News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by mannyv on Friday January 03, 2025 @11:59PM (#42592541)
Two unanswered question: why not put the camera in the middle of the phone? And why do the cameras keep moving around?
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by kaonwarb on Saturday January 04, 2025 @12:20AM (#42592645)
The space in the middle is dominated by a big battery in any smartphone I've seen. I suspect it would be less efficient to break that up.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by makeitdouble on Saturday January 04, 2025 @10:40AM (#42595351)
FWIW Xiaomi has flagships with split batteries for faster charge.

e.g.: https://www.mi.com/global/product/xiaomi-11t-pro-120w-xiaomi...

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by klipt on Saturday January 04, 2025 @12:22AM (#42592653)
I think I'd accidentally stick my thumb/finger in front of a central camera even more often than I already do with corner cameras!
[dead]
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by jval43 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @01:19AM (#42592860)
Your comment makes no sense.

Every mirrorless body has a center marking for the middle of the sensor, so the camera can be mounted exactly centered on a tripod. It's actually important for photos to be exactly on axis if you want to do panoramas or stitching.

The only reason the body is not exactly symmetrical is engineering and ergonomics. Many point and shoots of the past in fact had the lens exactly in the center.

And "chirality of the optical path" is not anything related to this, in fact the term is not usable in this context at all.

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by nakedrobot2 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @01:13AM (#42592838)
What on earth did I just read? Is this ai slop that I just read? None of this is correct or true.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by Toutouxc on Saturday January 04, 2025 @05:20AM (#42593855)
I vouched for this comment just so I could reply to it. The entire thing is so fascinatingly, unbelievably, OBVIOUSLY, violently incorrect in every single way, yet it doesn’t feel like straight GPT output.

It was also posted by a person with a huge karma. I want to understand what happened.

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by snowwrestler on Saturday January 04, 2025 @09:24AM (#42594821)
Thanks for vouching. I guess I figured people would realize I was joking based on how ridiculous it was.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by brookst on Saturday January 04, 2025 @10:38AM (#42595342)
It was a good joke, but sadly our world has gotten so strange that it fits right in with many 100% earnest comments. Either that or the world is mired in full of jokers than I realized.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by Toutouxc on Saturday January 04, 2025 @09:40AM (#42594917)
That... didn't occur to me at all. Nowadays stuff like this usually a LLM running amok. :( Sorry about that.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by snowwrestler on Saturday January 04, 2025 @01:29PM (#42596628)
An LLM running amok is probably not a bad description of me after a couple of drinks, actually.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by rob_c on Saturday January 04, 2025 @07:40AM (#42594369)
What the actual f•©k?
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by ipv6ipv4 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @02:30AM (#42593152)
If we are playing with phone camera form factors, I vote for thinking outside the phone. Remove the camera entirely from the phone, and put it in a separate cylindrical device; a smaller incarnation of Apple's ancient iSight webcam. Stuff in better optics, put controls on the cylinder, and allow viewing the image from my watch when taking a photo/video. So I can leave the phone at home...
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by Someone on Saturday January 04, 2025 @02:45AM (#42593215)
I think that would be a niche product, at best.

Most users would want to use the screen of their smartphone as a viewfinder. That either means using both hands or requiring a way to attach the thing to the smartphone.

Also, to do the image processing, that cylinder would need to have most of the processing power of the iPhone and, thus, a fairly large battery.

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by ipv6ipv4 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @03:22AM (#42593363)
Yes, it is niche today. I’m hoping for a less phone screen oriented future.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by kalleboo on Saturday January 04, 2025 @04:19AM (#42593638)
Sony actually did something like this once back in 2013. It could work independently or clip onto your phone as a viewfinder

Low end model https://www.dpreview.com/products/sony/compacts/sony_dscqx10

High end model https://www.dpreview.com/reviews/sony-cybershot-dsc-qx100

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by globular-toast on Saturday January 04, 2025 @05:11AM (#42593825)
Tbh answer is usually "Sony did that, but nobody cared". They also did the camera in the middle thing with the Xperia Pro. It even had adjustable aperture!

Sony has consistently been innovating in this space but has always had basically insignificant market share. People keep complaining about mundane updates and AI crap but they won't buy phones from the one manufacturer that bucks this trend. MKBHD has a couple of videos about it (regarding the Xperia 1vi iirc).

My Sony phone has a 4k 120hz oled screen, notification led, headphone jack, fully manual camera mode, no bloatware or ai crap, great battery life (never had to charge my phone during the day). They had the battery save features years before other manufacturers. They've been doing this consistently for years. I don't know how they keep doing it, but I'm glad they do.

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by asciimov on Saturday January 04, 2025 @02:42AM (#42593206)
> why not put the camera in the middle of the phone?

Because when you pick it up, your hand is covering up the middle of the phone. However the top quarter is unobstructed.

> And why do the cameras keep moving around?

Easy way to tell models apart.

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by dylan604 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @03:06AM (#42593305)
> Easy way to tell models apart.

is that the reason or just a convenient side effect? the last two models had to move the lenses around slightly so they could capture whatever they called their stereo AR/VR type acquisition so the pupil distances worked correctly. after that, there's only so many ways to arrange 2 or 3 lenses.

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by mcintyre1994 on Saturday January 04, 2025 @07:49AM (#42594410)
Another reason that comes to mind is the camera bump. If you put the camera in the middle then it’d kinda rest on that on a flat surface and wobble. With the camera in a corner it sits on the camera bump + the opposite corner which is a bit more stable and less obvious.
Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by makeitdouble on Saturday January 04, 2025 @10:44AM (#42595379)
That's not the market they're going after, even with all the ads and promotion. It's more an aspirational positioning than a hardcore one.

For instance Xiaomi is a lot more serious about the photo part (and they also sell a lot less as well, this model was only noticed in photography circles)

https://www.mi.com/global/product/xiaomi-14-ultra/

Re:A Billion Pixels a Second: Rare Look Inside Apple's iPhon... by jdietrich on Saturday January 04, 2025 @11:30AM (#42595699)
Packaging. A phone is absolutely stuffed with components, most of the market highly values thinness, so every mm^3 is jealously fought over. Putting the camera in the middle might mean making the phone bigger, having to shrink the battery, or putting antennas in less-than-ideal places. It's design trade-offs all the way down.