This sounds great, until you are in a stressful or life-threatening health situation. Not only that, you are in a worse negotiation position if say, your leg is broken.
Also it might encourage people to postpone needed medical attention (e.g. dentist visits, don’t know if they are covered by insurance in the US) because they are worried that they blow through 4000 that year and don’t have the means to cover the additional 2000.
Covid-19 pandemic supply chain issues caused prices to surge to meet the new costs, but when those issues were resolved, prices remained high because people absorbed the costs and the companies saw no reason to lower them after realizing incredible profit growth. I wonder if we would see the same problem if we removed insurance agencies without regulating the hospitals: with the powerful middle management of insurance agencies gone, hospitals would wield incredible billing power over individuals, who might end up seeing higher bills from their hospital visits.
I don't mean to advocate for things to stay the same; I definitely think things need to be changed. I just don't see the insurance agencies as the problem in the system, in that their removal would repair the majority of our billing issues. I instead see them as potentially a target of a lot of our grievances without actually potentially being the cause of every one of them.
A different person on the internet had some thoughts that seem compelling: Noahpinion — Insurance companies aren't the main villain of the U.S. health system — https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/insurance-companies-arent-the-...
Monopsony means that single-payer health care systems enjoy significantly lower prices than market systems.
Shouldn’t the your money figure be $2000, since the employer will only reimburse $4000 out of $6000?
Universal healthcare is so much better.
Sorry, but my understanding is that because of Health Insurance companies, the price of many treatments skyrocketed.
Btw, your comment feels kind of GPT-ey but my apologies if you are a real human.
That doesn't sound like an excellent solution to me. Maybe some variant of it could work - I do like the part about eliminating the "use it or lose it" aspect of current HSAs - but as stated it sounds pretty unfair. "This will force a cultural change" has rarely worked out that way in practice. IMX it usually leads to a worse culture where all pretense of collaboration is abandoned in favor of chasing loopholes and bogus metrics, and more often than not that's intentional.
Life is inherently unfair to some extend. Some people are born beautiful and others are born ugly. Some are born intelligent and others are born dumb. You can't equalize everything.
>You are not hiring insurance companies to do the second part but they do it any way in order to increase their profits. They should be removed from this role via legislation.
Okay, but in any system, even the beloved European ones, someone does this -- they can't just spend bottomless money on everyone, but draw a line based on the relative costs and benefits. US insurers are just unusually random, kafkaesque, and inconsistent about how they do it.
There is never one platonically optimal "medically necessary" treatment; everything's a tradeoff, and the calculation will always depend on considerations other than "maximize this patient's health/lifespan as a much as physically possible".
You are not hiring insurance companies to do the second part but they do it any way in order to increase their profits. They should be removed from this role via legislation.
The first part is necessary, because hospitals and drug companies would charge even more if nobody tried to control the prices. But the consumer is the best person to keep prices in check. It is challenging because consumers of the knowledge asymmetry. Regardless, the consumer needs to feel the cost.
One employer I know of has an excellent solution to the problem: Make employees pay 100% of their medical bills up to an out-of-pocket maximum, such as $6000. That's a large amount, but the employer then contributes a large amount to your Health Savings Account (HSA), such as $4000. This amount is for you to keep regardless of whether you have any medical bills or not. (This money can be used for medical expenses only, but can be used any time, including after retirement). So the maximum you will spend out of pocket per year is $2000. How does this encourage the consumer to scrutinize and control medical expenditure? Because the first $6000 of medical spending in a year is "your money". This is money you'd be able to keep in your HSA if you didn't have any medical expenses. This gives the consumer a strong incentive to reduce costs, question charges, avoid unnecessary services, and so on. When physicians and hospitals know that patients are scrutinizing care plans it will force a cultural change. That cultural change will subsume older practices.