you're half a second late
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by sigmar on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:21PM (#42613437)
This is a good point. There's tons of times when I'm watching a clock to watch for a precise moment (like buying concert tickets, limited edition merchandise, stock market opening). Losing the ability to see when a 12:00:00 happens would be annoying
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by croes on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:23PM (#42613468)
> If it's 11:55, you would usually mentally subtract and conclude: the meeting is in 5 minutes.

Even that part is wrong. I guess I‘m not the only one who knows and thinks it’s less than 5 minutes.

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by brnt on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:21PM (#42613444)
The technically correct thing to do would be to educate on precision, perhaps even display it, such that people know that 12:00 means a time between 11:59 and 12:01, not 12:00.000.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by timerol on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:46PM (#42613809)
The point is that we use 12:00 to note a time between 12:00:00.0 (inclusive) and 12:01:00.0 (exclusive). Saying that 12:00 is a time between 11:59 and 12:01 implies that the range of error is twice as big as it actually is.

How long between 12:01:00.0 and 12:00 (as read on a clock)? Between 0 and 60 seconds.

How long between 11:59:00.0 and 12:00 (as read on a clock)? Between 60 and 120 seconds.

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by brnt on Monday January 06, 2025 @04:52PM (#42616375)
What I am saying is that that use is incorrect as well. There is only one way to understand numbers, and that is scientifically. I.e. significant digit.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by lxgr on Monday January 06, 2025 @02:29PM (#42614488)
Good luck educating people on why they should change lifelong habits that actually even make more sense most of the time too.
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by snowfarthing on Friday January 10, 2025 @12:11PM (#42657540)
With the lack of precision for clocks the way they are, and worries about variance in travel time due to traffic, distractions, potty emergencies, and so forth, the more natural way to handle precision is to give yourself a 5-to-15-minute-to-an-hour buffer to ensure that you're in your seat when the clock ticks from 11:59 to 12:00.

And yes, 5-to-15-to-an-hour is something that varies, depending on the length of your trip. 5 is appropriate when you're in your office and you need to get to the conference room, 15 if you're driving from your nearby home, an hour if you're flying in, or if you have to drive 200 miles or so -- particularly if it's a trip you don't regularly take!

For meetings, I actually give myself 16 "precise" minutes -- one minute less than 15, with 4-minute-30-second snoozes, so I can have both adequate warning, and regular pokes, to make sure I can do something on time.

Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by bena on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:20PM (#42613420)
Exactly, this article can be summed up on one sentence: "Look at me, I'm so clever"
Re:All clocks are 30 seconds late by caseyy on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:53PM (#42627333)
> If it's 11:55, you would usually mentally subtract and conclude: the meeting is in 5 minutes. That's how I always do it myself anyway

And if you showed up to the meeting in exactly 5 minutes, you’d be on time!