Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by db48x on Sunday December 08, 2024 @02:20PM
(#42359585)
Youtube doesn’t know, because the DMCA doesn’t require the complainant to be very specific. The right course of action is to deny the complaint and make a counter complaint to youtube. This forces Youtube to reinstate the video, and forces the original complainant to take their complaint to an actual court. A copyright bully will simply never do that. They’re relying on people to give up at the first step, without making a counter complaint.
Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by Animats on Sunday December 08, 2024 @03:49PM
(#42360297)
Does YouTube do put-back if you file a counter-complaint? YouTube says they do.[1]
Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by LocalH on Sunday December 08, 2024 @06:05PM
(#42361530)
They have to do so by law, under an actual DMCA complaint. Not so much under Content ID.
Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by FireBeyond on Sunday December 08, 2024 @08:27PM
(#42362284)
YouTube's system has nothing to do with DMCA.
You can also use this mechanism, but their "Content Protection" system has no legal requirements.
Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by nadermx on Sunday December 08, 2024 @01:58PM
(#42359344)
Yes, but copyright has fair use exception. And in theory when you send a DMCA, you are suppose to consider fair use[0], so this seems more like abuse.
[0] https://www.arl.org/blog/9th-circuit-holds-fair-use-must-be-...
Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by mig39 on Sunday December 08, 2024 @02:26PM
(#42359648)
This is the UK? DMCA doesn't apply there?
Re:Mend it Mark gets suspect copyright strike for £25k audio...
by nadermx on Sunday December 08, 2024 @02:48PM
(#42359807)
Pretty sure when you submit a DMCA you submit to US jurisdiction, and since YouTube's copyright strike are their version of "DMCA", and they are a US company, I'd venture to say it's probably still US law they are under for this as they even site fair use[0]
Per the article, it is unclear what was copyrighted. It’s possible that YouTube knows but is not making it public, or maybe even YouTube doesn’t know. I definitely feel that YouTube’s handling of copyright issues is annoying, I feel like the creator should be told what YouTube knows. But that’s not an issue with copyright itself.