News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by Rygian on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:52PM (#42344298)
I would wager that, in general, supporting the notion that several different entities are all the authority over a piece of data simultaneously and without live coordination is not solvable. This is a learned lesson for distributed systems, and is readily apparent in the article when considering distributed editing of documents. Same goes for dual input in flight cabins, parenting, and probably any other disparate example one can think of.
Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by beefnugs on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:13PM (#42344510)
It is solvable, but needs more complicated contextual information that many people would not want to bother entering : "this word i just changed only makes sense if it is apart of this whole sentence, which is not necessarily required for the whole paragraph..."

And calling this "solvable" is a funny thing to think about, since huge portions of the earth think the chaos output of LLMs could be anywhere near deciding the final output of computation at this point in time

Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by theamk on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:19PM (#42346973)
heh, I bet no matter what kind of textual explanation you required, I can provide the situation it does not cover.

You say this word is only required if it's a part of this whole sentence? OK, the other edit kept the whole sentence, but changed a single other word in it, which happened to be the subject.

Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by eastern on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:52PM (#42347119)
100%.

The given situation is solvable only by the humans involved. They want different things. Either one of them has authority over the other, or they talk it over.

Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by Rygian on Saturday December 07, 2024 @08:33AM (#42349733)
"It is solvable" is equivalent to "politics are not necessary", which I can't agree with.

Agreeing on edits requires a shared context, a shared understanding of the goal and requirements of the text being edited, and a shared projection of how readers should understand the text and how they will understand it instead.

The specific contextual information required for automated editing is dependent on the combined situation of all writers, considering their professional, personal and cultural contexts.

Assuming that context can't be made available in a systematized way, the machine will choose an edit that is not guaranteed to match the intentions and expectations of the people involved. Instead, it will just act as adding one more writer to the mix.

Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by hinkley on Sunday December 08, 2024 @01:21PM (#42358922)
Idiomatic speech and allusion being two important cases. Turning a line into a literary or pop culture reference require pretty close adherence to the exact phrasing. And two edits are unlikely to achieve that.
Re:Lies I was told about collab editing, Part 1: Algorithms ... by fsckboy on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:51PM (#42347112)
Brewer's CAP theorem of distributed data storage. you can have two out of these three:

1. Consistency

2. Availability

3. Partition tolerance