News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Quinzel on Thursday November 14, 2024 @05:11AM (#42134707)
I don’t believe Gwern lives as frugally as he’s described in this (if this even actually is the real Gwern). I’m 100% sure that he has a persona he likes to portray and being perceived as frugal is a part of that persona. When it comes to answering the question “who is gwern?” I reckon Gwern’s a plant a seed in people’s mind type of guy, and let them come up with the rest of the story.

Still, I like a lot of his writing. Especially the weird and niche stuff that most people don’t even stop to think about. And thanks to Gwern’s essay on the sunk costs fallacy, I ended up not getting a tattoo that I had changed my mind about. I almost got it because I had paid a deposit, but I genuinely decided I hated the idea of what I was going to get… and almost got it, but the week before I went to get the tattoo, I read that essay, and decided if small children and animals don’t fall victim to sunk costs, then neither should I! Literally - Gwern saved the skin on my back with his writing. Haha.

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Tenoke on Thursday November 14, 2024 @07:13AM (#42135472)
I'm fairly sure it's relatively true (except for occasional extra purchases on top) unless he's been keeping it up in places I wouldn't expect him to.

I don't like that now people might pigeonhole him a bit by thinking about his effective frugality but I do hope he gets a ton of donations (either directly or via patreon.com/gwern ) to make up for it.

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by dash2 on Thursday November 14, 2024 @07:14AM (#42135475)
Have you got any real evidence behind your first paragraph?
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by michaelt on Thursday November 14, 2024 @08:14AM (#42135873)
I don't follow gwern's work closely.

But I do know he created an enormous dataset of anime images used to train machine learning and generative AI models [1]. Hosting large datasets is moderately expensive - and it's full of NSFW stuff, so he's probably not having his employer or his college host it. Easy for someone on a six-figure salary, difficult for a person on $12k/year.

Also, I thought these lesswrong folks were all about "effective altruism" and "earning to give" and that stuff.

[1] https://gwern.net/danbooru2021

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by esdf on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:22AM (#42137757)
Hosting large datasets can be expensive but the hosting for the danbooru datasets was not. It's "only" a few terabytes in size. A previous release was 3.4TB, so the latest is probably some hundreds of GB, to a TB~, in size larger. The download was hosted on a hetzner IP, which is a provider known for cheap servers. You can pay them $50/m for a server with "unmetered" 1gigabit up/down network + 16TB of disks. $600 a year would not be difficult.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by itake on Friday November 15, 2024 @11:59AM (#42148668)
$600 a year is a lot of money..
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by gwern on Friday November 15, 2024 @10:19PM (#42153849)
I think people tend to wildly overestimate how expensive hosting a large dataset has to be, because of cloud.

If you only need a few terabytes, you can rent from Hetzner for more like <$20/month. Maybe <$10 at this point, if you are patient. And you can use the server for other things too, since it's a fixed cost, like your website or encrypted backups or other files you host. I spent a while figuring this out before I decided to do Danbooru20xx, to make sure it was very cheap. Given how my website has grown in size, and how absurdly exorbitant cloud bandwidth and object/hard drive space is, the Danbooru dataset was practically free at the margin!

> Also, I thought these lesswrong folks were all about "effective altruism" and "earning to give" and that stuff.

Some people are, some people aren't. I'm not. (I have intellectual sympathy with EA, but not emotional.)

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by freejazz on Thursday November 14, 2024 @04:14PM (#42141293)
I think it would be more odd to take someone with such a shtick at their word, but skepticism abounds either way.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Quinzel on Sunday November 17, 2024 @05:01AM (#42163179)
Do people need evidence for an opinion?
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by cpp_frog on Thursday November 14, 2024 @06:48AM (#42135298)
There is a comment on the r/slatestarcodex subreddit with supposedly true information about him (which I found googling 'who is gwern'), but it left me with even more questions.

EDIT: grammar

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by scarmig on Thursday November 14, 2024 @08:04AM (#42135805)
That comment is just a fanciful flight of whimsy.

> Gwern was the first patient to successfully complete a medical transition to the gender he was originally assigned at birth... his older brother died of a Nuvigil overdose in 2001... his (rather tasteful) neck tattoo of the modafinil molecule

The only concrete things we actually know about gwern are that he's a world-renowned breeder of Maine Coons and that he is the sole known survivor of a transverse cerebral bifurcation.

He does have a neck tattoo, but it's actually a QR code containing the minimal weights to label MNIST at 99% accuracy.

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by trogdor on Thursday November 14, 2024 @04:59PM (#42141673)
> The only concrete things we know about gwern are that he's a world-renowned breeder of Maine Coons and that he is the sole known survivor of a transverse cerebral bifurcation.

How do you know those things are true?

Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Vecr on Thursday November 14, 2024 @05:29PM (#42141890)
They aren't, he doesn't even live in Maine.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by ComputerGuru on Thursday November 14, 2024 @10:02PM (#42143618)
You clearly don’t know what a Maine Coon is…
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Quinzel on Saturday November 16, 2024 @04:13AM (#42155425)
Meow
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by dewey on Thursday November 14, 2024 @07:00AM (#42135379)
There's some articles on his site about these attempts and they claim that they are all wrong. If it would be that "easily found" I'd guess we wouldn't be having these discussions: https://gwern.net/blackmail#pseudonymity-bounty
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by tectec on Thursday November 14, 2024 @07:02AM (#42135392)
Can you link the comment here?
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by endtime on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:42AM (#42137983)
I met Gwern once, when he came to the NYC Less Wrong meetup. I don't think he was internet-famous yet. It was probably 12 years ago or so, but based on my recollection, I'm totally willing to believe that he lives very frugally. FWIW he wouldn't have looked out of place at an anime convention.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Quinzel on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:48PM (#42139685)
What did he look like?
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by endtime on Thursday November 14, 2024 @11:11PM (#42143900)
I don't really want to do anything to deanonymize a guy who clearly wants to be anonymous. But I will say that at the time he had long hair.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by nuz on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:49PM (#42139691)
I believe him.
Re:Gwern Branwen – How an Anonymous Researcher Predicted AI'... by Quinzel on Thursday November 14, 2024 @01:58PM (#42139832)
You believe that someone who has the capacity and resources to do all this fancy computer and AI stuff lives on $12k USD a year? That’s hilarious.

I’m willing to bet he became a millionaire thanks to bitcoin.