News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by EternalFury on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:22AM (#42184413)
I tried it and lasted only 4 days. The platform feels very reactionary, with many users seemingly intent on creating a left-leaning alternative to Truth Social or X.

I was searching for an apolitical, more progressive, and intellectual space, but this didn’t meet those expectations. A significant number of users appear to spend their time copying and pasting tweets to comment on them without engaging directly on X, which I find odd.

For context, I’m not a Truth Social user, and I haven’t used X for several years. I prefer to keep my political views private, confined to the voting booth. My goal was simply to find a platform for sharing and discussing ideas.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by rsynnott on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:24AM (#42185190)
> apolitical, more progressive, and intellectual space

What does 'apolitical' mean, though? At some level, everything is political. Like, unless you want to restrict it to entirely cat photos, I'm not sure how this would work.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by etrautmann on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:23PM (#42187104)
There's an enormous gulf between the two extremes, where the vast majority of human conversation lies. It's not entirely implausible to have a social media platform that captures less of the culture war or partisan fighting in the US and elsewhere.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by orionsbelt on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:27PM (#42187738)
Yup. For example, Hacker News, or pre-Elon Twitter.

I'm a fan of Elon and Twitter, but post-Elon, my Twitter feed is far more filled with culture war nonsense, political flamebait, etc.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by mike_hearn on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:47PM (#42187357)
Threads is trying exactly that strategy, so it's clearly something that can be attempted.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by archagon on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:01PM (#42188574)
Also, “progressive” and “apolitical” seem inherently contradictory.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by RestlessMind on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:12PM (#42190225)
Here are some examples of apolitical links (from HN): "Tiny Glade 'built' its way to >600k sold in a month", "Open Riak – open, modern Riak fork", "Fair coins tend to land on the side they started", "Tiling with Three Polygons Is Undecidable".

Here are some examples of political links (from HN / Reddit): "Trump picks Dr. Oz to run Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services", "If the US tries mass deportations, what happens if all other countries refuse to take them?", "Marjorie Taylor Greene Suggests Releasing All Ethics Reports, Not Just Gaetz's: "If We're Going to Dance, Let's All Dance In The Sunlight'", "Russia says Ukraine attacked it using U.S. long-range missiles, signals it's ready for nuclear response", "Donald Trump’s pick for energy secretary says ‘there is no climate crisis’"

While this trope is always parroted, not everything has to be political tbh. Normal people I know will classify the first group as "apolitical" while the second group as "political" discussions.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by skissane on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:28PM (#42190593)
> At some level, everything is political

Every workplace has “office politics” - e.g. managers fighting over which team does what or which projects get funded. Even community organisations, hobby groups, kids sports teams, volunteer groups, churches/synagogues/mosques/etc, open source projects, inevitably end up with politics of this kind. You might call this “private politics”, the internal politics of private organisations, whether for-profit or not-for-profit

But that’s a rather different thing from public politics, electoral politics, political parties and candidates, lobbying for or against legislation, etc. Every workplace has private politics but not every workplace has public politics. If the job itself doesn’t explicitly intersect with the publicly political (e.g. you work for a political party, elected official, political consulting firm, activist group, etc), then how much presence public politics has really comes down to the norms and culture of the workplace, which are largely up to the senior leadership (although the wider background culture also plays some role-certain professions/industries tend to have a built-in political lean, at least in some countries, so if the senior leadership doesn’t push neutrality in publicly politics as a norm, that lean may determine the norm de facto)

In practice, a lot of the time when people say “political”, they mean the “public politics” which only explicitly exists in some spaces, not the “private politics” which is universal. To respond by pointing out that “private politics” is indeed (near-)universal, or that public politics ends up touching implicitly on a lot of things that aren’t explicitly involved in it, is turning the conversation into a pointless game of semantics by ignoring what the person you are responding to is actually using the word “political” to mean

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by skepticATX on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:38AM (#42184666)
I think it’ll keep improving as more folks move over. This is just a temporary artifact of X refugees being the first to migrate.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by EternalFury on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:53AM (#42184824)
I’ll check it again in a year. Their “algorithm” is another polarization device, however. If you click or like anything, your feed fills with extremely similar things. Usually, that makes recovery from a closed mindset impossible.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by dewey on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:33AM (#42185306)
That's why it's cool that you can bring your own algorithm, for example there's this preset which will give you a feed of your "quiet followers", people who rarely post: https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:vpkhqolt662uhesyj6nxm7ys/fe...
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by kazinator on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:16PM (#42187041)
When has a single social thing in human history improved with more folks moving over (beyond a small, early threshold)?
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by b0sk on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:05AM (#42184972)
The "algorithm" aspect of the platform has improved for me. Here's what I did -- I artificially liked a non-trivial number of posts of topics I liked (say CS theory, systems programming, NFL, Soccer etc). Now the "Discover" feed is good (not great but this is a start).

A few days back when I was starting out, the Discover feed was mostly random.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by samsari on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:41AM (#42184689)
> My goal was simply to find a platform for sharing and discussing ideas

Which makes it all the stranger that you're complaining about others doing the same.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by EternalFury on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:48AM (#42184777)
I get what you’re saying. Political banter is a form of that. But it’s an echo chamber and I am tired of that. I would rather be alone in the woods than having to put up with another echo chamber.

It’s not for me; it may be for you and apparently it’s worth a try for at least 20 million individuals.

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by ryandvm on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:51AM (#42184807)
> I was searching for an apolitical, more progressive, and intellectual space

This is a concept I struggle with. HN tries to be culture and politically agnostic, but culture and politics drive everything. I think it's intellectually lazy to suggest that this shouldn't be a place for smart people to discuss important issues because the reality is that those places are woefully uncommon.

Begging for forums and content to be apolitical is just willfully wearing blinders. It may be great for mental health, but it's probably not great for society. It's on the same philosophical slope of "I don't want to be political, I just want to make great bombs for whoever."

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by EternalFury on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:01AM (#42184921)
I am probably jaded. The way I see it, activisms and politics are occupations of the wealthy. I want to be wrong, but when I observe the political landscape, I find this to be true. I have no interest in being an activist or a politician. I disapprove of many ideologies and policies, and I vote accordingly, but trying to make minds beyond my own has only reduced my quality of life.
Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by skissane on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:22PM (#42190809)
> Begging for forums and content to be apolitical is just willfully wearing blinders. It may be great for mental health, but it's probably not great for society.

Politics is still largely a national affair. One will often observe online discussions of some topic which isn’t in itself nation-specific get derailed into tangents about US national politics - and for non-Americans, that can be an annoying and alienating distraction. So an online space with cultural norms (or moderation) against political tangents can be more globally inclusive as a result.

Even transnational politics tends to be somewhat region-specific: Brexit was a much bigger deal for people in France than for people in Japan, for cross-strait or inter-Korea relations it is the other way around

Of course, intellectually curious people will often be interested in reading intelligent takes on the politics of the other side of the planet, even if it has minimal relevance to their own life. But a lot of online political discussion isn’t like that, it is just tribal point scoring and repetitive predictable talking points that have been said a thousand times before

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by cafebabbe on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @11:17AM (#42195392)
Code is law, and it's becoming more & more like this every day, so it's kind of weird that people insist it's feasible to be able to discuss technology without any of the its consequence & implications.

Plus, when i try to think of something apolitical, HN is clearly not the first thing that pops to mind. Yeah, it 'tries', indeed

Re:Bluesky just crossed 20M users by cafebabbe on Wednesday November 20, 2024 @11:11AM (#42195302)
I don't see what's preventing you to discuss "ideas" on Bluesky, or Twitter.

I don't discuss politics either, but i had good interactions on both of these platforms.