News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by krupan on Thursday December 19, 2024 @05:17PM (#42466300)
It's wild that we can't differentiate lust and love, committed relationship and meaningless sex. That's the main thing I get from the confusion in the article and the confusion in the comments here about what even defines polyamory. It sounds to me like who you have sex with is the main and only thing that defines a relationship? Can people that wait to have sex until marriage ever be considered polyamorous while unmarried? If a married person gets close to a second person but doesn't do anything sexual with them are they still being monogamous?
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by bluefirebrand on Thursday December 19, 2024 @05:30PM (#42466414)
Polyamory may literally just mean "Many loves" but I think we can all agree that we are not in a polyamorous relationship with our parents or close friends

The level of partnership doesn't have to be sex, but being real sex is the thing that most often differentiates romantic partnerships from other close relationships

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by t-writescode on Thursday December 19, 2024 @05:38PM (#42466474)
> but being real sex is the thing that most often differentiates romantic partnerships from other close relationships

I don't actually agree. I think "willingness and continued intention to follow this person and live with them ever still, including the sacrifices that come along with it" tends to be something that connects more with relationships traditionally seen as romantic.

It's something that would separate a very close friendship from, for example, a "Queer Platonic Relationship", which could very arguably be romantic.

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by archagon on Thursday December 19, 2024 @05:46PM (#42466528)
People devote themselves to their non-romantic loved ones, including parents and siblings.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by Spivak on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:51PM (#42482975)
Sure but the thing that matters is when you make a bond with someone who isn't a member of your family.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by valval on Friday December 20, 2024 @04:02AM (#42469398)
Many would argue that there is no such thing as meaningless sex.

I’m of the opinion that arguing for the existence of such thing is naive and idiotic.

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by portaouflop on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:36AM (#42471400)
It depends how you define meaningful and meaningless which is highly subjective - so it’s neither naive nor idiotic to be able to have meaningless sex - maybe it’s just not something you feel
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by valval on Sunday December 22, 2024 @12:47PM (#42487897)
There are powers at play in this world that don't care about one's feelings.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by coldtea on Friday December 20, 2024 @10:03AM (#42471640)
If it's all meaningful, then it has no meaning.

Meaning comes from distinction, the opposite of undifferentiated sex.

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by missedthecue on Friday December 20, 2024 @11:34AM (#42472511)
Meaning, particularly in this context, can also come from consequences
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by nerdjon on Friday December 20, 2024 @12:03PM (#42472745)
I think it depends on what we consider "meaningless".

Is it "meaningless" that I hang out with friends on a Friday night? We didn't really accomplish anything except for possibly growing our relationships.

I think when myself and many people say we have "meaningless" sex it just means that beyond that particular moment, it doesn't have any other purpose. (beyond maybe its with a friend and it does the same as going out for drinks and just grows a relationship).

It was fun in the moment, but thats it. It is the same as going out for drinks, playing a game, or any other activity that I engage with friends with. Of course it's not truly "meaningless" or we wouldn't be doing it since we wouldn't be enjoying it. But it doesn't have to go deeper than that.

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by RamblingCTO on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:10AM (#42469731)
You could make the argument that there is no real meaningless sex, because oxytocin is released when having sex and oxytocin causes binding.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by portaouflop on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:34AM (#42471383)
Then you have to define what is meaning because it’s not just hormones
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by theasisa on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:43AM (#42469942)
It can be difficult to differentiate between those, because you can have meaningless sex in a committed relationship and meaningful sex in a non-committed one. I have sex with several of my close friends because the difference between platonic love and romantic relationship is not very clear in my mind. And I've had relationships that are very close and intimate where I haven't had sex with them because while some of them have been romantic, they just haven't been physical.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by dingnuts on Friday December 20, 2024 @02:03PM (#42473833)
> you can have meaningless sex in a committed relationship and meaningful sex in a non-committed one

no, I don't think this is true. The older I get the more I think there's real wisdom in being very careful about who you have sex with.

It will have meaning, whether you want it to or not, and it will be negative meaning like regret if you are not very careful.

Sex is extremely dangerous and it is only safe to engage in it with someone you know well and trust, and trust isn't to be given lightly. You will be at your most vulnerable with your partner, both during the act and potentially afterwards due to the hormonal effects and emotional effects as well as the potential physical consequences. "Safe sex" is a lie.

I don't think in the age of birth control that everyone needs to wait until marriage but we have gone very far in the other direction and I really wish someone had told me when I was younger that I would remember all of my partners in vivid detail, especially the ones I wish I could forget.

No, there is really no such thing as meaningless sex.

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by subjectsigma on Friday December 20, 2024 @07:41AM (#42470598)
For our ancestors, not being choosy about sex had very serious consequences. (It still might.) It’s “wild” to you that 3 million years of evolution is working as intended?
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by amanaplanacanal on Friday December 20, 2024 @07:47AM (#42470651)
I assume you are talking about our Hunter-gatherer ancestors based on the timeframe, but I'm not sure what you mean by serious consequences. Could you expand on that a bit?

I suspect monogamy as we know it is a response to the invention of agriculture, and we have closer relatives (the bonobos) who have sex much more freely than some of our other closer relatives.

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by subjectsigma on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:43AM (#42471462)
https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms11219

EDIT: Whoops I misread the abstract of the article, that doesn’t really give evidence towards my claim. However STDs did exist and I’m assuming people knew about them. Pregnancy itself would be a deterrent

Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by sneed_chucker on Friday December 20, 2024 @09:06AM (#42471159)
For our female ancestors, yes. For our male ancestors, less so.
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by siva7 on Friday December 20, 2024 @05:55PM (#42475929)
3 million? You may have missed some classes in school
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by subjectsigma on Monday December 23, 2024 @01:18PM (#42496415)
Believe it or not evolution did not start with Homo Sapiens!
Re:Polyamory doesn't Liberate; Monogamy doesn't Protect by ricksunny on Friday December 20, 2024 @03:03PM (#42474461)
>lust and love, committed relationship and meaningless sex

Just to complicate, some more types of love to add into the mix: limerence and agape.