News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by saturdaysaint on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:16AM (#4229584)
Consistently, strategically EOL-ing/deprecating technologies, even through some painful transitions, is no small part of why Apple are in a good position today. There's no way they could've pushed the iPhone out the door in 2007 if they were obsessively keeping all of their Mac software compatible across Intel/PPC or providing support to OS9 users (not that those are completely meritless). The de-emphasis of backward compatibility has been a tactical advantage against Microsoft.
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by harshpotatoes on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:13PM (#4230138)
On the other end of the spectrum, I work with lab equipment that are more than 15 years old but still work great. The software which interfaces with it is old, but still works with Windows. Would such a thing be possible with Apple, or would Apple's insistence on upgrading every few years force the lab equipment to be replaced at significantly greater cost?
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by saturdaysaint on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:05PM (#4230840)
(parent here)

I completely agree and that's a very valid scenario. Apple tactical advantage is that consumers have completely different usage patterns and expectations than the enterprise/lab (which Apple essentially ignores). If %95 of consumers either (a) upgrade within five years or (b) are completely perplexed by the notion of updating their operating system at all, then Apple are at a huge efficiency advantage EOL-ing technologies around the five year mark. As opposed to having top engineers work on maintaining compatibility with deprecated APIs, old hardware, etc. for 15 year old software.

Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by jpxxx on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:44PM (#4230307)
Macs have never really been appropriate for embedded computation, and it doesn't come up much in practice.

I work with people who work with lab software which is happily running OS X 10.2 Jaguar. It's no different than the XP box in the corner, as long as everyone understands that the checkbook has to come out when it breaks.

On the other hand, the quarter million dollar cytometer is going to be running Windows NT 4 Embedded, and when that ATA-66 hard drive fails or the software becomes unable to talk properly with the modern world anymore, it's on the vendor to make it work again. The support typically blows, but it's their problem to handle and none of them are going to be relying on Apple's memory-hole platform.

Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by pooriaazimi on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:19PM (#4230525)
They're not gonna come and take your lab equipments away, you know... Leave them on OS X Lion for a century and you'll be okay. Just like many have left their lab computers on Windows XP for a decade.

As long as Lion gets security updates (2 years, minimum), there's absolutely no need for an upgrade. After that, you can just disconnect it from the Internet and use an stronger password.

Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by eswangren on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:45PM (#4231861)
Because using a stronger password somehow nullifies security holes in an OS?
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by pooriaazimi on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:22AM (#4234944)
Sorry, I said a stupid thing. You shouldn't comment when you're sleepy... I meant you can restrict remote access to them to be more safe (from trojans, etc), but somehow a stupid point about restricting "physical access" made its way into my comment and made it look ridiculous :)
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by wmf on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:45PM (#4230309)
Apple maintained Classic compatibility from ~1984-2006 and Carbon PPC compatibility from ~2000-2010. It's a long time but it's not forever.
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by gurkendoktor on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:26PM (#4229898)
I read this all the time but I don't buy it.

Hiring some maintenance programmers to take care of 10.6 or 10.7 security for X more years (and announcing that EOL date!) sounds pretty harmless. How would that hold Apple back at all? They have mountains of cash in the bank and those programmers wouldn't get into the way of 10.8 or 10.9 at all.

Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by bestes on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:50PM (#4230016)
That is the brute-force approach Microsoft uses. Corporations love it. I find the problem is that the "matrix" of possibilities you have to keep in mind as a programmer keeps getting bigger and bigger. You end up with the Adobe Flash effect (least common denominator) within your own OS or program or whatever. I would call that a very high price indeed.
Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by saturdaysaint on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:47PM (#4230716)
Security patches, while not trivial or cheap, are vastly simpler than either the backward compatibility problems I described or the issue at hand with incompatible video drivers.

You can't just add programmers to mate cutting edge OS kernel features (ie leveraging recent videocards) with old hardware. None of us can speak authoritatively on the case in point, but it seems painfully optimistic to think you can pull this off without introducing a lot of complexity. And then, what happens if the 10.8 team tweaks the kernel during a point update? Yep, better double or triple the testing team.

"Oh, it looks like it'll take some work to get 10.8 working with all of our old AMD chipsets - either we delay release until fall (after Windows 8, unfortunately) or we put some of our "A" engineers on it."

Complexity is the keyword. Complexity and mediocrity go hand in hand. Backward compatibility is a noble goal in many ways, but every generation back of software/hardware you try to maintain exponentially increases the complexity you deal with instead of putting a better new product in user's hands.

Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by gurkendoktor on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:39PM (#4232663)
I was only thinking of security updates, new features can often be added by third parties and that leads to a healthy market that will fill the gaps on older OS versions.

HN completely ignores the class of computer users who only need Safari, Mail and some variation of Word, and then live in these apps for years without any major upgrade. In my experience, these people don't even feel entitled to any upgrade and they don't add any complexity to any testing matrix. All they need are baseline security updates, and existing services better don't stop without a plausible reason (see MobileMe). I'm not thinking of MegaCorp here, but rather my own and friends' close relatives.

The machine that got excluded from 10.8 after only 4 years was not a rev-A MacBook Air in the hands of some early adopters but a Mac Mini, the most traditional Mac money can buy. That really leaves little hope that all my "slow adopter" relatives will ever leave the Windowsverse.

Re:Confirmed: Mountain Lion sends some 64-bit Macs gently in... by philwelch on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:58PM (#4230376)
If you can hire qualified systems programmers, you can put them to much more productive use than maintaining Mac OS 10.6 for another decade.