Technically every trade influences the stock, but I agree that it won't have any effect at all.
> I believe the goal is to see if AI can do better than rats [0]. There is no shame in that.
But even then you wouldn't have to perform real trades, you could still just calculate the profit as if trades would have happened.
I think the actual trading is just to make it more interesting.
Depending on the type of trades, the volume of the equities, etc.. it can be very difficult to simulate the ability to open/close positions with sufficient accuracy to evaluate the strategies.
> their interpretation cannot be influenced by the fact that the trading orders are passed for real
It's not going to make much difference with $5 trades, but the impact on the market is non-zero.
Whenever I trade, I somehow always get an adverse price. I figure it's the "no fee" brokerage chiseling a bit off for themselves. I compensate by being a buy and hold hold hold investor, so paying very little in aggregate for that.
What I don't understand is how day traders avoid being eaten alive by this.
Day traders use platforms that are optimized for speed and minimal fees, and that don't charge fees based on lot size.
The more nuanced practice that brokers use to monetize is payment for order flow. They sell your security order flow to algorithmic trading shops that buy and sell the securities you want to trade.
You’re correct in that most retail orders never make it to a regulated exchange, but that may not always be a bad thing. There’s been studies showing that HFTs often match retail trades even when the market moves against them since they are better able to predict market changes and can still profit off the trades.
[1] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3423101
I don't really buy this. If the goal was to study how different LLMs interpret financial data there would be no use for actual trades, since their interpretation cannot be influenced by the fact that the trading orders are passed for real.
I believe the goal is to see if AI can do better than rats [0]. There is no shame in that.
[0]: https://www.vice.com/en/article/rattraders-0000519-v21n12/