For right now housing improvements and household appliances deliver a lot more value. They, too, will use power, but they can also save power through efficiency advances.
You would know this of course if you had travelled so I can only really assume that you haven't. Drop a pin randomly on a point in Europe and it's overwhelmingly likely that you can't even get to that spot without a car.
Really makes you wonder how the Europeans coped for several millennia prior to the car.
Cutting to the chase; train, bus, bicycle, walking can get people pretty much every where in modern Europe, save those few places that require serious climbing skills.
Well, people in Europe also coped with plague, recurring mass famines, cholera epidemics practically by the day and, pertinent to your specific statement, simply not traveling much at all. Instead being comfortably ensconced in the misery of their ancestral homes, or hells.
The point of the human present is to make the future better, and that includes living less like our ancestors did in the ways that give more freedom and options.
Cars are not a problem per se, it's how their technology develops that makes the difference. Also, for many, many, many people in the world, they're vital economic tools for building a better personal life and supporting their families.
Speaking from your cozy bubble of superiority about your public transport options without taking such diverse needs for so many into account is simply a form of naval gazing arrogance.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Do better.
Way too common among the comments on this site.
The point remains. People buy cars as soon as they can unless the built environment forces most of them not to (e.g. London, NYC, Tokyo).
Even in London most people buy cars as soon as they have a family unless they're skint.
Already, for a few decades now, more humans live in urban settings rather those that live outside city bounds - the rising trend is for more energy efficient urban transport, in non US setiings that leads to improved mass transit and cheaper rates for lighter vehicles.
> Of course you can technically walk to anywhere that a car can go and more places besides.
Some of us actually do, no technicality required.
If you think rising nations can skip cars, then I am afraid that you don't really know such societies.
I recognize my heterodox perspective is uncommon, but I exhibit it here only to demonstrate that the counter-meme exists already in the wild.
Where are these supposed billions?
Because populations are either already contracting or on the verge of contracting nearly everywhere: China, India, Nigeria, even Pakistan, etc.
The first things people do when they get richer is that they stop having so many kids.
it's a lame balancing act by the elites who based all their livelihood off masses of people to explore, and the need to be sensible with resources to keep the status quo a little longer.
china, when they were briefly communists, put a population limit as it was sensible when the plan was to make everyone enjoy the benefits of society. ...then they jumped to capitalism as usual and changed gears.
Anyway, there are no billions of new middle class people ready to buy a car there. You are far, far overestimating the growth potential and at the same time underestimating the current rate of vehicles ownership (mostly two wheeled).
Electrification, certainly, more A/C definitely, more cars, sure a bit but infrastructures are already under heavy load which limits the interest. Billions of cars, never.
" If you believe the myths of science, the Tolowa lived in this region for at least 12,500 years. If you believe the myths of the Tolowa, they lived here since the beginning of time." --Derrick Jensen
Oh, and uh, forget about going to space.
This worked great in the past, and we already have proven out the technology that we need for the next 50-100 years.
The main problem I see is political corruption, and greed / laziness from vested interests.
Edit: Concretely, we know how to make gasoline carbon negative for $1/gallon. Permaculture sounds good, but the yield per acre (and man hour) is way worse than comparably good conventional techniques like no-till, which we should have moved to 30 years ago.
In return anyone leaving the island stays gone and can never publicly talk about degrowth and their dreams of ending civilization. Also, you must tell your children the truth about all the accomplishments of industrial society.
I agree that our prehistoric ancestors were the most stable populations when looking at them from very far away. You seem to actually want to return to their brutal and ignorant lives. Well go ahead, put some skin in the game before publicly advocating for the death of billions.
Aside from the complete practical and moral wrongness of all the nonsense you just said, there's the hypocrisy.
You state the above while using either a desktop device or phone to comment on a site like HN (and presumably interact with many other sites on the web), with all of these and your device being pinnacle product results of a mass industrial modern society. Not to mention your lament that billions don't die to have "far fewer numbers", while obviously keeping yourself alive despite this regret about all those others.
> When oil got cheap and plentiful after World War II, humans didn’t enjoy the savings. They built more cars.
In the same way cheap solar will induce massive demand for all kinds of stuff, which is still made by emitting CO2. Like, yes, your car has lower carbon footprint than ICE car. But it has some, and far from negligible. And when billions of newly minted middle class buy their own first car, it will add up, even if these are all solar powered BEVs.
Maybe it will turn into a nonproblem, idk(that happens rarely)...but our predictions and projections ough to be fixed in any case.