News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by sneak on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:51AM (#42308266)
Gifts don’t require repayment. Releasing free software is a gift to the world. Corporations don’t owe free software maintainers a cent, because people using your software doesn’t cost you anything.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by nu11ptr on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:21PM (#42308617)
100%. This new trend of maintaining or starting an open source project and then getting upset when people don't send you money is seriously weird. If you want compensation, start a company, otherwise consider anything you receive a gift.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by mardifoufs on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:35PM (#42308775)
Yeah, though I have sympathies for single devs or projects like perl that are obviously non profit. Like, I get the frustrations for actual volunteers and people who survive on building OSS at a small scale.

What really annoys me is when someone decides to build a corporation around an open source project, and then you get the usual blog post around users not paying or OSS not being sustainable. Yes, using OSS as your marketing and adoption strategy is probably not very reliable and can cause users to use your OSS as if it was OSS, that is, without giving anything back. But usually those projects succeed because they are OSS, and would've had basically no users otherwise. Who would've used MongoDB, elastic search, or redis if they were proprietary and required a paid license from the get go?

In a way, that's also true in this case (success came from being OSS) but again, I get why it seems unfair for some when it's a non profit not being able to sustain itself or get contributions for corporate users.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by robertlagrant on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:38PM (#42312402)
The problem is, if their software had cost what it needed to from the start then that would've put it in a totally different competition with other companies. Bypassing that competition doesn't mean they can suddenly start complaining about how many customers they have vs how much they get.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by mardifoufs on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @06:31PM (#42312895)
Yeah I completely agree and that's exactly why the most annoying part of the OSS sustainability conversation. Most of the big OSS players (not individual devs, I'm referring more to the open core type of corporations) would just not exist at all, much less make more money, without OSS. No matter how much money elastic search lost to Amazon for example, they would've made basically nothing without OSS.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by graemep on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @01:46PM (#42309676)
You can also do things like dual licensing.

GPL or Affero GPL plus proprietary license. Of course this puts off outside contributors so not if you want a "bazaar" development mode—but people complaining about this are usually not doing so.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by sneak on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:45PM (#42319912)
First off, the AGPL license is nonfree (and also nonsensical, it is a EULA pretending to be a license), but more importantly, dual licensing means that you don’t actually believe in software freedoms. If you think users have basic and fundamental rights to the software that they run on their computer, you would never release software under proprietary licenses.

It’s like Microsoft’s VS Code nonsense where all the important bits are non free, or any company with “open core”. They don’t care about software freedoms; it’s just open source cosplay.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by raiph on Monday December 09, 2024 @05:24PM (#42371222)
> dual licensing means that you don’t actually believe in software freedoms

If both licenses are accepted by essentially everyone as inherently fully free software licenses, and they don't contradict each other, then what's not to like?

Consider the appropriate example here, which isn't anything to do with AGPL (which many people do NOT accept as a free software license), but rather the AL2 / GPL pairing which was the evolution of the original pairing created by the inventor of dual licensing (Larry Wall).

What's your beef with Artistic License 2.0 / GPL dual licensing?

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by bigiain on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @09:19PM (#42324162)
Perl might have been the original dual license. GPL or Perl Artistic license.

I remember learning about Affero at a Perl Conference in the late 90's or so.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by pjmlp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @03:59AM (#42315708)
The problem, for some, is that they believed the dream it is possible to make a living out of free software.

They forgot to read the footnote on how it actually works in capitalist and money driven societies.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by sneak on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:45PM (#42319916)
I make a good living only writing public domain software. Most of it is never published to the web.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by pjmlp on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @04:46PM (#42322371)
I wonder how it plays out in money that comes in, and money that goes into the authors of the public domain tools that get used, and make this all possible.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by lelele on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:56AM (#42337454)
What do you mean? Would you please elaborate on that?
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by coldbrewed on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:05PM (#42308429)
Open source is a gift within a gift economy. The software may be freely used but the labor needs to come from somewhere, and donations of either direct labor or compensation help ensure that the overall gift economy can continue to function.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by anticorporate on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:06PM (#42308440)
Do they owe anything today, in the sense of a legal obligation? No.

But we've regulated the tragedy of the commons in all sorts of other instances. There's no reason, for example, that a small percentage of corporate income tax couldn't be allocated to a grant program for free and open source software projects.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by badsectoracula on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:28PM (#42308680)
That's a good thought in isolation. The problem however is how are you going to ensure the money collected for that purpose go to the projects that actually need it and there wont be any corruption involved?

It isn't hard to notice, for example, that in EU where gamedev companies often receive grants for various nebulous reasons tend to be companies that do not need the money in the first place (and yes, of course there are devs who received money that needed them, somehow people have to excuse the existence things they benefit from).

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by anticorporate on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:48PM (#42308928)
I don't think you're going to solve corruption perfectly in any system, but isn't that a bit of a red herring?

We manage to do this within other fields of endeavor, at least in the United States, by using an intermediary. Examples: National Science Foundation, Corporation for Public Broadcasting, National Endowment for the Arts.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by robertlagrant on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:40PM (#42312415)
It's definitely not a red herring. Software is there to do something. Art isn't. If you're spending money on software, it's to do something, and if it's the wrong thing it's a waste of people's money.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by sneak on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @12:48PM (#42319946)
Redistributing tax money to economically unproductive (and usually worthless, as evidenced by the fact that people wouldn’t pay for it voluntarily) endeavors is a whole debate that has nothing to do with open source software.

Ultimately if people value things, they will buy them. Forcing people to pay for things they don’t want to buy simply because you think it would be good for them is a special kind of tyranny.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by anticorporate on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @01:08PM (#42320175)
> Forcing people to pay for things they don’t want to buy simply because you think it would be good for them is a special kind of tyranny.

Wait until you learn where the rest of your tax dollars get spent.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by carlosjobim on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @01:03PM (#42309105)
That's honestly the sneakiest suggestion for implementation of communism I've heard so far in my life. Give away low quality software for free, then later demand that the government force people who want nothing to do with you or your code to pay you for your efforts. It's parasitic on several different levels.

Then all FOSS hackers will be like Khrushchev, wondering why Western industry always outproduced his own, even though the Soviets "where doing everything right".

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by creato on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @01:50PM (#42309743)
> There's no reason

There definitely is a reason, and it's the same reason this problem exists in the first place: it's hard to measure the value a library or tool generates, whether it's open source or not. How are you going to allocate this tax to projects at scale?

Companies already can barely solve this problem internally, and often fail completely at it. Just imagine how many times you read a comment on HN lamenting the lack of investment in IT infrastructure. The idea that you'll solve it at society scale as a government, for things much more nebulous than even IT infrastructure, is laughable.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by anticorporate on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:19PM (#42311591)
Grants don't need to be given on the basis of usage alone. Generally speaking, the people on a grants committee would be knowledgeable industry experts who make allocation based on a number of factors like impact, ability of the organization receiving the funds the utilize them well, the sustainability of the project as a whole, the success of previous grant projects, etc.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by robertlagrant on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:41PM (#42312430)
This just creates a cottage industry of people who are good at writing OSS grant applications and demonstrating "progress". It also keeps incumbents in place. Central funding is the worst idea unless there really is no alternative.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by munificent on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:07PM (#42308449)
> because people using your software doesn’t cost you anything.

Tell me you've never been an open source maintainer without telling me you've never been an open source maintainer. :)

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by jefftk on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:15PM (#42308540)
I've been an open source maintainer (and still am to a smaller degree) and I think sneak is right. I'm happy for people to use things I create and release, and their use doesn't impose costs on me.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by seam_carver on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:24PM (#42308642)
Tech support still takes time.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by badsectoracula on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:31PM (#42308721)
When you release an open source project you are not obligated to provide tech support.

My project might be given to you for free but if you want my time you'll have to pay for it - and i get to decide if i'll sell it to you.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by layer8 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:34PM (#42308765)
Just seeing the issue submissions can have a cost in terms of emotional impact. Of course, you can shield yourself from any feedback, but that has its costs as well (e.g. not getting genuine high-quality error reports). One has to live with those trade-offs.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by toast0 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:49PM (#42314567)
I have 37k unread messages in my in email inbox. I can ignore issues on github that don't interest me, too. :p

Or, as the case may be, claim that I'll look at them soon, and never make it back.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by jefftk on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:40PM (#42308835)
Tech support is entirely optional, and I only do it to the extent that I enjoy it.

(Or, when at one point I had a job as an open source developer, to the extent that I thought it would improve our software.)

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by samus on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:39PM (#42308817)
Their use doesn't, but from time to time they send in bug reports and feature requests, don't they?

Where do you draw the line between extending your project and providing free labor to a for-profit company?

Fixing bugs is less controversial, while finding solutions to issues arising in bespoke production environments, with short deadlines, is grueling work for which companies are usually gladly purchasing support contract. Where is the line past which you ask for money, and are you really fine helping a company avoid lawsuits and brand damage after they neglect updates for years, with no gratitude from their side? Case in point: log4shell in late 2021

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by jefftk on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @01:29PM (#42309472)
> Where do you draw the line between extending your project and providing free labor to a for-profit company?

I work on my various projects to the extent that it is fun. If it stops being fun, I don't do it. Making something broadly useful is generally more fun than helping someone with a one-off thing, though that is not my decision criteria.

If someone wants me to do something that isn't fun, they can offer me money, though they will generally need to offer me enough more money than it isn't worth it.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by samus on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:29PM (#42312306)
If you put in work only to the extend that it's fun, then it is probably something with very clearly delineated scope (kudos for sticking to that!) or not really one of the projects that are so critical that companies should be expected to chip in money for support.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by renewiltord on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @08:39PM (#42313706)
Bug reports are other people doing work for me. I’m fine with that. These are free interactions between people. If you want to charge for bug reports then you can put that in your repo text and just auto-close any issue from non-approved authors.

If you want to bountysource a solution do that. If you don’t want to fix an issue don’t.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by samus on Friday December 06, 2024 @01:36PM (#42342671)
Filing a bug report is only half of the work. The bug then has to be reproduced, fixed, tested, documented, and rolled out. Sometimes with a deadline.

If that sounds fun to you, I really cannot argue against it. Usually, that is part of a support contract, and therefore hobbyist open source developers basically supply free labor to for-profit companies.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by renewiltord on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @02:02PM (#42453639)
You don't have to fix bugs. They can remain bugs. Deadlines are other people's problems.
Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by mistrial9 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:27PM (#42314496)
> Releasing free software is a gift to the world.

definite maybe, but it is not only that.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by kamaal on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @09:23AM (#42317668)
Part of the reasons why developers are so common is because starting is easy thanks to these 'free' tools.

They better pay, or some body 15 years from now will have to spend $10,000 just to being learning how to code.

That not only reduces number of programmers that you can hire, that will create a serious general programmer crunch, that will likely increase the cost of making software 1000x.

Re:DuckDuckGo Donates $25,000 to the Perl and Raku Foundation by aithrowawaycomm on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @10:10AM (#42318199)
The stronger claim is that not giving back is short-sighted rather than unethical: using a volunteer product in your business without doing anything to ensure it's long-term longevity risks regression bugs and dependency hell.