News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by rini17 on Sunday December 01, 2024 @03:29PM (#42290526)
You're forgetting car is a symbol of freedom and wealth and these always trump efficiency.
Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by anonymouskimmer on Sunday December 01, 2024 @04:19PM (#42290809)
If the city isn't built up around the existence of cars it's a lot more difficult to shoehorn them in.
Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by woodruffw on Sunday December 01, 2024 @04:24PM (#42290835)
This is really only true in the US, and only in the last 70 years. I can think of more than a few symbols that would be more fitting for those values than a car.
Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by WorldMaker on Sunday December 01, 2024 @04:25PM (#42290843)
The car is a symbol of freedom and wealth in the US. The fun part about rising nations speed running US industrialization/wealth is that they can also skip the marketing-influenced/embellished parts. Just because US marketers were too great at selling the ideas of the "nuclear family" and suburbs designed only for lots of cars (subsequently accidentally destroying much of the urban environment), doesn't mean that's the best way to sell cars in a rising nation. Different nations, different national ideals, different ways to view wealth (and freedom). US marketing still isn't "manifest destiny" for the world's views, even though it likes to think it is (even with the US military backing it).
Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by naming_the_user on Sunday December 01, 2024 @04:32PM (#42290878)
Basically everywhere in the world everyone who can afford it gets a car as soon as they can. The only exceptions are some of the megacities like London in which it's impractical due to congestion / on street parking being scarce.

You would know this of course if you had travelled so I can only really assume that you haven't. Drop a pin randomly on a point in Europe and it's overwhelmingly likely that you can't even get to that spot without a car.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by defrost on Sunday December 01, 2024 @05:42PM (#42291282)
> Drop a pin randomly on a point in Europe and it's overwhelmingly likely that you can't even get to that spot without a car.

Really makes you wonder how the Europeans coped for several millennia prior to the car.

Cutting to the chase; train, bus, bicycle, walking can get people pretty much every where in modern Europe, save those few places that require serious climbing skills.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by southernplaces7 on Sunday December 01, 2024 @08:01PM (#42292074)
>Really makes you wonder how the Europeans coped for several millennia prior to the car.

Well, people in Europe also coped with plague, recurring mass famines, cholera epidemics practically by the day and, pertinent to your specific statement, simply not traveling much at all. Instead being comfortably ensconced in the misery of their ancestral homes, or hells.

The point of the human present is to make the future better, and that includes living less like our ancestors did in the ways that give more freedom and options.

Cars are not a problem per se, it's how their technology develops that makes the difference. Also, for many, many, many people in the world, they're vital economic tools for building a better personal life and supporting their families.

Speaking from your cozy bubble of superiority about your public transport options without taking such diverse needs for so many into account is simply a form of naval gazing arrogance.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by defrost on Sunday December 01, 2024 @08:10PM (#42292113)
> Speaking from your cozy bubble of superiority .. is simply a form of naval gazing arrogance.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Do better.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by southernplaces7 on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:03AM (#42293278)
Nope. The people who post myopic nonsense like this can do better. It is absurd to be favored by some very specific little bubble of circumstances and simply assume it's fine for the rest of the world, with blandly smug self congratulation.

Way too common among the comments on this site.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by naming_the_user on Sunday December 01, 2024 @06:17PM (#42291487)
By "can't" I obviously mean that it's impractical not literally impossible. Of course you can technically walk to anywhere that a car can go and more places besides.

The point remains. People buy cars as soon as they can unless the built environment forces most of them not to (e.g. London, NYC, Tokyo).

Even in London most people buy cars as soon as they have a family unless they're skint.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by defrost on Sunday December 01, 2024 @07:19PM (#42291837)
Habits can change and transport habits will very likely change in near future (course of a human lifetime).

Already, for a few decades now, more humans live in urban settings rather those that live outside city bounds - the rising trend is for more energy efficient urban transport, in non US setiings that leads to improved mass transit and cheaper rates for lighter vehicles.

> Of course you can technically walk to anywhere that a car can go and more places besides.

Some of us actually do, no technicality required.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by RestlessMind on Monday December 02, 2024 @03:47PM (#42300229)
May I ask where you are from and where you live now? I come from one of those "rising nations" you allude to and every single friend and family I have there now own at least one car. FWIW, they all live in cities which were there even before the cars were invented.

If you think rising nations can skip cars, then I am afraid that you don't really know such societies.

Re:A surprise solar boom reveals a fatal flaw in our climate... by rexpop on Sunday December 01, 2024 @05:33PM (#42291218)
To me, a car symbolizes willful ignorance, ugly selfishness, jealousy, and insecurity. It's also a tragic reminder of our inability to organize and collaborate. It's really a disgusting thing that we're trapped in. To me, freedom is riding the train.

I recognize my heterodox perspective is uncommon, but I exhibit it here only to demonstrate that the counter-meme exists already in the wild.