Should we also start imprisoning everyone who voted for Obama because Obama's DoD conducted drone strikes against weddings, churches, and other civilian facilities and gatherings resulting in more civilian deaths than Bush's?
Shareholders are no more responsible for the misdeeds of management than voters are for the misdeeds of politicians, after all.
Your proposal goes against the core tenants of justice, liability, and property rights that have guided the civilization responsible for every part of your life that you cherish - from the device and connection you're posting with to the appliances that you cannot live without, to the economic systems that have lifted more human beings out of poverty than any other economic system ever conceived.
What's the argument in favor of your proposal that outweighs these cons?
P.S. - I upvoted your comment because as much as I vehemently disagree with your proposal, I believe we should all have the decency to discuss ideas we disagree with rather than attempt to censor them.
Our system does not treat seriously the bad behavior of corporations. It is a way for shareholders to get only the upside and not suffer the consequences.
Long ago, I divested from a mutual fund when I realized that it made me an indirect owner of Philip Morris. As shareholders, we can make choices that harm people and yet we risk no consequences beyond losing our investment.
If it is a serious argument that we should jail more CEOs, then all who profit from criminal corporate behavior should be punished.
>then all who profit from criminal corporate behavior should be punished.
American, European, and British citizens profit from exploitation of the global south, exploitation that often includes violence. Should all American, European, and British citizens be punished simply for being beneficiaries of activity they don't necessarily endorse or support?
What about shareholders who didn't make a choice to purchase shares of the companies in question, like recipients of pensions where the pension fund purchased shares in pursuit of producing a return for the workers they have promised to support financially?
I am not convinced that we should jail shareholders. I am also not convinced that legal entities designed to limit liability should exist.
As for the second part of your question about those who inadvertently and ignorantly own shares in criminal enterprises, I think it is a good question and I do not have an answer. Maybe pension funds should be responsible for their investments.
* Shareholders do not directly commit crimes. We should hold those that directly commit the crime liable.
* Shareholders often hold assets that hold stocks. Should I be responsible if I own an index fund with stocks in a company that owns stocks in a company that commits a crime?
* Shareholders do not have perfect information about the inside operations of a company. I cannot read internal emails to determine if I own a shares in a company that is planning on committing a crime.
* Shareholders can physically be outside of the legal jurisdictions that the company is operating from. Is it fair if Venezuelan shareholders are effectively unpunished while US resident shareholders are held responsible?
If shareholders were legally responsible for the actions of the companies they own, they would expect and be entitled to more transparency.
I remain unconvinced that the system we were born into just happens to be the right way to do things. I can currently extract profit by owning pieces of corporations that harm individuals and society. This seems less than ideal to me.
While I agree with your argument here, that opening line really raises questions.
Do we want "capital markets" at all if they're structured in a way that incentivizes risking innocent people's lives to reward the market participants with increased profits, without any equivalently existential consequences when that risk goes bad and hundreds of people die as the next Boeing airliner ploughs a hole in the ground?
Something's deeply wrong with how things work now, and capitalism is looking awfully like the root cause.
I don't refute that there are big problems with how things are currently being run, but what evidence exists suggesting that an alternative economic system is the solution?
Please correct me if I'm wrong, but China has far more industrial accidents and avoidable deaths than the US does, no?
We also didn't have the same extent of the kinds of problems being discussed here in the past, while the US was still a capitalist country then too, right?
That makes me ponder whether a change in the implementation of capitalism is to be blamed more so than capitalism itself - if not a combination of that and other factors unrelated to the economic system.
It's not difficult to draw a line back to when we shifted away from a more "stakeholder-y" capitalism towards shareholder value maximization as a motif, but that begs the question: why were we more unified and stakeholder oriented back then, but not so much anymore, if the rationale behind shareholder value maximization was as true then as it is now?
It still runs capitalism, just more state controlled. It's the mirror side of the corporate-controlled government of the US.
Shareholder value maximization is not what changed, but zero regulation happened, and securitization so that nobody knows where to really go with pitchfork and torches. Probably somewhere overseas to seize random tax haven assets.
It's not exactly capitalism, but it is a regulatory failure that exposes the corruption of the institutions that oversee Boeing. Corruption is the cause.
Our implementation mostly uses lobbying and the revolving door instead of direct bribes, but nevertheless results in 737 MAX.
Maybe we can improve the system in the U.S. and make it less corrupt. I hope so, but I am not very optimistic.
I want free markets, free trade, private property, and the capitalism that arises from these forces. But our current implementation is not proving itself to be ideal.
That's BS. Big shareholders can get seats on the board of directors and have influence over management decision-making.
Jail time for shareholders is probably going too far in most circumstances, but forfeiture of shares is pretty reasonable.
I don't think so. The scenario isn't an eminent domain "give it up 'cause we want that property" it's "you did wrong [because it did wrong and you own it], and this is your punishment." It's basically a fine, and fines aren't unconstitutional.
Furthermore, in this specific case, Boeing has plead guilty to a felony, which makes the existence of a legal wrong pretty crystal clear.
https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S9-C3-3-...
https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/amdt5-9-1/ALD...
The level is aggressive ignorance that we see in HN comments about legal issues is both hilarious and depressing. Most HN users are educated US citizens and yet somehow they're still ignorant about the basics. I guess that's an indictment of our educational system?
Also, do you think the fine for a parking ticket is a taking? Does the government have to compensate me for the fair market value of the money it took? You application to the takings clause to these kids of scenarios is absurd.
From who, and to who?
From only those big shareholders with seats on the board, from the "little guy", or from both?
What happens to the forfeited shares in your proposal? Are we redistributing them? Are they getting nationalized? Mandatory buybacks? Destruction of those shares, increasing the voting power of the other shares?
No sternly worded letter, no slap on the wrist... Consequences!
I'd even "scare them incorrupt" by threatening to nationalize the company if no sufficient corrective actions are implemented to stop being a net negative to society.
Now that's the way to discipline the shareholders, which is a different problem than disciplining the leaders.
The "401k objection" is often used as cover by the defenders of those people, in a ploy to avoid accountability: "shares are held by all kinds of common people in their 401ks, and all you be doing is punishing those innocents!" My answer to that is to require public companies (with brokerages) to maintain a registry of the beneficial owners of their shares, then just nationalize the shares of the largest shareholders (as those are the people/organization with any real influence).
As for predictable objections of "it's impossible to collect that info1!1" they're already 90% of the way there, because they already know where to mail proxy statements. I think you can get the rest of the way with extra reporting requirements and onerous penalties for non-compliance (e.g. forfeiting the shares after a suitable grace period or if there is evidence of evasion).
Maybe if regulators grew a sack and started absolutely deleting companies for wrongdoing, people would think twice before they invest in them or the various institutional funds that invest in them. Wishful thinking.
Out of curiosity, if one were to "steelman" my proposal... If nationalization of companies were a consequence of public companies behaving badly, would it not pressure shareholders to divest from bad actors, rather than doubling down on those whose leaders lacking moral scruples?
What I'm trying to ask is: wouldn't it result in a better (moderately regulated) "free market" if there were consequences to leaders and shareholders alike?
I think the GP is on the right track. Business leaders need fear consequences, so they moderate their behavior, and that means messages must be sent. It would be perfect to have some fortune 100 CEO go to Davos one year, then return the next in a prison jumpsuit to tell all the collected elites about what it feels like to be utterly ruined. Then do it again and again until the message gets through.
There's no need to resort to extreme measure, unless things are truly beyond the pale. It matters far more that regulations are enforced and consequences are enacted. Consequence don't need to be dire, unless actions are so beyond the pale that it required criminal investigations and consequences. If things escalated to the point of criminal investigation, your system isn't working.
The first step is early detection, enforcement, and auditing. The FAA should be beefed up so that they can rely on their own agents for enforcing the rules, together with the ability to ramp up fines, stop production, and other gradual escalation until there are compliance to regulation.
What does that mean to you? People have died in fatal 737 Max crashes - is that not truly beyond the pale?
Sometimes, consequences _do_ need to be dire.
I had a boss once who used to calm everybody down when things were going badly saying "It's OK. Nobody is going to die." And he was right. We just build websites. No matter which customer was yelling on the phone like the world was ending, it was at worst a website outage.
But some jobs, you can't say "Nobody is going to die." Canonically these are rocket science and brain surgery. But building airliners is 100% a job where if you don't do it right people are going to die. And airliners are more serious, brain surgery kills one patient when you make a mistake, rocket science kills a few astronauts. Faulty airliners kill hundreds of passengers at once.
In my opinion, consequences for trading off even small increases in risk of death for hundreds of people at once just to meet financial targets _should_ be dire.
Boeing didn't kill people overnight, it comes as gradual escalation and ignoring boneheaded mistakes over and over again.
If someone is being investigated for crime, the problem with the company began a long time ago. Consequences doesn't matter because what was minor issues became big issues.
Dire consequences doesn't do anything. You're looking at justice not prevention.
You mean a golden parachute? I don't think that will deter anything.
I think the GP is on the right track. Business leaders need fear consequences, so they moderate their behavior, and that means messages must be sent. It would be perfect to have some fortune 100 CEO go to Davos one year, then return the next in a prison jumpsuit to tell all the collected elites about what it feels like to be utterly ruined. Then do it again and again until the message gets through.