News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by gaze on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:26PM (#42368156)
I'm upset they put this in because this is absolutely not the view of most quantum foundations researchers.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by justinpombrio on Monday December 09, 2024 @02:02PM (#42369300)
From Wikipedia[1]:

A poll of 72 "leading quantum cosmologists and other quantum field theorists" conducted before 1991 by L. David Raub showed 58% agreement with "Yes, I think MWI is true".[85]

Max Tegmark reports the result of a "highly unscientific" poll taken at a 1997 quantum mechanics workshop. According to Tegmark, "The many worlds interpretation (MWI) scored second, comfortably ahead of the consistent histories and Bohm interpretations."[86]

In response to Sean M. Carroll's statement "As crazy as it sounds, most working physicists buy into the many-worlds theory",[87] Michael Nielsen counters: "at a quantum computing conference at Cambridge in 1998, a many-worlder surveyed the audience of approximately 200 people... Many-worlds did just fine, garnering support on a level comparable to, but somewhat below, Copenhagen and decoherence." But Nielsen notes that it seemed most attendees found it to be a waste of time: Peres "got a huge and sustained round of applause…when he got up at the end of the polling and asked 'And who here believes the laws of physics are decided by a democratic vote?'"[88]

A 2005 poll of fewer than 40 students and researchers taken after a course on the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics at the Institute for Quantum Computing University of Waterloo found "Many Worlds (and decoherence)" to be the least favored.[89]

A 2011 poll of 33 participants at an Austrian conference on quantum foundations found 6 endorsed MWI, 8 "Information-based/information-theoretical", and 14 Copenhagen;[90] the authors remark that MWI received a similar percentage of votes as in Tegmark's 1997 poll.[90]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Many-worlds_interpretation#Pol...

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by whimsicalism on Monday December 09, 2024 @02:51PM (#42369825)
i think if these polls were anonymous, copenhagen would lose share. there's a reason why MWI is disproportionately popular among people who basically have no professional worries because they are already uber-distinguished.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by klipt on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:30PM (#42368196)
Soon: "are alien universes slowing down your internet? Click here to learn more!"

Reminds me of the Aorist Rods from Hitchhikers' Guide to the Galaxy.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by rafram on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:37PM (#42368284)
Well there has to be some reason I'm not getting the "gigabit" speeds I was quoted.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by duderific on Monday December 09, 2024 @02:12PM (#42369409)
You were probably quoted "up to" gigabit speed. Which means anything from zero to gigabit is acceptable.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by sebastiennight on Monday December 09, 2024 @07:14PM (#42372138)
Are negative speeds acceptable too?
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by hshshshshsh on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:16PM (#42368796)
Science is not based on consensus seeking.

Science is about coming up with the best explanations irrespective of whether or not a large chunk does not believe it.

And best explanations are the ones that is hard to vary. Not the one that is most widely accepted or easy to accept based on the current world view.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by brisky on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:42PM (#42369092)
David is this you?
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by jayd16 on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:29PM (#42368937)
Actually it is exactly based on hypotheses that are verified.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by hshshshshsh on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:34PM (#42368990)
And how do you verify hypothesis? What is the process to do that?
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by fwip on Monday December 09, 2024 @05:17PM (#42371163)
You use the hypotheses to make predictions and design experiments. Then you carry those out and see if they support the hypothesis.

Or is this one of those rhetorical questions?

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by hshshshshsh on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:11PM (#42373655)
Okay. I have a hypothesis that the rain is controlled by a god called Ringo. If you pray to Ringo and he listens to your prayer it will rain in next 24 hours. If he doesn't listen it won't rain. You can also test this experimentally by praying and observing the outcomes.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by kelnos on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:15PM (#42373008)
I assume this is a rhetorical question, since you are perfectly capable of doing a search for "the scientific method" on your own.

MWI has not led to any verifiably-correct predictions, has it? At least not any that other interpretations can also predict, and have other, better properties.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by JanisErdmanis on Monday December 09, 2024 @05:58PM (#42371503)
I think the idea here is that the choice on which hypothesis to verify is based on the risk assessment of the scientist whose goal is to optimize successful results and hence better theories are more likely to surface. In this way one does not need to form a consensus around the theory but instead make consensus on what constitutes a successful result.

Ideally this would be true, but funding agencies are already preloaded with implicit asssumptions what constitutes a scientific progress.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by kelnos on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:13PM (#42372994)
> Science is not based on consensus seeking.

No, but as non-experts in a given field, the best information we have to go on is the consensus among scientists who are experts in the field.

Certainly this isn't a perfect metric, and consensus-smashing evidence sometimes comes to light, but unless and until that happens, we should assume that the people who study this sort of thing as their life's work are probably more correct than we are.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by ColinHayhurst on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:34PM (#42368257)
Credibility of the article plummeted when I got to that sentence, and especially since using name dropping.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by whimsicalism on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:30PM (#42368195)
the everettian view is absolutely not the view? i am not so sure.

or you mean specifically the parallel computation view?

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by wasabi991011 on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:36PM (#42368280)
In my opinion the "shut up and calculate" view is the most common among actual quantum computing researchers.

Unsure about those working on quantum foundations, but I think the absence of consensus is enough to claim any view as absolutely not the view.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by whimsicalism on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:38PM (#42368298)
i don’t really view “shut up and calculate” or very restrained copenhagenism as a real view at all.

i think if you were to ask people to make a real metaphysical speculation, majority might be partial to everett - especially if they felt confident the results were anonymous

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by wasabi991011 on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:49PM (#42369168)
I agree, but that kind of goes to my point:

I believe the vast majority of researchers in quantum computing* spend almost no time on metaphysical speculation,

*Well, those on the "practical side" that thinks about algorithms and engineering quantum systems like the Google Quantum AI team and others. Not the computer science theorists knee-deep in quantum computational complexity proofs nor physics theorists working on foundations of quantum mechanics. But these last two categories are outnumbered by the "practical" side.

Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by spookie on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:23PM (#42373720)
Seeing to believe is indeed a view, as they would have to view it in order to believe!
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by gaze on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:35PM (#42368259)
sorry -- the results don't add weight to one view or the other. The interpretations are equivalent.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by whimsicalism on Monday December 09, 2024 @12:39PM (#42368304)
not metaphysically equivalent. also, i’m not so certain it will always be untestable. i would have thought the same thing about hidden variables but i underestimated the cleverness of experimentalists
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by DennisP on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:03PM (#42368620)
I think "experimentally equivalent" is what GP meant, and as of today, it holds true. Google's results are predicted by other interpretations just as well as by Everett. Maybe someday there will be a clever experiment to distinguish the models but just "we have a good QC" is not that.
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by whimsicalism on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:46PM (#42369144)
i think you're arguing against a point i never made in any of my comments
Re:Willow, Our Quantum Chip by ferfumarma on Monday December 09, 2024 @01:05PM (#42368659)
One of the biggest problems with such an assertion is that it's not falsifiable.

It could be that we are borrowing qbit processing power from Russel's quantum teapot.