So yea human biology is as complex if not more complex I agree - creating medicine after a proven recipe is not.
https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-high-school-student-whos-build...
As your “creating medicine after a proven recipe” remark, that is not how things work. The way it usually works is that you study organic chemistry in college and then you work out a recipe yourself based on the chemical formula. You do not follow a recipe from someone else because recipes are often trade secrets. At least, that is what I took away from studying organic chemistry in college. Well, that and a remark by the professor that those making illicit drugs take that course before getting started.
In the context of access to cheap mass production, it would of course be silly to use the DIY product of that professionally.
In the context of "having zero access" to the technology, then the hand-produced products can be better than nothing, especially if the "no access" alternative is heinous or deadly in its own right.
It's kind of a micro-scale version of the larger discussion, perhaps?
I don’t get why that is so controversial. Microchips are definitely not what I have in mind when I talk about a “tool” at all.
You say that this is a good enough example to completely refute the OPs point which I disagree with.
Artisan made tools compared to high end tools from a factory are more like a mechanical watch compared to an electronic one. It might be a cool mechanism and a more unique statement piece than an Apple Watch, but it sure won’t keep better time.
On other topics, the cognition flips.
This is the nature of evolved, culturally conditioned consciousness (one of the things most HN'ers like talking about from an abstract perspective, but really don't like talking about at the object level during discussions of certain controversial ideas, when heuristics have taken control of the mind).
For fun: observe the nature of comments in this thread from a meta perspective of a curious alien observer.
it's important to get the chemistry right, but if you know the failure modes, it's far less of a black box and thus less scary.
A chemist broke this rule on YouTube by turning styrofoam into cinnamon candy that he ate himself, but he went through an extreme amount of effort to make it safe:
I think this phenomenon itself is very interesting and a huge deal (cognitive ability is what makes us the most dominant species, and is required just to maintain living standards), but also the secondary effect is interesting: the mind does not allow focus to be placed on it.
If you ask me, it is about as close to magic as you can get.
Good faith reading of his argument would be that a custom, artisan crafted hammer is better than a factory made one. I can’t say if that is true or not but using chips as an example- probably the most complex man made thing- is bad faith argumentation