Re:PHP: The Right Way
by mcantor on Sunday July 08, 2012 @12:46AM
(#4213674)
Yeah... only idiots "sudo aptitude install" without reading and building from source first!
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You really can't tell the difference between blindly executing input from an insecure HTTP connection, and installing packages with a tool that verifies cryptographic signatures against known good keys shipped with your distro?
Mr. Cantor, I have added to the list of people to never hire I keep in my notebook.
You can explain the difference without attacking the person you're replying to.
Re:PHP: The Right Way
by huhtenberg on Sunday July 08, 2012 @02:32AM
(#4213879)
The risk of picking up malicious executable from the legit server is far higher than that of picking up a malicious executable from an impersonating server. Practically speaking.
So? Who says the verified package isn't malicious? My point isn't about cryptography, it's about complexity. Unless you personally read through every line of code, how do you really know that there isn't something in there waiting to screw you over?
I trust my system's package maintainers and the signing makes sure that it is them.
I do not trust a random website that could easily be MITMd.
So you'd be fine with https?
You don't know. What you know however is who to sue if the package ends up being malicious, thanks to the signature.