News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by k__ on Monday December 16, 2024 @03:54AM (#42429215)
I started in crypto just three years ago, and while it's a bit more alternative, overall it's just business.

Sure, I get paid in all kinds of tokens, and it's nice to see some coins rise after I get paid, which makes freelancer work feel a tiiiiiny bit more like being and employee with stock.

But it's just a job like any other. I write articles, I write code, I talk with clients, investors, users... And at the end of the day I get paid.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by staunton on Monday December 16, 2024 @04:06AM (#42429279)
There's ransomware hackers in some countries who also write reports while getting health insurance and paid parental leave...
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by k__ on Monday December 16, 2024 @04:20AM (#42429368)
Fair.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by bbarnett on Monday December 16, 2024 @04:39AM (#42429476)
You could say the same about anything, let's pick cars.

"There are people driving cars to commit crimes, like bank robbery!"

Oh no! Now all cars and their drivers are criminals, I suppose? Grandma driving to the grocery store surely is up to no good?

I think the claim being attempted is that crypto is mostly used for crime. Yet is that true? How many transactions happened yesterday? And how many were nefarious?

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by staunton on Monday December 16, 2024 @05:03AM (#42429611)
I made no specific claim about "crypto" one way or the other. My point is that to decide if some activity is legal, or moral, etc., you have to look at what is actually done.

It's not enough to look at whether the day-to-day work "feels like a normal job", or "looks like a normal job" from the outside. You can have a highly respectable job while interacting with people who all look like stereotypical movie mobsters (e.g. prison social worker). You can also sit in a respectable office all day wearing a nice suit while committing genocide.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by Terr_ on Monday December 16, 2024 @06:35AM (#42430136)
> "He was just a little villain. An old-fashioned craftsman, making crimes one-off. The really unforgivable acts are committed by calm men in beautiful green silk rooms, who deal death wholesale, by the shipload, without lust, or anger, or desire, or any redeeming emotion to excuse them but cold fear of some pretended future. But the crimes they hope to prevent in that future are imaginary. The ones they commit in the present–they are real."

-- Shards of Honor by Lois McMaster Bujold

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by ElFitz on Monday December 16, 2024 @08:50AM (#42430920)
Totally unrelated. But first Discworld, now this?

I need your book recommendations, or reading list :)

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wiredfool on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:23PM (#42433106)
I can definitely recommend the Vorkosigan series by Bujold. That quote is from the first one, and echoes here and there throughout.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by ElFitz on Monday December 16, 2024 @01:56PM (#42434058)
Thank you!
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by Terr_ on Monday December 16, 2024 @01:27PM (#42433771)
Pratchett and Bujold are pretty much my top-two, which extends the the degree to which I feel compelled to share quotes. Both are rather character-oriented and often I find things (jokes, references, turns of phrase) on a re-read that I didn't catch the first time.

My main caution is that I wouldn't start with Pratchett's earliest works--there are already bunch of suggested reading-order guides out there. I spent a decade thinking Pratchett was overrated because I started with the wrong book. (IIRC The Colour of Magic seemed just too much of a parade of absurd situations for their own sake.) I like the City Watch books (starting in Guards! Guards!) and Small Gods is a decent stand-alone.

For Bujold, the Vorkosigan series is the flagship, where I'd put the Curse of Chalion (fantasy) as a second.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by ElFitz on Monday December 16, 2024 @01:56PM (#42434055)
Thanks!
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by danielheath on Monday December 16, 2024 @04:51AM (#42429551)
> I think the claim being attempted is that crypto is mostly used for crime. Yet is that true?

I mean... whether it's true or not, it sure _looks true from the outside_.

What it looks like from the outside has little bearing on the underlying reality, but it's extremely relevant to questions like "will I be viewed with suspicion for having worked with this" or "is my company likely to end up subject to restrictive regulation".

Assuming (I genuinely do not know) that the crypto industry has got legitimate uses which are not dwarfed by illegitimate ones, it has got a _massive_ image problem - because "everyone knows" it's for crime.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Monday December 16, 2024 @08:58AM (#42430985)
That's not the right question. There are three buckets.

The biggest bucket is going to be purely financial trades. This is true whether you're trading wheat or copper or oil or whatever. Anybody who thinks they can make a dime but doesn't actually want any of the underlying is here.

Then of the rest, you split by social value. For the traditional markets, most of these trades will be socially positive. Wheat buyers and wheat sellers are mostly making things that people actually want and benefit from. Anything like that is in the "positive social value" bucket.

The third bucket is socially negative. In the traditional commodities, this includes the people who were trading nickel but just swapped in rocks, and other kinds of fraud. Or if you were a terrorist who was buying oil to dump it on the Great Barrier Reef, that'd be there too.

Most crypto trading is in the first bucket, because that's true of almost any financial market. People who need the underlying don't trade much compared with people who are seeking financial advantage. But of the rest, unlike traditional markets, most of the non-financial trades are socially negative. Cryptocurrencies main non-trading uses are things like ransomware, scams, pump-and-dumps, rug pulls, and money laundering, plus other efforts to evade the controls of the traditional financial system.

So the right societal question is: Ignoring the financial traders, what's the ratio between the socially positive and socially negative uses of the underlying?

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by spencerflem on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:11PM (#42432978)
This is a great way of looking at it imo
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by bbarnett on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @12:58AM (#42438724)
So the right societal question is: Ignoring the financial traders, what's the ratio between the socially positive and socially negative uses of the underlying?

If you look at my last two sentences, that is precisely what I said, so saying it's "not the right question", then asking the same question isn't very fair.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:23AM (#42441129)
No, in my reading you were conflating the financial trader bucket and the socially positive bucket in a way that minimizes the socially negative bucket. Which is a very common defense of crypto.

Your analogy, driving cars, certainly primes people in that direction, as the great bulk of current car trips aren't caused by traders looking to make a buck off the underlying motion of the people who actually need to get somewhere.

I think you're also grossly misunderstanding the most relevant claim, which is not that most crypto trades are directly criminal. I think most informed people agree that these days the bulk of them are speculative. (But speculators can speculate in anything, so crypto doesn't add anything to the world there.) The common claim is instead that the places where crypto has a direct advantage for actual use are mostly criminal.

And I think that's pretty obviously the case. When you compare the original Bitcoin paper with the current state of things like online bill pay, debit cards, Zelle, Square, Cash App, Venmo, M-Pesa, and the like, it's clear that Bitcoin has failed in it stated goals. It's just not very good at solving the problems normal people have transmitting money. Who needs to move money around but can't use any of the effective legit options? It's mostly criminals.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by pavlov on Monday December 16, 2024 @04:50AM (#42429545)
> “I get paid in all kinds of tokens, and it's nice to see some coins rise after I get paid, which makes freelancer work feel a tiiiiiny bit more like being an employee with stock.”

This is the very definition of a security in US law. These tokens are unregulated penny stocks. (Of course you and your employers may be in another country and this doesn’t apply.)

It certainly doesn’t seem like a big crime. And maybe your employers are the good guys. But everyone knows there are also tons of bad actors in crypto who sell junk tokens to retail investors who lose their savings.

This happens all over the world: millions of Nigerians have invested in crypto, but it’s almost exclusively into tokens created by local influencers that end up being worthless in a few years. That’s the overwhelming global reality of crypto, not the stories of noble dissidents receiving Bitcoin.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by k__ on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:14PM (#42433012)
Yes, it's mostly a shit show.

NFTs, meme coins, etc.

I don't understand most of that.

I keep to my niche, build with stuff I think is interesting, and keep away from most of it.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Monday December 16, 2024 @08:46AM (#42430881)
Does it bother you that there's no actual value creation at the bottom of it?

I used to work for financial traders, and while I was there I'd justify it to myself in the usual terms: the traditional commodities markets increase liquidity and keep prices low for people doing actually socially valuable things, like growing wheat or turning it into food.

But honestly, even then that could have been accomplished with 1/10th of the effort and smarts that was put into trading, and it was mostly driven by greedy people and/or fools, so when I got out of that industry I was glad to be shut of it. Crypto strikes me as yet worse, in that there's no underlying value, just a circus of greed.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by k__ on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:18PM (#42433052)
I don't know much about fintech, just that token incentives motivate people to host service I'd like to use.

Proof of work for stored data sounds like a reasonable use case for me.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:24AM (#42441137)
Could you say more about the hosted service you're using? It's pretty rare I hear from an actual user.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by esperent on Monday December 16, 2024 @11:14AM (#42432364)
> there's no underlying value, just a circus of greed

At least it keeps the clowns occupied.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Monday December 16, 2024 @03:07PM (#42434847)
I thought that too, but we're seeing increasing spillover. Molly White points out that the crypto "industry" spent $200m to influence US elections. That we know of.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by digging on Monday December 16, 2024 @11:11AM (#42432336)
The crypto industry is extremely untrustworthy, but for me, I don't think "there's no actual value creation at the bottom of it" is more true of e.g. Bitcoin than USD.

Assume USD is somehow attached to food, shelter, and other necessities (for the record, I agree that it is, but only indirectly). Those necessities are the things we need, but we don't need money to create them. We just need energy and physical resources (which, technically, also just require energy). All money is an accounting system built on top of the physical processes that we use to grow, gather, hunt, cultivate, shape, and build matter.

So there's nothing weird, to me, about money being built almost directly on top of energy usage. I think it makes sense.

Most money is built on top of gold or other precious-but-unnecessary materials, which I can't say seems more attached to real value than energy. But even if we assume 1 unit of money is 1 day's worth of food, who's to say that unit of food is actually a necessity for the holder? That food is a specialized form of energy; energy which has been used and which can't be unused. The food itself is an accounting of entropy. But it (mostly) can't be converted into shelter or other necessities, only traded or stored. So, again, I don't see "this money is an accounting of energy used" as outlandish, but reasonable.

Let me conclude, however, by roundly rebuking crypto grifters and the majority of the industry. They're generally not operating on the arguments I've made above anyway.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Monday December 16, 2024 @11:22AM (#42432439)
All currencies are built on trust. The reason the wildcat banking era failed was lack of trust. The reason various national currencies failed was never about resources, but lack of trust in the government behind the currency. The USD has been a very strong currency because it's backed by a stable government with a strong economy and has a stoutly independent central bank, which has built up enormous trust as a custodian of the currency.

I grant that the rhetoric of Bitcoin is about energy usage, but it doesn't work that way in practice. The most obvious use is the rise of Ethereum and its shift to proof of stake rather than proof of work. But there's plenty of other evidence. David Rosenthal has some good evidence there, like:

https://blog.dshr.org/2024/10/it-was-ten-years-ago-today.htm...

https://blog.dshr.org/2024/05/sufficiently-decentralized.htm...

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by digging on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:24PM (#42433118)
Well, yeah. I avoided the subject of trust because it wasn't the subject of the comment I was responding to. It's a different component of money.

Money depends entirely on trust which is a form of belief. But it only matters because it accounts for energy. Because there is nothing to trust in if money can't be exchanged for energy. We trust that our paychecks will buy food because our society is usually fairly robust in that respect. We trust that the US government will go to war to prevent the USD from being deprecated, which lets us continue to use USD.

There's no trust that Bitcoin can always be exchanged for any arbitrary good or service - whereas USD can be turned into anything you want. Bitcoin will always account for some energy usage, but so will starting forest fires. The difference is that nobody is ever going to trade me anything of value for starting a forest fire. That's the trust element. But starting a forest fire leaves just as real an impact on the universe as mining crypto, as mining gold, as building bombs to threaten grifters with.

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Monday December 16, 2024 @02:49PM (#42434633)
That also doesn't make much sense to me. Money existed long before energy was a significant commodity. Like, thousands of years before.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by digging on Monday December 16, 2024 @06:18PM (#42436592)
Energy is used to grow food, so, no. Keep in mind the context of my first comment.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:53AM (#42441329)
Again, for most of agricultural history, energy was not used to grow food. The key commodity was land. The concept of energy you're referring to didn't come along until the 1800s, a couple thousand years after people invented the coin, and didn't have any real economic meaning until the industrial revolution.

I get where you're trying to go, but I just don't think it makes sense. If you're serious in trying to find some sort of fundamental thing behind money, you might read Buchan's "Frozen Desire".

Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by digging on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @12:46PM (#42443427)
I'll look into it, but, it's not true that energy was not used to grow food. Farming is labor, it takes human effort; food has to be eaten to grow more food.
Re:Consider Negotiating with Infringers by wpietri on Thursday December 19, 2024 @11:22PM (#42468259)
You really seem to be having a hard time grasping what I'm saying. I guess I'll take one more swing at it just in case. Energy was not a commodity until the industrial revolution. If you want to say that you have your own personal conception of currency and a physics-ish notion of energy enters into that, go nuts. But as far as the actual history or common theoretical notions of money goes, it doesn't make much sense, because the concept of energy didn't exist and wasn't material to the creation of money.