News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by animal_spirits on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:53AM (#42108018)
The people who want to revive the woolly mammoth want to release them into the Siberian Steppe to restore grassland to fix carbon into the earth.

- https://e360.yale.edu/features/the_case_for_de-extinction_wh...

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by thayne on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:19AM (#42108246)
That sounds like a justification for something they want to do for other reasons (like attracting funding).
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by bondarchuk on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:47AM (#42108491)
If it works it works and the original motivations don't really matter then. Now whether it would actually work is something else ofc.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:28PM (#42108809)
well that's why I'm skeptical too, what are the odds that a big vanity project just happens to also be a great climate change fix? They also want to resurrect the dodo and the Tasmanian tiger. It's hard enough to find climate solutions that work when you're motivated by that, when you're motivated by "doing cool stuff" you might stumble onto a solution, but the odds do seem rather low.

They would be trying to resurrect the mammoth either way, so it's not like there's any real incentive to actually research whether it will work.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 11, 2024 @03:21PM (#42110156)
> It's hard enough to find climate solutions that work when you're motivated by that, when you're motivated by "doing cool stuff" you might stumble onto a solution, but the odds do seem rather low.

Yes, it is critical to not let your focus split, and always stay true to the most important goal.

If you're a robot.

"Doing cool stuff" is one of the major, most basic drives behind progress of science and technology. Definitely more honest than "doing it for the money" or "doing it for social status", where you can always find ways to cheat if the going gets annoying. "Doing cool stuff" is up there with "doing it to save ourselves from an imminent, lethal threat" - the other highly reliable motivator that has little tolerance for bullshit, and was responsible for most of the rapid progress thorough history. Of the two, I'd prefer the one that doesn't involve violence and fear of death. It's probably more sustainable, too.

See also: something something Feynman on having fun in research.

Consider also: Most progress happens in small increments; the set of people motivated by wanting to solve climate is small, so it doesn't really hurt to also add the people motivated by doing cool shit in parallel. The chance of getting critical increment doubles; the chance of any one in any of the two groups having the full solution is ~zero.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by xorbax on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:13PM (#42110473)
Also, recreation is technology. If it turns out that ten mammoths are more efficient and require less human maintenance to modulate tundra and encourage the ecocycle, we know how to do it. We don't need to start a 50 year investment in 2050 and hope it works. Mammoths are likely to be equally or more useful than AI image generation or gigantic warehouses that sequester carbon given various precision-machined parts and chemical engineering. Animals are more efficient and require fewer externalities than most human endeavors. Even if we just ignore the externalities and admire these new impressive technologies. Life is very efficient.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by TeMPOraL on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:59PM (#42110801)
Agree with all, except for:

> Life is very efficient.

I mean, is it? It's a total tangent, but I've long been having a problem wrapping my mind around the topic of efficiency of life. At whichever scale I look, from ecosystems to inner workings of cells, I see systems held in balance by negative feedback loops, zero-sum games. That is, everything fights everything else for resources, and what we call "balance" is a temporary equilibrium between reproduction, destruction and starvation. Feels like the exact opposite of efficiency. And yet, I can't deny that life can and does a lot with very little. I'm not sure how to reconcile this.

I have this general image in my head wrt. efficiency. Imagine you want to put a box a meter above the ground. There are many ways to do it. You could strap a PLC controller and a rocket engine to it, and keep it up actively. You could put it on a floating platform, filled with hot air, or better, helium or hydrogen. Or, you could just put a mast in the ground and bolt the box to it. The first one is obviously the least efficient, and the last one the most.

When I look at life, I see a lot of things being balanced by means equivalent to the rocket engine approach.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by kadonoishi on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:39PM (#42111434)
Ok, so, try dividing time into a view of it repeating, and progressing.

Time "repeats" in that we have days, years; your heart repeatedly beats about once a second; menstruation is about a month.

Time "progresses" more literally in that nothing repeats, "repeating" seems like an abstraction. Tuesday, Nov 12, 2024 only happens once; Tuesday happens every week; Nov 12 happens every year.

It's not very workable to keep in mind the literal physical view that every day, every second is unique. Interferes with using experience.

Here's [0] a nice video on Schrodinger's equation, where it's written nicely

H psi = ih d/dt psi

H is doing a lot of work. psi is the mysterious wave function. h explains what it's talking about by giving the units.

The i on the right side, in this writing, is associated with the time partial derivative d/dt. i, the imaginary number, is associated with rotations, which means in a way this writing of Schrodinger's Equation is implying rotational time, repeating time.

Suppose time really is legit repeating even way down deep. Then try reinterpreting your negative feedback loops as repeating time.

To extend speculatively, invoke the notion of fractals, where you can iterate and find more complexity thereby.

So suppose that life repeats time, but in the manner of a fractal where you uncover more structure by iterating.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WPA1L9uJqo

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by BalinKing on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:47PM (#42111478)
It's been a while since I took any classes about it, but I don't think i implies "repeating time." I'm pretty sure it's just from the fact that waves themselves are repeating, i.e. periodic. But Schrodinger's equation doesn't say anything about the nature of time itself IIRC.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by kadonoishi on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:58PM (#42111536)
Yeah, yes, Schrodinger meant no such thing. But suppose for a moment that a wave, in going up and down repeatedly, is manifesting time itself repeating. Like time legit has an aspect where it's a repeating thing.

To reconcile that with the common experience of time progressing, it could be a sort of statistical matter of time not repeating exactly, where the accumulation of little differences produces the experience of passing time out of quantum-level mostly repeating time.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:33PM (#42111746)
I think it's great to have "help fix the climate" as a sort of stretch goal for someone's cool project, it's just not something I'm going to take particularly seriously. Maybe they'll produce a couple mammoths who get sold to zoos and then get bored and move on to their dodo resurrection instead.

I worry that they can use the climate change argument to deflect from the ethical arguments around whether it's even a good idea to resurrect a highly intelligent social animal like this. Imagine bioengineering a resurrected "Neanderthal" into a world without Neanderthals. There's something bleak about it. If the breeding/release idea doesn't work out you've just intentionally created some endlings[0] with no real future.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endling

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by Teever on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:30AM (#42113769)
Asimov wrote an interesting story that has a similar premise.[0] Since I read it as a child I have wanted to see cloned hominids.

I think that in the near future we'll wealthy weirdos start to clone their ancestors, and things like native groups in colonized places like Canada or New Zealand start to clone their ancestors to buff up their population and strengthen their legal claims to territory. Think about what we'll be able to do with artificial wombs.[1]

As for your neanderthal endlings it probably will be pretty bleak for a lot of these hominids, but who knows, maybe some of them will end up being smarter than your average human and they'll have a role in society.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ugly_Little_Boy

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/25/15421734/artificial-womb-...

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by stanford_labrat on Monday November 11, 2024 @03:32PM (#42110211)
you'd be absolutely right that the global warming justification is a retro-active "find a problem" situation. the true motivator lies in the technology that Colossal is attempting to accomplish the mammoth cloning with.

as it stands right now, cloning of any organism requires at the very least living fibroblast cells. Of course, you cannot get these from deceased mammals. Colossal's strategy is to essentially blast the host genome with fragments of the subjects DNA (which you can get from deceased/fossilized tissue) and hope that the end result is an elephant cell that's been reprogrammed into a mammoth-like cell from which to do cloning.

imo if they really wanted a mammoth, they could just make a hairy elephant. that would be 10x easier. but the whole idea is being able to resurrect...mammals.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by inglor_cz on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:01AM (#42113642)
From a certain point of view, the entire civilization beyond the absolute basics is a "big vanity project". Whenever you gaze at Notre Dame or Taj Mahal, or even an old Greek amphitheatre of which there are hundreds, you can say "this could have been used to feed the poor, no one needs a theatre to survive and a theatre won't help us solve climate change or whatever pressing problem is on the horizon".

But people in general don't want to live completely utilitarian life, and your "vanity" is someone else's "exploration of the possible" or "lifting up human mind". Both of you might even be right at the same time.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @05:40PM (#42131004)
It's a bit like saying you're going to Mars to save the world. No, you're going to Mars because it would be cool.

Doing stuff because it would be cool is great, it's just kind of dumb to pretend you're doing it for a practical purpose. Just say you want to do the big thing because it would be fun, or inspiring, or you have a trillion dollars and can afford it.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by patall on Monday November 11, 2024 @01:56PM (#42109532)
Maybe my view is a different one here (I have donated to Pleistocene Park before), but at least here in Europe most big ecological project seem to follow the megaherbivore theory, and try to implement it in some areas.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by TylerE on Monday November 11, 2024 @02:18PM (#42109692)
Doesn't that line of thinking just lead to endless reductionism? Is anything besides literally curing cancer and feeding the starving worthwhile for you?
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by sushid on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:39PM (#42110653)
I mean isn't that what a lot of random robotics labs do as well (e.g. "some potential application for this feature includes search and rescue, etc.")? What's wrong with it?
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by lolinder on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:00AM (#42108081)
I mentioned that, but I think that's a pitch to get investors into a project that actually started because they read Jurassic Park and got the wrong message. It's a classic solution in search of a problem.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by tw04 on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:18AM (#42108236)
The problem is Siberia releasing carbon, that’s pretty clearly and well defined. I don’t know what other “more efficient” solution we could possibly have. Sometimes nature is the best solution to the problem.

It’s no different than reintroducing beavers into areas to reduce wildfires. Nothing we’ve invented so far is a better option.

https://coloradosun.com/2024/04/19/fighting-wildland-fire-wi...

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by lolinder on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:21AM (#42108264)
No one looked at siberia's carbon emissions and said "let's revive the mammoth to solve that problem". They started with the mammoth resurrection program and then found a justification for it.

That doesn't mean the justification that they found is necessarily invalid, but the reason why solutions in search of a problem are problematic is that the chosen solution is rarely the optimal one because it wasn't designed for the problem—the problem was designed for the solution.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by s1artibartfast on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:04PM (#42108617)
I dont think that is a fair criticism of solutions in search of a problem. I would argue that the vast majority of technology and innovation falls into this category.

The wheel and combustion engine weren't invented as a bespoke solutions for automobiles and trains. The internet wasn't invented as a platform for e-commerce.

History is full of examples of technology leading the application, with curious or enterprising individuals adapting the technology to a productive use.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by aziaziazi on Monday November 11, 2024 @02:21PM (#42109717)
History is also almost empty of positive climate change outcome. Photovoltaic might be an exemption.

EV batteries is still unresolved at scale and cars are still made of tons of extracted metals and oilchemestry. They are fun and new tech sell well and oil price go up. That’s the reasons EV were invented. Branding them as green works great because it’s look plausible and we all want to have greener cars (and/or continue using them, which is correlated).

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by s1artibartfast on Monday November 11, 2024 @02:34PM (#42109819)
>History is also almost empty of positive climate change outcome.

What would you consider positive a climate change outcome? I think there are tons of positive outcomes, but agree there is a lot of greenwashing as well.

Moving from coal to natural gas has a enormous positive outcome. PV is as well. US CO2 per capita and total emissions are down 25% in the last 20 years, which is a massive positive outcome. Global CO2 per capita has gone negative, which is another massive win.

It is too soon to tell, but we may even be at or have passed global peak emissions, which will be another massive milestone.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by aziaziazi on Monday November 11, 2024 @03:12PM (#42110090)
> moving from coal

We didn’t, and coal consumption even double since 80’s. What we did is add oil to it and then gaz [0]. Some could argue that without oil and gaz, coal might be even higher today. In that sense gas is more a “less bad” than a good one : it did not diminish the coal consumption neither out energy need.

https://ourworldindata.org/fossil-fuels

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by CrazyStat on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:13PM (#42110472)
Individual countries like the US absolutely have moved away from coal; US coal consumption has been cut in half in the past 20 years. These reductions have been more than offset by increases in other countries.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by s1artibartfast on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:49PM (#42110727)
US Coal is half of what it was in 2007. Is that not progress? Would you rather we double it back to where it was? because that was the alternative alternative.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by aziaziazi on Monday November 11, 2024 @05:31PM (#42111040)
By “we” I don’t mean “USA” but “humans”. I’m very happy USA did cut its coal consumption.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:27AM (#42108310)
What a weak, by-side-effect argument.

You present no evidence it won't work, but you oppose it because you think the method might be... sub-optimal? Maybe?

Ironically it sounds like you started with opposition to this project (I blame Jurassic Park) and then worked backwards in search of a justification for your opinion.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by sobellian on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:34AM (#42108363)
The giant problem leaping out at me is, what evidence do we have that mammoths could even survive in the wild today, let alone thrive to the extent necessary to change the ecology? They went extinct, after all.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by jjk166 on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:18PM (#42110518)
If we knew the answer ahead of time, there would be no point in doing the experiment.

One can easily argue that Mammoths ought to be able to survive - they survived periods with climates similar to our current one and there are a lot fewer paleolithic hunters running about now. But we won't really know unless we try.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @05:53PM (#42111178)
>a lot fewer paleolithic hunters

Modern poachers with modern technology beat paleolithic hunters, hands down.

Technology works, as it turns out... :D

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by jjk166 on Monday November 11, 2024 @06:14PM (#42111283)
Poachers aren't part of the natural environment. When people say "survive in the wild" they are typically referring to the case where the species' and its natural habitat are largely left alone by modern civilization. Any species could be wiped out if humans tried to do so, even humans.

Anyways, in this scenario we have the means of producing mammoths at will, so why would there be a market for mammoth poaching? If people do kill a mammoth, just add another mammoth. Technology works.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @10:41PM (#42112575)
I wish semantics worked against actual poachers. :-(

  >why would there be a market for mammoth poaching?
You haven't met humans, I see.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by jjk166 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:25PM (#42119856)
I don't think you understood what I was saying. Why would there be a market for poaching an animal that is mass-bred in captivity?
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:38AM (#42108408)
If you started at the problem and worked in the other direction, maybe there are half a dozen ideas for solutions that are cheaper and more likely to work than "engineer mammoths." Like, is the engineering project even likely to work, if it works will they actually be bred in any number, if they are will anyone be willing to let them roam free, if they roam free are they likely to survive and breed more, if they do are they likely to have a positive impact, etc.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:41AM (#42108430)

  > maybe
What is this, National Argument By Insinuation Day? :-\

I don't even have a dog in this fight one way or another, I just call out terrible and weak logical arguments when I see them. This thread is rife with bad arguments.

It seems people here thought "Jurassic Park bad," then twisted themselves into knots to come up with something to complain about. Bad form guys.

If you want to fool people (in a durable way that's immune to logic), write a book or movie they watch as a kid.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:44AM (#42108454)
The point is that when someone comes up with an expensive vanity project with a promise that it's really about climate change, you don't have to believe them.

Maybe they are coincidentally right and it will work, but they definitely seem less interested in rigorously investigating whether it will work than investigating the cool parts of engineering a mammoth.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:45AM (#42108469)
...and you don't have to disbelieve that it will work either. It gives you no evidence either way.

"Really about" climate change is a different issue from whether or not it works. You're again trying to change the subject to the distraction issue of original intent, not actual efficacy (for which you clearly have no evidence, only insinuation).

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:51AM (#42108511)
The odds that a vanity project that someone picked because they thought it was cool will fix climate change seems substantially lower than a project that was picked because they really think it will fix climate change. Those two things are pretty closely related, since it's much easier to come up with a cool project with a vague promise of a climate change goal than a project that will really work.

Instead of bringing back mammoths, maybe help genetically engineer existing species to help them adapt faster, like people are doing with coral. I don't know, but "resurrecting the mammoths" is probably far down the list of useful climate change projects these people could be putting effort into.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:52AM (#42108524)
> I don't know, but...

That's the thread, folks! Thanks for finally admitting your lack of a real evidence-based argument.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:55AM (#42108550)
The mammoth-breeders aren't climate change experts either. They're genetic engineers. They don't know either, but they're selling it like they do.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:00PM (#42108590)
Genetic engineers can't talk to / work with climate experts? News to me.

Specialization of labor within a project is hardly a new concept.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by roywiggins on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:24PM (#42108778)
Well that's the thing, I don't think they care whether it would benefit the climate. They want to do it either way. They're also trying to de-extinct the dodo and the Tasmanian tiger. So why should I trust them that they've done the research?

If it does work, that would be awesome. A wooly mammoth certainly sounds cool and it's not my money, so whatever.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by ipaddr on Monday November 11, 2024 @02:17PM (#42109691)
Someone might trust them because they sat through a presentation, read the facts and have a background. Why should you trust them? I don't think you should. Save your trust for things you know about.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by schiffern on Monday November 11, 2024 @05:24PM (#42110994)
Quoting myself (missed it the first time?):

  > You're again trying to change the subject to the distraction issue of original intent, not actual efficacy.
We're spinning in circles now. You have no argument against the concept or against the results, only a vague disdain for the path taken. You don't enjoy the storybook, nothing more.

Come back with a real argument please. Until then we have nothing to talk about.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by IncreasePosts on Monday November 11, 2024 @03:12PM (#42110089)
Let's be realistic though, if wooly mammoths we're released in Siberia, the first thing millions of trophy hunters would do is flock to Siberia and shoot them all.
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by animal_spirits on Monday November 11, 2024 @12:08PM (#42108656)
Yeah, but this is far from putting them "in a cage". Watching the documentary on the lead of this, Stewart Brand, it is clear his goal is to build the technology to prevent species extinction and to re-introduce animals that have already been extinct. The parts about climate change are a justification for pursuing woolly mammoths specifically.

- https://www.weareasgods.film

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by DimuP on Monday November 11, 2024 @11:53AM (#42108532)
At least that would be useful
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by anyonecancode on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:19PM (#42110523)
I'm skeptical that would work. Animals aren't robots; their behavior isn't just programmed in to their DNA. Absent adult mammoths to teach the newly "revived" mammoth how to be a mammoth, I doubt it simply releasing them onto the steppe would work. Very likely, the mammoth would die.

So then this becomes an exercise in cruelty, bringing a creature to life only for it to suffer a painful, short existence. Reminds me of Frankenstein, honestly.

Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by josefx on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:28PM (#42110591)
If only there was some kind of way to raise and train animals. Next thing you know people will try to harness fire and lightning, madness!
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by anyonecancode on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:42PM (#42111800)
Is there a real-world example of raising an animal from birth, with no contact with any others of its kind, being released into the wild and successfully living there?
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by shiroiushi on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:28AM (#42113045)
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by jandrese on Monday November 11, 2024 @04:27PM (#42110586)
What's wrong with the elk that are already there? Is there something about the mammoth that makes them better at fixing carbon?
Re:Did Scientists Revive an Extinct Animal or Just Breed a L... by seanhunter on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @11:07AM (#42116691)
Well I had dinner with Ben Lamm[1] and he was very open in saying that for him the whole project was about setting up a big zoo attraction and charging people a bunch of money to come and see the mammoths.

[1] Co-founder of colossal, the company that is attempting the mammoth de-extinction.