News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by Reason077 on Saturday November 09, 2024 @09:22PM (#42098214)
Stargate. The original movie was cool but I never could get in to the TV show, even during its heyday with Richard Dean Anderson. That said, if they ever did a reboot I'd probably check it out!
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by jsnell on Saturday November 09, 2024 @10:00PM (#42098339)
I've watched seasons 1-5 this year. It's basically my first run through, I'd only watched a couple of random episodes back in the day and not been impressed, so there's no nostalgia at play here.

It absolutely holds up, and does things that seem to be impossible for streaming-era TV shows in terms of building the characters and the universe.

The first season is very obviously done on a shoestring budget, but the production values will start improving after that. I honestly can't imagine what value a reboot would bring.

Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by Izkata on Sunday November 10, 2024 @03:01AM (#42099016)
You're right around the point they got renewed for two seasons at once, so they had a lot more freedom for extended plot/setting development. I forget exactly which two seasons they were, though.

If you're continuing and at all interested in the timing, SG-1 season 8 has a two-parter premiere, and Stargate Atlantis begins immediately after that, not before or at the same time.

I'd actually decided to re-watch the series this year and am just finishing the 8th season right now.

Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by jsnell on Sunday November 10, 2024 @06:20PM (#42103305)
Yes, I was intending to continue at least until Atlantis so that I can check that out with the proper context as well. Thanks for the details on viewing order.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by cheald on Saturday November 09, 2024 @09:41PM (#42098282)
The first couple of seasons are a little rocky, but once it established its own cast of characters and mythos, it really became something special.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by lightlyused on Saturday November 09, 2024 @11:15PM (#42098526)
The one where Teal'c goes to a performance of the Vagina Dialogs is one of my favorites.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by self_awareness on Sunday November 10, 2024 @03:33AM (#42099101)
Lol, had to Google it.

Indeed!

Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by aetherspawn on Saturday November 09, 2024 @09:53PM (#42098321)
Atlantis was a lot better than SG1 in my opinion (relative to modern attention spans), maybe start there.

I liked SG Universe but it got a bit Home-and-away every now and then which was off-putting. Relationships in a sci-fi? Who cares

Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by Zanni on Saturday November 09, 2024 @10:21PM (#42098399)
Universe was the only series I watched (due to Scalzi being a technical advisor), but I found it infuriating that they let Tim Roth's character continue to have the run of the ship after he proved himself a psychopath.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by Izkata on Sunday November 10, 2024 @03:06AM (#42099037)
Do you mean Robert Carlyle? Tim Roth kind of looks similar to him, but doesn't appear to have been on any Stargate.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by Zanni on Monday November 11, 2024 @07:35PM (#42111753)
That is who I mean, thank you. It's been a few years ...
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by pmlnr on Sunday November 10, 2024 @03:07AM (#42099039)
The first season of universe is off putting. Shame because the second was brilliant.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by aetherspawn on Sunday November 10, 2024 @06:29AM (#42099654)
Yes, I think universe is one of the most innovative sci-fi ever written in terms of using plausible science to form a plot.

I also appreciated they went into a lot of effort to explain, technically, how each plot element worked. For example they explained the science behind the gates in great detail, the shields, the air system, the stones, the vastness of space between the galaxies, etc.. don’t need to go into more detail it’s kind of spoilers.

By doing it that way they made sure that all the plot twists were simple and obvious in hindsight but difficult to predict beforehand, which was very satisfying.

Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by lazystar on Saturday November 09, 2024 @09:44PM (#42098291)
the plot arcs don't hold up very well, but I highly recommend watching the monster of the week episodes. some of those one-off episodes, like the black hole episode, expanded my concepts of time and space in ways that I have not experienced while watching other sci fi shows.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by cridenour on Saturday November 09, 2024 @09:30PM (#42098253)
Funny enough, I felt the complete opposite. Loved the shows, especially Atlantis, but found the movie pretty meh.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by s0rce on Saturday November 09, 2024 @09:31PM (#42098262)
I liked both. TV show was great through.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by pmlnr on Sunday November 10, 2024 @03:08AM (#42099041)
The movie didn't age well. The series' will probably hold up forever.
Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by Avamander on Sunday November 10, 2024 @06:25AM (#42099640)
I really wouldn't go for a reboot. SG: Origins was kinda bad even. There's a bunch of lore they could build on top of that people love and new viewers could learn to love. They could find all new cast and everything, like Atlantis was for a while and do cameos.

The issue will likely be that the streaming format does not encourage character building the way it was. They'd likely make a really long movie split into seven parts. Which is not Stargate, with it's weekly monsters, overarching plotlines and occasional gags.

Re:Stargate built 15 years ago in Ohio 50k pounds concrete f... by drivingmenuts on Sunday November 10, 2024 @07:36AM (#42099869)
I didn't start watching until the first couple of seasons were available on ... gasp ... DVD (remember those)?

Got the first season because I was bored. Laid on the couch all weekend watching the entire set of shows. Called in sick on Monday and Tuesday so I could go buy and watch the second season.

I used to own the movie, all ten(?) seasons and the SG-1 movies. I rewatched them a couple of times.

It holds up surprisingly well. I wouldn't argue against a reboot, but I would want to see something different rather than just copying the old shows with a different cast.

I think maybe the last couple of seasons were kind of a bit of stunt casting and while it eventually sort of worked, those were the worst shows since it was just sort of a rehash of the "Well, we pissed off yet another super-alien race by existing so lets kick their asses" idea. New villains, same as the old villain.