News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by saraid216 on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:14PM (#4226248)
Global warming is one of those topics I've always withheld judgement on because it's such a huge topic that, even ignoring politics, it seems very hard to get a solid understanding of the science.
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by bryanlarsen on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:33PM (#4226340)
Unfortunately, by deciding to be "neutral" on the issue, you're exactly where the climate change deniers want you to be.

The deniers don't have to be proven correct to prevent action on climate change, they just have to put out enough FUD to create doubt.

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:44PM (#4226379)
As IBM and Microsoft were aware, to win with FUD (fear, uncertainty, doubt), they didn't have to convince you to buy their product, they just had to convince you not to buy the competitions', thereby starving the competition out.

Cigarettes, seat belts, lead paint, asbestos, Linux, climate change. They've all been fought using the same tactics.

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by Strangiato on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:48PM (#4226397)
There is no need to ascribe malice to those that disagree with you about climate change issues. Reasonable people can disagree, especially on an issue that is complex and depends on predictions about future conditions.
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by anthonyb on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @09:37PM (#4227260)
It doesn't depend on predictions. Climate change is happening; the models are just to try and figure out how much warmer it's going to get, and how soon.
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by jack-r-abbit on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:52PM (#4226416)
But from the "deniers" side it is the "what ever you call the opposite of deniers" who are using FUD.
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by TheAmazingIdiot on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:54PM (#4226427)
Most of the real changes would require many people to die.

Going back, worldwide, to a pre-industrial civilisation would be a possibility. However, We're looking at 90% fatality rates to get to that point due to lack of food production. Probably would be even less than that. No chance in happening, unless forced by catastrophic event.

Another possibility is tremendous rationing. We see what having even simple healthcare is in this country. Instead, we would look at rationing everything in the world, including determining who lives and dies by how much resources they use (carbon debt). With 2 high input/output countries, good luck on this happening either.

And we have to look at all the smaller ways to handle global warming. One proposal is to dump megatonnes of lime in the ocean?! Or perhaps this carbon credits scam: it makes the rich richer (Well, where DOES the money go?). At least sources of energy like solar or wind make sense... Until you realise the amount of energy to make a solar panel is greater than the total energy you will get out of it. Bummer.

And underlying is this assumption that global warming == CO2 peak.. I've heard of this law called thermodynamics. CO2 may trap heat, but heat generated anywhere is still heat. We generate heat via our vehicles, electric grid, generators, burn piles, and other human sources of heat. Is this not a direct consideration as well?

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by DennisP on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @07:45PM (#4226899)
A study about a year ago claimed that we could get to half the reductions required to keep us under +2C just by halting all fossil fuel subsidies worldwide (not that that's feasible).

A little googling on solar panel energy cost found, for example, these links:

http://solarbus.org/documents/pvpayback.pdf

http://www.theoildrum.com/node/3910

which claim that energy payback of solar panels takes about three years.

For various reasons I think we'd do better with advanced nuclear, such as integral fast reactors or molten salt reactors. Either would be safer than what we have now, proliferation-resistant, and produce a lot less nuclear waste with a much shorter lifetime. We could have a very energy-rich future without carbon emissions.

As for carbon credits, a lot of economists advocate a "fee-and-dividend" scheme. Instead of trading credits, major source emitters simply pay a flat fee per ton of carbon, passing on the cost to the rest of us. The money is divided among all citizens, equal amount per person. Most people come out ahead (since the median emissions are less than the average), but since the dividend is constant and the new cost variable, everyone has more incentive to conserve.

I've seen calculations for the contribution of waste heat and it's very minor compared to greenhouse gases. However, if our energy usage continues to grow exponentially on this planet it'll be a real problem in a couple hundred years: http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/galactic-scale-e...

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by anthonyb on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @09:35PM (#4227254)
That's complete crap. All it takes is a reasonable investment in technologies like wind and solar.

For example, I'm in Australia. Aluminium smelting here consumes about 1/3 of the electrical energy produced. Mostly that's done with hugely subsidised brown coal. If there were a serious effort to use solar power to smelt Aluminium instead, you'd see a big reduction in the CO2 produced, and it'd likely be cheaper than the current situation.

But there isn't the political will to get it done - primarily because of idiotic arguments like yours.

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by nickpinkston on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:35PM (#4226353)
That's true - but when there's risk of something, you need to buy insurance. Alt. energy, geo-enginnering, and small CO2 taxes are all ways of hedging that we should deploy in some combination. We can't say "don't know, therefore do nothing".
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by glenra on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:54AM (#4227959)
There's also a risk we'll have another ice age. Global warming might be considered insurance against that eventuality. Whatever the perfectly optimum average planetary temperature for human life is, it is exceedingly unlikely that it was achieved in 1990. (And actually seems pretty likely that it's a fair bit warmer than now.)

Do we also need to actively "buy insurance" against meteor impacts?

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by nickpinkston on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:32PM (#4230999)
We, as a society, are really bad a planning for these things collective/non-pressing problems, and the data being hard to come by just adds to this. Your thinking is pragmatic only in a short term sense. Do you really need fire insurance? Only 1:1000 homes ever burn - I guess not then...

The risk for very bad global warming problems (mass despeciation or crop loss, etc. in 100 years) even at 10% is a really bad consequence that requires some form of insurance.

The risk for rock impact in 100 years is about 0.0002%, and we've got people tracking a ton of near earth objects and even some NASA work on how to deflect them. That's probably about $20M in insurance - probably too low, but yes we should care about these things.

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=98208&page=1

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by glenra on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:35PM (#4238109)
It's possible to spend too much on "insurance" and we almost certainly do that when it comes to climate. The general scientific consensus is that the next half-century of warming generally makes humanity better off. So this risk you presumably think we need to be actively trying to mitigate - as opposed to just doing the sort of stuff we do for asteroids - is predicated on the idea that current trends continue for a century. But 50-60 years is quite a long time when it comes to technology. Even if the models are right, by the time global warming starts to be a net negative rather than a net positive, our grandkids will have a lot better options to deal with it then than we do today. Our kids and grandkids will be richer, smarter, better fed (due to longer growing seasons and CO2 fertilization), and MUCH better informed than we are today. The best thing we can do for them is give them an economy that hasn't been crippled due to paranoia that any one PARTICULAR threat we can foresee today will doom their world.

There are an infinite number of potential threats that aren't hurting us now but that we can imagine might hurt our grandkids. Only some of them will actually turn out to be a serious problem. Spending trillions or even billions of dollars of resources combatting any one such threat reduces their potential ability to address all the others.

There's nothing wrong with caring about things like global warming, but there's quite a lot wrong with trying to "fix" it now. To put it in programming terms: "Premature optimization is the root of all evil."

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by nickpinkston on Saturday July 14, 2012 @04:24PM (#4245233)
This is a thoughtful response, and shows that we're actually pretty close. The science is mixed on whether humanity is better off I think - there are winners and losers for sure. However, despeciation gets me most as it seems most irreversible, that and whether or not there are other feedback loops that we're not thinking about.

I agree that it's overhyped, but the question here in on the margin. If we could take the insurance payment and put it towards alt./nuclear energy research we'd be killing a few birds.

I don't see how our economy would be crippled by the "insurance" even at $1T in debt funding (remember how big TARP and the Treasury's loans were). Currently, we're putting far far more than this into overspend on the military ($1.5T/year) - which is defending resource and shipping interests far more than anything else. Couldn't we just solve those problems with similar funding?

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:51PM (#4226414)
Spoken like a natural-born insurance salesman!
Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by anthonyb on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @09:21PM (#4227218)
Just talk to some scientists, maybe? Here's the Australian CSIRO's take: http://www.csiro.au/Outcomes/Climate/Understanding/State-of-...

They produce a nifty State of the Climate report every so often, which is pretty easy to understand. There's one just been released, in fact: http://www.csiro.au/Outcomes/Climate/Understanding/%7E/media...

Disclaimer: I currently work for the Bureau of Meteorology in Melbourne - as a programmer though, not a scientist.

Re:Facts about global warming that you should keep for yourself by CamperBob2 on Tuesday July 10, 2012 @05:46PM (#4226389)
I agree, and what annoys me is that as a supporter of public-school science education via www.ncse.com and other organizations, I find myself being dragged into debates I didn't want to participate in. NCSE in particular has decided to lump criticisms of climate education in with their original cause, which was to do something about widespread attempts on the part of religious people to subvert public-school biology curricula.

Strong evidence for anthropogenic climate change exists, to the best of my understanding. However, it's roughly 3.4 gazillion times weaker than the evidence for evolution by natural selection. There are reasons why I am actively interested in helping with one fight but not the other... but the organizations that I support as proxies in the fight don't appear to understand or care. I'm not even sure how annoyed I should be about this state of affairs, frankly.