https://docs.github.com/en/get-started/exploring-projects-on...
Were we supposed to use stars some other way ?
I also think stars should just be bookmarks - but some companies are obsessed with the star count (stargazers) as a sign of importance of their repo. Since that is obviously what sparked this research we are discussing to begin with.. just meant to point out that a lot of folks new to GitHub have no idea anyone could possibly care about the repo star count! :)
But like, any indirect signal, by its very nature, both can be gamed and will be gamed once people care about it, and so you need to be extremely careful ever using such signals on an ongoing basis, certainly once too many people know about them; and, frankly, if you make such a website, you should be doing everything in your power to prevent such signals from existing in the first place (such as by not tracking what users bookmark in the first place; or, if you somehow must, then keeping that information to yourself and not exposing it to users... this is hard to have fortitude on, as it also requires not trying to use it yourself as a signal, as people will figure that out and optimize for it even if they can't see it).
It's fraudulent only because Github use "stars" to rank popular repos.
I think a repo should be ranked by code quality and update activity rather than "stars"
If "stars" were the only metric we can find, then people should stop complaining "fake" stars.
Yesh, surely I can, but how about https://github.com/trending ?
It still uses "stars" are a sole marker, no? I don't think it's "good enough"?
It is Microsoft.
Code quality is (Number of stars + number of forks * median number of commits per fork + 10 * number of closed issues + 100 * number of open issues + 3 * number of dependent packages + 0.01 * number of installs in the last 30 days) * number of commits in the last 100 days * number of core contributors active in the last 7 days / percentage of lines of code with no test coverage / (1+the number of open CVEs in dependencies) * the vibe factor
Some companies take advantage of this by asking for stars in return of sponsorship. I have seen proposals that say for a $2000 sponsorship - 2000 stars guaranteed. The way it works is if a participant registers in the event they also have to show proof that they starred a specific repo that belongs to the company.