I wouldn't begrudge professional tooling companies trying to use consumer marketing to reach early-stage projects, when most early-stage projects are built by hobbyists, side-project-ists, professionals-who-arent-software-professionals, etc.
I think you're biased by the fact that the latter generates more attention briefly.
I may be biased, but I wouldn't be the only one :) There are so many great new projects getting started in South America, Middle East, Asia, Africa being built by people from non-traditional backgrounds who see software as a ladder to a middle-class or upper-middle-class livelihood. Just because their products sell to markets you're not familiar with, doesn't mean they don't exist.
I love the clip of @dhh's keynote to engineer's "learned helplessness" to AWS and the cloud [2]. While SST + containers is very very different than DHH's Kamal [3], they both embrace containers without the paas service tax (heroku/vercel/etc) or the overhead of kubernetes.
1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Afpgnb_9bA4
i made this video because it reflects my sense of humor and is the kind of content i'd appreciate
anything outside business as usual will draw polarizing reactions
but in a noisy world that's the only thing that'll work
- The junior dev with no say in decisions
- The seasoned contributors whose opinion is listened to but who know that there is no magic tool, only compromises
- The managers who almost always have the last word, who live with constant FOMO, and whose jobs are mostly based on impressions rather than actual results
So I think there are some people who don’t love the idea that tech is being driven by content creators.
But the reality is a well marketed product will always perform better than a well engineered product.
Given the fact that all these tools are interchangeable based on where you want to sacrifice, I actually think it’s pretty cool they are doing this kind of marketing.
You can’t win in that area on just product. And I think that really brothers a certain kind of HN poster.
This is a YC company.
Maybe not exactly a "product" in the normal sense (but neither is a Terraform-in-JS thingy so) but Linux beat every other competitor (in the server space) by just being "better", rather than "more marketed". I'm sure there are more examples out there proving "well marketed" doesn't always win.
Those PR messages are a form of marketing in and of themselves. It doesn’t have to be a commercial on Fox during football on Sunday.
You have to be authentic and speak to your audience.
- The reaction of many to something simple[1] becomes "oh it must be fly-by-night"
- It is more likely someone close to the project who can and will enjoy making something slick-looking
- B2B companies have had reasonably slick marketing for at least a decade, and there's always been a desire for many open projects to look like they can "play with the big boys"
I've noticed a trend where some of the dev tooling nowadays is sold almost as if it were consumer goods with the whole associated marketing behind it. This doesn't work for me, in reality actually has completely opposite effect. Give me boring well-written docs, that shows engineering that went into it, not the marketing show for teenagers.