News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by JohnFen on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:36AM (#42307261)
I think that immortality would be a disaster, personally. That we die is a critically important aspect of life. I'd prefer that we work on ways to make the death process less traumatic.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by ericmcer on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:07AM (#42307665)
Why? We have already decimated any semblance of natural selection so death is no longer a necessity from an evolutionary standpoint. Maybe immortal humans would be more beneficent because they wouldn't be scrambling to get ahead in their short time here.

If I didn't only have 30-40ish productive years to achieve whatever I will in this life it would be much easier to donate money or time to charitable pursuits.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by ryandvm on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:14PM (#42308527)
> If I didn't only have 30-40ish productive years to achieve whatever I will in this life it would be much easier to donate money or time to charitable pursuits.

Spoiler: The haves are not going to get any more generous when they've got thousand year lifespans. You would just have end up having to spend hundreds of years grinding away at the bottom of the ladder instead of 30 or 40.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by SergeyKa on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @01:48PM (#42309716)
We grind away to keep the body supplied and satiated.

A transcended/uploaded mind won't have the earthly needs and would be a lot cheaper to maintain, leaving it to achieve otherwise impossible results.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by guappa on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:38PM (#42310311)
Want some runtime on the good CPU? Got to work.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by lm28469 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:26AM (#42307926)
Everything would scale with it, 30 or 300 years, as long as you're running the same system it wouldn't matter

Not even talking about the fact that we live in a very finite system

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by JohnFen on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:45AM (#42308194)
> We have already decimated any semblance of natural selection

We certainly have not.

> If I didn't only have 30-40ish productive years to achieve whatever I will in this life it would be much easier to donate money or time to charitable pursuits.

True, but if you lived forever that would mean that it wouldn't be realistic for new people to come into the world, which means far fewer new ideas and ways of looking at the world. That would a net loss for humanity.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by Filligree on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:37PM (#42310297)
That sounds like a more tractable problem than death.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:40PM (#42310349)
1) There's no danger of overpopulation. People have a natural tendency to reproduce slower when they feel safer.

2) Trivial argument: if people already lived indefinitely would you advocate murdering them to "make room"? Telling people they shouldn't be able to pursue a longer life is equivalent. Making that decision for yourself is perfectly fine; making it for others is not.

3) 150k people die every day, nearly 2 people per second. If fixing that tragedy creates new problems, bring them on; we'll solve those problems too.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by achierius on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @03:31PM (#42310982)
1) Is not clearly true. Yes, 'feeling safer' pushes down on reproduction rates. But the _total_ effect on population growth could still be positive if the total death-rate drops enough -- we don't know enough to say for sure. And frankly, I think the most likely outcome is that people would be more likely to have kids if they didn't have to worry about missing out on their chance at XYZ dream.

2) Not true from most moral perspectives, including 'common sense morality'. In a pure utilitarian sense, sure, but most people don't subscribe to that. For example, choosing to not save someone from a burning fire is not the same as choosing to burn them to death. Both the actor and their intention matter.

3) I don't disagree with the first half of your point (that this is a tragedy) but I cannot share your optimism re.: us solving the consequent problems. If there's anything that the last fifty years of modernity have shown, it's that we're actually quite bad at solving broader social problems, with new and even-worse problems often arising well after we thought the original problem settled. Consider global warming (to which the 'solution' looks to be the further impoverishment of the third world, and probably mass deaths due to famine/drought/heat waves), or how we in the US 'solved' mobility by destroying main streets and replacing established public transportation with cars and mazes of concrete. Now we've "solved" loneliness by giving everyone a phone and -- well, I'm sure you know how that went.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:02PM (#42311369)
1) We already have a growing population, and I don't think it's inherent that curing mortality would have to make it grow faster. The net effect would certainly be an ongoing upwards growth (since I would hope that population never goes down), but I'm arguing that the net effect does not inherently have to be unchecked exponential growth. Immortality doesn't solve resource constraints, and resource constraints do influence people's choices. That said, I also believe that even if it did result in faster growth that that's a reason to not solve the problem.

2) The equivalence here isn't "choosing to not save". Choosing to push someone back into a burning building, or preventing them from trying to escape, is equivalent to choosing to burn them to death.

3) I am an incorrigible optimist and don't intend to ever stop being one. Humanity is incredible and it's amazing what we can solve over time. I don't believe that any potential solution we might come up with is worse than doing nothing and letting 150k people die every day.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by prometheus76 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:31AM (#42308020)
Wouldn't any change we make to who dies when also be natural? How is that not natural selection? Did earlier generations not attempt to stay alive?
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:28AM (#42307971)
I like knowing that the worlds biggest assholes sometimes lie awake at night fearfully pondering their own death. I don't want to deprive them of that.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by portaouflop on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:30AM (#42308008)
The Great Equalizer
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by 9dev on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:31AM (#42308011)
Well. How would you like a 290 years old Putin keeping a tight grip on Russia in the 23rd century?
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by all2 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:36PM (#42310278)
I see, so this is where the God-Emporer of Man comes from.

purge the xenos

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by bambax on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:50PM (#42310504)
Are you serious? Have you been around old rich people? Do you find them generous? People grow more selfish with age, because they care less and less.

The only thing to gain by abolishing biological death is perpetual civil war.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by vundercind on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @03:07PM (#42310695)
Plenty of the most-powerful already keep causing harm just to make number go up even more, well beyond the point at which they can conceivably personally benefit before they die. Imagine if they could conceivably personally benefit from that because they live for centuries. Why would anyone expect that to improve their behavior?
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by ericmcer on Thursday December 05, 2024 @12:57PM (#42330599)
I think old peoples inward focus is more a result of their physical condition than the amount of time they have been alive.

If you could put an 80 year olds mind in a 20 year old body they would probably approach life with the same optimism of other young people.

I think our behavior is more a product of our environment than some internal 'self' that is built over our lifetime. If you altered the environment from "75 years old, achy and slow body, limited future" to "25 years old, infinite future, healthy body" I would be amazed if there was not a humongous shift in behavior as well.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by marcodiego on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:26AM (#42307940)
What if death is just a 'feature' of how life evolved in this planet? What if we discover life in other planets that are just endless? It just seems too anthropocentric to think that all forms of life must die.

Ok, that maybe part of how 'WE' define life, but, for me, that looks a lot like an arbitrary definition.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by lm28469 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:40AM (#42308131)
It's a bit like fighting against the ocean imho, it doesn't matter how much you put into it you'll always lose eventually.

It's much simpler to accept and live within your constraints than to waste your life and mental energy wishing you could be/do something you will never be/do.

If you think about it most of the things we "fix" are extremely wonky, even something such as a bone fracture isn't guaranteed to heal 100%, most medicine have massive side effects, organ transplants have something like 50% survival at 15 years on average, &c. We think we're getting more and more control on things but most of it is a hack job temporarily delaying the inevitable

Also, anyone thinking being uploaded to a computer forever is heaven on earth must live a pretty fucking terrible life to begin with

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by nancybelowzero on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:01AM (#42307597)
>critically important aspect of life

Nothing says "life" like being dead.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by JohnFen on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:47AM (#42308216)
I meant "life" in the big picture, not on the individual level.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by wing-_-nuts on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:18AM (#42307807)
To be frank, the extent to which the very old now dominate science, business and politics is already unhealthy. I shudder to think what our world would look like if our most important positions of power were dominated by men born 110 years ago.

They say science advances one death at a time. Looking at congress, I think you can say the same for politics as well.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by hindsightbias on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:24AM (#42307889)
We could just have mandatory brain preservation at 50. Have to be a biologic to be in a position of authority.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by portaouflop on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:30AM (#42307992)
It would be hell on earth literally
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by jknoepfler on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:26AM (#42307932)
I don't know why you're getting so much pushback... Planetary resources are finite. If you give up dying, you have to give up reproducing beyond the replacement rate. People like to imagine they'll be part of some small tribe of a lucky few immortals, but the reality is we'd be in exactly the same situation as today, but with a population rapidly screeching beyond all known sustainable limits far faster than it is today. To name just one obvious problem.

Success of something like this entails a way to regulate reproduction at a far more draconian level than even China's one-child policy. I don't think any civilized nation could impose a "no child" policy and remain intact.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by portaouflop on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:32AM (#42308023)
> but the reality is we'd be in exactly the same situation as today, but with a population rapidly screeching beyond all known sustainable limits far faster than it is today

I don’t think this is a given. Most developed nations have bad birth rates for example

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by BenFranklin100 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:01AM (#42307607)
Nothing stopping you from dying. You make your personal decisions and let others make theirs.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by lm28469 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:27AM (#42307957)
Don't worry you'll die just as they will

It doesn't matter how much you like sci fi, even if it was technically possible it would be reserved to the 0.001% and you'd still be grinding your whole life just as you are doing now

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:43PM (#42310387)
The future never arrives in an evenly distributed fashion, but it reaches everyone eventually.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by bookofjoe on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:27AM (#42307948)
Yes. I have long believed that all those who applaud death as a good thing — Steve Jobs most memorably in his address at Stanford — will be first in line for life extension once it becomes an option.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by vanviegen on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:14AM (#42307762)
There are some externalities at play here though...

- We currently only have one world that all living humans must share. - Imagine the sickening amount of power some people would be able to gather given a few centuries. That can't be good for everyone else.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by rob74 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:23AM (#42307880)
Well, people already gather that sickening amount of power - not for themselves, for their heirs, but still - take the soon-to-be-again US president: he probably wouldn't be where he is right now if his father hadn't amassed a considerable fortune which he inherited.
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by portaouflop on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:37AM (#42308089)
So it’s bad already let’s make it an absolutely alhellish nightmare?
Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by huttyoop on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:05AM (#42307642)
You are welcome to die from any number of preventable deaths.

I choose life.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by jajko on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @11:33AM (#42308040)
Imagine people like putin pouring billions in, easily sacrificing millions to achieve such thing for themselves, and ideally nobody else. A truly terrible scenario worth fighting against.

Some folks are scared of rogue AI, when biggest threat to mankind always was, is and will be other, properly messed up humans with certain capabilities.

Re:'With brain preservation, nobody has to die' by kajumix on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @02:53PM (#42310546)
When I look back on my 45 years life, there are spans which feel like a different life altogether. I thought differently, and made choices that I won't make today. I'd say "in my former life" as if that life ended and a new one began. I suspect youthful immortality would be a sequence of many deaths and rebirths. If you had the neuroplasticity of a 25 year old and the experience and wisdom of a 50 year old, I imagine it won't get boring, and perhaps new ideas and modes of living won't require a generation to die, and a new one to be born.