I think people mistake his radical-styled rhetoric for radical policies

Trump is one of the most moderate Republicans on most social issues (abortion, lgb, criminal justice etc.)

He is the most moderate on entitlements (constantly promises to not cut medicare, medicaid and social security) contrary to every Republican campaign in the past (remember Paul Ryan?)

He is a "moderate" on foreign policy (not a Cheney/Bush war hawk, not a 60's style pacifist)

I could go on but I think the important point is; every point he wants to make, he makes in the loudest most wild way possible and people who aren't disposed to vote for him anyway see that as "radical". The correct word IMO is "crazy" or "wild".

Voters who are in the center or can swing either way see him as promising fairly conventional things but in a crazy tone. Maybe tone doesn't matter as much to them

I agree that there's a huge difference between the rhetoric and policies. I'm having a hard time wrapping my head around people viewing him as both a "straight talker" and someone who's "just jokin'". There's also huge variability about his personal policy whims he may lose interest in, and those in power around him with strong and motivated agendas.

He is a "moderate" on foreign policy (not a Cheney/Bush war hawk)

Which is hogwash, because at the time Trump went along with the Iraq war just like everybody else, of course:

   In the interview, which took place on Sept. 11, 2002, Stern asked Trump directly if he was for invading Iraq.

   "Yeah, I guess so," Trump responded. "I wish the first time it was done correctly."

https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/andrewkaczynski/in-2002...

So actually, um yeah, he was a "Cheney/Bush war hawk" just like the rest of them.

That really doesn't make your point. "I guess so" is the absolute opposite of what a hawk would say. "I guess so" is what the comment you're replying to is still implying he'd say.

I have no idea if they edited this in later or you removed it but just pointing this out: > not a 60's style pacifist

for the record; was not edited.

The part you need to focus on is where he says: "I wish the first time it was done correctly."