News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by stephc_int13 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:11AM (#42566110)
I think that most people are underestimating Nvidia strategy.

Their bet is that AI will unlock robotics use and they don't want to be simply compute providers, they want to innovate on the whole chain, software, hardware, services, everything.

Their position is quite unique as their R&D is basically financed by their future competitors, they are making bank while going where the puck will be.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by nthingtohide on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:43AM (#42566266)
I think Nvidia should try to create an compute-analogue of wifi routers where computation will be offloaded to smart-home gpu-servers. This strategy will cement their future for eternity.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by david-gpu on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:29AM (#42566583)
Something in that spirit is already making progress: compute attached to cell phone towers, called "edge computing".

Because you are pooling computer resources across many more users you have better amortized cost than if you had a workstation on every home that was idle 99% of the time. Of course, latency and bandwidth to the cell tower is worse than wifi, but better than if the compute is done on a remote server.

I have no idea of which model will succeed for which use cases, but the idea is sound.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by giancarlostoro on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:54AM (#42567221)
Not sure how well this would scale if every users needing to compute all at once. Which all it takes is some meme new app that requires heavy computation and then everyone downloads it.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by david-gpu on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @01:59PM (#42568232)
It has the same scalability issues and the same scalability solutions as cell towers themselves, doesn't it? Densely populated areas have more cell towers and thus smaller cells.

Again: which computation paradigm works best depends on the use case. It is not an all or nothing situation.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by nthingtohide on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @12:20PM (#42567431)
Smart mirror, smart appliances, smart robots (of various kinds), all could benefit from such a central compute server which can work without internet. All appliances will have voice interface, and will require heavy intelligence so it is better if the model is downloaded to a central place at home. This model also means all home appliances can be equally smart with no restriction on form factor of the appliances themselves. Nvidia could model itself around current mobile companies selling OS, models, everything in a nice compute-rack package.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by dartos on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:11AM (#42566456)
Why sell to consumers when you can sell to large corporations at 10x the price?
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by talldayo on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:36AM (#42567080)
Because consumers will pay ~3-5x MSRP if the hype is big enough.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by jszymborski on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @03:53PM (#42569199)
Corps aren't impervious to hype either.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by Teever on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:58AM (#42567273)
I think there's a definite itch to scratch with this kind of stuff and you can see hobbyists already tinkering on the edges with things like home assistant and the homelabs community.

As much as there are market drivers to make the cloud attractive to businesses and legitimate reasons why cloud solutions are better than alternatives there is a real desire in a growing number of people to have a solution that they can tinker with but that also has a polished UI so they don't have to tinker with it when they don't want to.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by penjelly on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @02:53PM (#42568743)
funny I landed on this idea myself but ended up thinking it had no value
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by detourdog on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:22AM (#42566959)
The hard part to pull off with this strategy is that a truly wide spread "robot" platform I think depends on the commodification of the IP driving the platform.

I think there are many early innovators that fail in later stage growth because of this issue.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by amelius on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @10:55AM (#42566756)
> they don't want to be simply compute providers

I'm still surprised they did not create an App Store for AI. Basically lock everything down and make developers pay a % of their revenue, Apple style.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by detourdog on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:25AM (#42566988)
Apple works with consumers who need that simplification. The developers need the market. "AI" in its current form isn't really a consumer product to be sold in that way. Consumers aren't purchasing Nvidia products to improve their life developers are.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by alephnerd on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:12AM (#42566903)
> Basically lock everything down and make developers pay a % of their revenue, Apple style

At enterprise scale, locked down marketplaces don't work. They act as an forcing factor for larger organizations to build in house because no one wants vendor lock-in or to lose money via an arbitrage.

This is a major reason why you'll see large deals pushing for enhanced customization options or API parity, as larger customers have the ability to push back against vendor lock-in.

Furthermore, a relatively open market (eg. NGC) acts as a loss-leader by allowing a community to develop using a corporate standard, thus allowing you to build stickiness without directly impacting a customer's bottom-line

Fundamentally, a company driven by Enterprise revenue (eg. Nvidia) will have a different marketplace structure from a B2C product such as Apple's App Store where purchasers have little power.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by akutlay on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @12:12PM (#42567374)
I think AWS showed us that it could work for enterprises too.
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by alephnerd on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @12:17PM (#42567408)
Listing fees for AWS Marketplace are marginal compared to the overall margins of Enterprise SaaS, as 90% are the expected target margins in Enterprise SaaS - hence why 80% discounts are fairly common in enterprise sales.

More tactically, excessive charging on marketplace pushes vendors away from selling on AWS Marketplace and makes them develop alternative deployment methods, which reduce the stickiness of AWS, as hyperscalers are commodified nowadays.

Motorola learned that the hard way 40 years ago when pushing excessively restrictive OEM and Partnership rules compared to IBM.

AWS is only as strong as it's Partnership ecosystem, as companies that are purchasing tend to use 80-90 different apps along with their cloud.

Basically, Enteprise Sales shows hallmarks of a Stag Hunt Game, so a mutually beneficial pricing strategy amongst vendors (AWS, AWS Partners such as Nvidia, MSP) is ideal.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by amelius on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:21AM (#42566953)
> At enterprise scale, locked down marketplaces don't work.

If this was true, we'd have more mobile computing platforms. Large enterprises publish in Apple's AppStore.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by alephnerd on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:22AM (#42566962)
> Large enterprises publish in Apple's AppStore.

Purchasers from Apple's App Store are primarily individual consumers. It is a B2C play.

Monetizing an Nvidia marketplace such as NGC would be foolhardy as the primary users/"purchasers" are organizations with budgets and procurement power. It is an Enterprise B2B player.

In enterprise sales, the power differential between (mid- and upper-market) customers and vendors is in the customer's favor, as they have significant buying power and thus a higher user acquisition cost. The upside is revenue is much higher, margins are better, and you can differentiate on product as commodification is difficult.

This is less so in consumer facing sales as customers have significantly weaker buying power, but conversely have a much lower user acquisition cost at scale. Hence, a growth-based GTM approach is critical, as you need customers in aggregate to truly unlock revenue at scale.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by amelius on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @06:18PM (#42570117)
They could still segment the market into large enterprises and small businesses.

Also, I don't believe the balance of power is tipping towards business customers, as nvidia is basically the only relevant player.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by talldayo on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @11:39AM (#42567109)
> If this was true, we'd have more mobile computing platforms.

If you think smartphone customers and server customers are evaluating hardware based on the same criteria, then why isn't Apple the leading datacenter hardware OEM?

> Large enterprises publish in Apple's AppStore.

Yeah? Where's my Pro Tools download on the App Store? Where's my Cinema4D download? Can I get Bitwig Studio from there? Hell, is iTerm2 or Hammerspoon even available there?

Large enterprises very explicitly don't publish on the MacOS App Store because it is a purely raw deal. If you're developing a cross-platform app (which most large enterprises do), then you've already solved all the problems the App Store offers to help with. It's a burdonsome tax for anyone that's not a helpless indie, and even the indies lack the negotiating power that makes the App Store profitable for certain enterprises.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by amelius on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @01:05PM (#42567792)
> If you think smartphone customers and server customers are evaluating hardware based on the same criteria, then why isn't Apple the leading datacenter hardware OEM?

Because Apple doesn't want to be in the B2B space.

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by talldayo on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @01:48PM (#42568122)
Let it never be said they didn't learn their lesson from XServe, eh?
Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by amelius on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @01:02PM (#42567765)
> At enterprise scale, locked down marketplaces don't work. They act as an forcing factor for larger organizations to build in house because no one wants vendor lock-in or to lose money via an arbitrage.

But you can say exactly the same thing about large companies publishing (consumer apps) in the App Store. Why would they want vendor lock-in?

Re:Nvidia bets on robotics to drive future growth by QuadmasterXLII on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @07:26PM (#42570484)
I mean, you’re almost describing Google’s TPU sales approach, and we can all see how that goes