I am not convinced that we should jail shareholders. I am also not convinced that legal entities designed to limit liability should exist.
As for the second part of your question about those who inadvertently and ignorantly own shares in criminal enterprises, I think it is a good question and I do not have an answer. Maybe pension funds should be responsible for their investments.
* Shareholders do not directly commit crimes. We should hold those that directly commit the crime liable.
* Shareholders often hold assets that hold stocks. Should I be responsible if I own an index fund with stocks in a company that owns stocks in a company that commits a crime?
* Shareholders do not have perfect information about the inside operations of a company. I cannot read internal emails to determine if I own a shares in a company that is planning on committing a crime.
* Shareholders can physically be outside of the legal jurisdictions that the company is operating from. Is it fair if Venezuelan shareholders are effectively unpunished while US resident shareholders are held responsible?
If shareholders were legally responsible for the actions of the companies they own, they would expect and be entitled to more transparency.
I remain unconvinced that the system we were born into just happens to be the right way to do things. I can currently extract profit by owning pieces of corporations that harm individuals and society. This seems less than ideal to me.
>then all who profit from criminal corporate behavior should be punished.
American, European, and British citizens profit from exploitation of the global south, exploitation that often includes violence. Should all American, European, and British citizens be punished simply for being beneficiaries of activity they don't necessarily endorse or support?
What about shareholders who didn't make a choice to purchase shares of the companies in question, like recipients of pensions where the pension fund purchased shares in pursuit of producing a return for the workers they have promised to support financially?