News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by kristianp on Thursday December 05, 2024 @04:17PM (#42332858)
Reddit is too easily censored by biased community moderators. Instead of a flagging model, comments and threads can be completely removed, with no evidence of their having existed.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by squigz on Thursday December 05, 2024 @04:58PM (#42333272)
Why should community moderators not be able to determine what is or isn't allowed in their communities?
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by yatopifo on Thursday December 05, 2024 @08:00PM (#42334820)
They should. However, they should not be allowed to misrepresent their rules. I know a few subreddits that claim to be unbiased (to attract subscribers) but engage in highly selective moderation. While it’s ok to do so, such subreddits should be forced to explicitly declare their leanings and moderation policies in the description.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by squigz on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:20PM (#42336300)
This is probably easier said than done, for at least a couple reasons:

a) How do you determine which subreddits need to disclose that information?

b) How do you put something as abstract as what warrants moderation in a community into a simple description? Codes of Conduct can help with this, but as I'm sure others will inevitably point out, those can be abused by poor moderators as well.

Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by lmm on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:41AM (#42336721)
Having a public mod action log (like the one on lobste.rs) for all subreddits would go a long way.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by squigz on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:46AM (#42336758)
Depending on the context of the community, such things can actually do more harm than good - many users react negatively to any display of authority, no matter how reasonable it is. I don't think community managers should have to subject themselves to the questioning of users who don't have anything better to do, if they don't feel like it adds to their community.

Of course, this does work in some places - Wikipedia is extremely transparent about its moderation actions and policies - but I don't think it should be the default for every single community.

Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by lmm on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:55AM (#42336817)
I mean if the mods want to run their subreddit as a dictatorship that's allowed, and having a public log wouldn't stop that. It just means that you can't pretend you're not intervening if you are.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by squigz on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:57AM (#42336827)
The vast, vast majority of communities, on reddit and otherwise, are "dictatorships"
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by lmm on Friday December 06, 2024 @01:31AM (#42336995)
Yes and no. Like, is there a guy who decides who to kick out of the intramural softball league? Probably yes. But people will see that it's happened and talk about it, and if it was unreasonable then at some point they'll have a word with the guy, and maybe oust him or start their own splinter league or what have you. All of which is sort of possible on reddit up to a point, but those mechanisms are much less functional because the only community interaction is the subreddit itself where the moderator can just silently remove any posts they don't like.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by add-sub-mul-div on Thursday December 05, 2024 @05:08PM (#42333400)
It could go either way. If the purpose of the community is to benefit the moderators, they should have more control to censor. If the purpose of the community is to benefit the users, they should have more freedom in what they're allowed to say.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by squigz on Thursday December 05, 2024 @11:24PM (#42336317)
This is a rather 1-dimensional view on community moderation.

The purpose of a community is (generally speaking) to provide a place for people to engage and interact with each other, not to 'benefit' any one particular group of people. Users should have the freedom to discuss what they want, yes - within reason, as long as it doesn't jeopardize the core goal of the community. Moderators need to use their best judgement and knowledge of the community to determine what meets that criteria.

Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by lmm on Friday December 06, 2024 @12:39AM (#42336710)
They should be allowed to, but their decisions should be public. Currently Reddit moderators are able to arbitrarily and secretly remove posts and comments, even when doing so goes directly against the stated goals and published rules of their community.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by Teever on Thursday December 05, 2024 @08:21PM (#42334991)
The problem isn't just the moderators, it's the administration and rules of Reddit itself.

Reddit has a rule about not celebrating the death of someone, which they very selectively enforce.

They allow people to cheer the death of the likes of Adolf Hitler or Muammar_Gaddafi and some random soldier in the Ukraine-Russia war, but they're quite picky about other stuff.

I'm sure they'd clamp down more on this one if they could but the people have spoken and there are simply too many people celebrating this death.

Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by devvvvvvv on Thursday December 05, 2024 @10:48PM (#42336141)
You know flagging automatically kills (marks as dead) posts/comments here when enough are added right? Even worse. Imagine a bunch of redditors with a downvote that deletes posts and you have HN.
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by tim333 on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:05AM (#42338208)
The thread discussed in the article seems to be up and open: https://www.reddit.com/r/medicine/comments/1h6h3hh/unitedhea...
Re:Moderators Delete Reddit Thread as Doctors Torch Dead Uni... by emilamlom on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:14AM (#42340523)
HN seems to be doing it too (though they're just hidden, not deleted). None of the UHC posts are on the frontpage and I checked all the way to 200 posts down. I had to google just to find this one.