News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by taligent on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:34PM (#4221178)
Something very odd is happening at Apple. Either there is a massive shortage of developers (unlikely) or developers have been moved to a new project (AppleTV ?).

Because Mountain Lion and iOS6 are by far the most underwhelming updates yet in terms of features.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by CoolGuySteve on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:57PM (#4221268)
After Snow Leopard, they changed to a development cycle consistent of two week sprints followed by a one week convergence period. Stuff that can't get in by the specified milestone gets pushed back, moved, or cancelled.

It actually makes for a nicer development model than the 'everything doesn't work for a year and then miraculously comes together 4 months before release' development model. For example, with Snow Leopard, XCode became garbage collected and was unusable for like 50 releases in a row.

Ultimately, while you get a slightly less buggy release that comes out on time more or less, the features seem less ambitious.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by chrisdroukas on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:40PM (#4221203)
Eh. OS X has been on somewhat of a tick-tock update cycle since Leopard. Add features then refine them.

Also, it's twenty bucks.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by dr42 on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:46PM (#4221232)
The cost has nothing to do with the product, that's determined based on other factors, like how many Mac's OSX sells. There's no straightforward relationship between price number of features.

The direction appears to be cheap upgrades, and merging feature sets between IOS and OSX so eventually there's one operating system that changes in unison.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by Zirro on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:03PM (#4221279)
"The direction appears to be cheap upgrades, and merging feature sets between IOS and OSX so eventually there's one operating system that changes in unison."

It is believed by some that Apple will not be pushing their operating systems in this direction:

http://daringfireball.net/2012/02/mountain_lion

Specifically: "Mountain Lion is not a step towards a single OS that powers both the Mac and iPad, but rather another in a series of steps toward defining a set of shared concepts, styles, and principles between two fundamentally distinct OSes."

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by taligent on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:25PM (#4221331)
I think I might have been misunderstood. I have no complaints with Mountain Lion and think it offers tremendous value.

My point was whether there had been a movement of developers to a new iOS/OSX based project e.g. like an AppleTV. Because it seems that iOS6 and Mountain Lion combined seem to lack the combined punch of previous releases.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by jaylevitt on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:47PM (#4221394)
Frankly, if the only punch Mountain Lion packs is "breaks way less", I am first in line.
Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by gdsf34dfsg on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:39PM (#4221371)
Agreed.

I think they have gone quite carefully on iCloud.

Beyond that, actual UI enhancements are minimal.

It's more iClouding Apps. Or App improvements. Less to do with the OS itself.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by elithrar on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:48PM (#4221237)
They have also moved to an 18 month release cycle for OS X[1], so we should not expect huge swathes of changes in each release.

[1]: http://forums.appleinsider.com/t/143731/mac-os-x-mountain-li...

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by yottabyte47 on Monday July 09, 2012 @09:06PM (#4221457)
I thought they announced they were moving to a yearly release cycle.

http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/44444/mac-os-x-updates-yearl...

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by bluthru on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:32PM (#4221350)
Over 200 new features and plenty of behind-the-scenes refinements, all for $20 and 12 months after Lion. Sounds like they're firing on all cylinders in Cupertino.

http://www.apple.com/osx/whats-new/features.html

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by FireBeyond on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:53PM (#4221410)
Beg to differ / disagree. I'd say there's a lot less than 200 features, most are "refinements". I mean, really, is "Date Picker in Calendar now has a mini Calendar" is a "new feature"? A new widget on a control?
Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by pooriaazimi on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:57PM (#4221829)
These are user features. Snow leopard and mountain lion (as their names might suggest) are all about under the hood refinements. Snow leopard was ten times better than leopard, but the most striking new user feature was scrollable stacks (in Dock)! So, don't judge ML too harshly. I used dev versions and they were rock solid (more stable than anything before 10.6.4 or 10.7.1).
Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by r00fus on Monday July 09, 2012 @09:00PM (#4221432)
Underwhelming by what means?

Small features like VIP whitelists for Mail.app, the Finder "share" button, and bigger features like Power Nap are significant improvements for many users.

I'm all about the future made into reality, but what kind of features do you see in other recent OS updates that are a) successful and not buggy as hell and b) ambitious enough to be not considered "underwhelming"?

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by pooriaazimi on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:52PM (#4221810)
The refined App sandbox and new system services (through XPC) are a major under-the-hood change. I don't have time to go through it, but they seem to have changed erything in OS X for XPC (watch WWDC sessions if you're interested).

But I completely agree with your first point. iWork hasn't been updated since 2009... I just can't believe it. It's still not on iCloud so if you want to share files between iOS and iWork on Mac, you have to manually copy and upload them. It's disgusting.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by ary on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:46PM (#4221228)
What exactly would have been overwhelming?
Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by tensor on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:33PM (#4221352)
ZFS file system. Fixing iCal and Address book by returning them to proper non-skeuomorph applications, maybe even adjusting the UI to the strengths of computers rather than bring in the inefficiencies of the paper tools we left behind.

Proper Mail.app plugins. Not limiting the notification system to App Store apps. Finder replacement. Maybe with something like semantic tagging replacing folders, complete with proper filesystem level unix support.

Even bigger pie in the sky features: distributed process migration. If you are at home and have multiple computers, why not borrow your desktops CPU to do heavy processing (say for photos or video?)

In other words, features targeting professionals, the opposite of Apple current strategy.

edit: these would be overwhelming to me

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by shawnz on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:40PM (#4221378)
While you have some legitimate suggestions spliced in here, the majority of your post says to me "The feature they should have added is to change everything back to the way it was, and change the business strategy". This is not really a very good interpretation of the question, for obvious reasons.
Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by 9999 on Monday July 09, 2012 @09:14PM (#4221478)
"If you are at home and have multiple computers, why not borrow your desktops CPU to do heavy processing (say for photos or video?)"

You can do this in Compressor.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by mkaltenecker on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:46PM (#4221391)
Skeumorphism is about taste. You just don’t share Apple’s. Simple as that. As long as it doesn’t impact the UI there is nothing wrong with skeumorphism.

Every app can use the notification system. They only can’t use push notifications if they are not in the App Store. Not terribly relevant for the desktop.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by tensor on Monday July 09, 2012 @09:03PM (#4221442)
I disagree that skeuomorphism is only about taste. It's not just a skin, it also removes and limits functionality. I can even give specific examples. If you have lion, go to your address book.

It probably opens and lists people on the left with their details on the right. It looks like a book. Can you group people? It's certainly not obvious that such functionality (which is useful!) exists.

Now click the red bookmark thing on top. Not very intuitive. It looks like a bookmark, not something that switches to a different view. Anyways, viola! The grouping interface! But now I can't see contact details. I need to "flip the page" back to see the details. This is a huge step backwards and is so inefficient that I completely stopped using groups when I moved to Lion.

Now consider Mountain lion: http://6.mshcdn.com/wp-content/gallery/apple-os-x-mountain-l...

Hey! It's the three column view from the old address book! Now I can see my groups, contacts, and details, just like before. Not as skeuomorph though. Now it's just an app that is skinned to look like a book. It doesn't function like a book. There are no pages to flip. It still has the dimensions of a book I guess, but that only makes that left page looks mighty constrained.

UI is about displaying and working with information, and this skeuomorphism is arguably not a very good way of doing either. I can lodge similar complaints about iCal. For instance, why are months always on separate pages? When I'm near the end of a month, I have to keep switching back and forth (with a slow unneeded animation on top). It's a computer, surely we can come up with an interface that discards this old page limitation of paper calendars! Not if you are thinking with skeuomorphism though.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by shadesandcolour on Monday July 09, 2012 @09:59PM (#4221628)
Of course we can come up with UIs that don't mimic the old school ways of doing things, we had them. Skeuomorphism is absolutely purely about design choices.

The bookmark thing is a bookmark, and it works like one. It saves your place on a page in a book and you use it to go back to one. The little familiar groups icon on the tab tells you where it goes.

I'm not going to argue that some of the functionality of Address Book has been reduced or gone, but it has to do with a decision that Apple made about what they wanted, not directly tied to the fact that the interface is skeuomorphic now.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by mkaltenecker on Monday July 09, 2012 @09:29PM (#4221532)
Skeumorphism is purely about looks. If it impacts functionality it’s more than that.

If it’s only looks it doesn’t matter and is only about taste.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by tensor on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:07PM (#4221653)
You cannot just change the definition of a word to suite your argument. Most people consider skeuomorphic design to include both looks and behaviour. Regardless, what I've described is all looks. Address Book still has grouping functionality. It's just been made extremely difficult to use because of the design of the interface.

Further, looks are about much more than just taste. Designs affect how easy it is to understand the information being displayed, or to understand how to use an application. Skeuomorphic design is typically used to try to improve the latter: help people to understand how to use the app. It mimics a physical object because people already know how that object works. This benefit disappears if your skeuomorphic design doesn't actually work like the object it mimics though.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by mkaltenecker on Monday July 09, 2012 @11:05PM (#4221861)
Ok, then I won’t.

Skeumorphism that doesn’t affect functionality is purely about taste. Anything beyond that is bad. End of the story.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by yen223 on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:10PM (#4221666)
Tensor's point, which I agree with, is that Apple's choice to use skeumorphism has impacted functionality, and is not a good design principal at all.

I would also argue that a lot of their designs look downright ugly to be honest.

Re:Apple Releases Final Mac OS X Mountain Lion to Developers by mkaltenecker on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:47PM (#4221234)
Does the amount of stuff added matter? If the quality is good I honestly don’t care.

Lion was a bit of a dud. Mountain Lion doesn’t add much but it improves massively on Lion. It corrects its mistakes. I’m very much ok with that, I don’t need flashy new features. I really don’t want Apple to start pulling features out of there ass (especially now that they switched to a yearly update cycle), mere refinements every year for something mature like OS X would be awesome.