News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by lxgr on Monday November 04, 2024 @03:15PM (#42045597)
Did he actually say that?

Because in the article, there's only a tweet of him saying that Perplexity is "on standby to help", of which "offering to replace striking staff with AI" seems a pretty strong mischaracterization.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by seabass-labrax on Monday November 04, 2024 @03:48PM (#42045836)
> ...to help ensure your essential coverage is available to all through the election.

That sounds liking replacing striking staff to me, at least for the duration of the election. What other services of value except LLMs to write articles does Perplexity have to offer to the New York Times?

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by lxgr on Monday November 04, 2024 @03:53PM (#42045870)
> That sounds liking replacing striking staff to me

That's my read too, but they could also e.g. lend them some engineers, have them build an election dashboard for them etc.

The fact that that would still be crossing the picket line, how realistic any of that is, or how genuine the offer, are all great questions/observations, but "replace with AI" seems like a quite dishonest editorialization in any case.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by seabass-labrax on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:10PM (#42046003)
If editorialization is ever appropriate, this feels to me like the right time. Substantively, Perplexity make LLM tools - that's all they advertise on their website and what they are known for. Maybe they do have some jack-of-all-trade engineers who could turn their hands to web development or something, but there are also no doubt cleaners working at Perplexity. They aren't offering the New York Times help with the toilets!
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by morpheuskafka on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:22PM (#42046099)
But the article writers at NYT aren’t on strike—-as they’re in a diff bargaining unit with a contract and no-strike clause.

The only way having AI write articles would help is if it freed up working staff to help out with tech stuff-—which they said they won’t do.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by seabass-labrax on Monday November 04, 2024 @07:47PM (#42047637)
Thank you for pointing that out; I missed it myself. That would imply that Perplexity's offer probably isn't even helpful in this situation, and it rather proves lxgr's point about TechCrunch's editorialization! It seems that the original journalist has made a correction:

> Though TechCrunch asked Perplexity for comment, Srinivas responded to TechCrunch’s post on X saying that “the offer was not to ‘replace’ journalists or engineers with AI but to provide technical infra support on a high-traffic day.” The striking workers in question, however, are the ones who provide that service to the NYT. It’s not really clear what services other than AI tools Perplexity could offer, or why they would not amount to replacing the workers in question. (However, in response to the clarification, we have opted to change the headline to reflect the claim that this offer was not necessarily specific to AI services.)

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by llm_trw on Monday November 04, 2024 @07:40PM (#42047604)
I've found llm generated code to work amazingly well for visualisation since you can just look and check you're getting the right results.
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by benatkin on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:51PM (#42046341)
I don't think it's necessarily either-or. If he had the time to personally write the tweet, I think he would be willing to lend some engineers to help get them set up with their services.
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by micromacrofoot on Monday November 04, 2024 @03:59PM (#42045909)
The full quote is

> Hey AG Sulzberger @nytimes sorry to see this. Perplexity is on standby to help ensure your essential coverage is available to all through the election. DM me anytime here.”

it's absolutely scab behavior

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by lxgr on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:05PM (#42045963)
Sure, but why add "with AI"?
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by miltonlost on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:24PM (#42046120)
"Because if a "machine/AI" does the work, it's not scabbing!" - executives, lying through their teeth.

They're using AI as smokescreen for anti-labor practices, as all AI tech executives are.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by lxgr on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:32PM (#42046201)
> "Because if a "machine/AI" does the work, it's not scabbing!"

Who is claiming that in this thread, the linked Techcrunch article, or the tweet quoted in that article?

And even if the Perplexity CEO in particular, or AI tech executives generally were to make that claim elsewhere: Misquoting somebody to strengthen a point like that immediately and significantly reduces my trust in a source.

Also, I'd say that the fact that Techcrunch just changed the headline speaks for itself.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by miltonlost on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:41PM (#42046786)
Oh, mine wasn't intended to be a literal quote from anyone, hence why I said `- executives, lying through their teeth.` and didn't name anyone specific.

But this notion is definitely rolling around in the heads of these people, even if they won't say so because it's bad optics. What a CEO/executive says and what they believe and what they do are three very different things. You often cannot trust their weasel words.

But as for "the PerplexityAI CEO didn't say "with AI" in those words!!!"... how else exactly would an AI company help out with striking workers without their product of AI? That is an obvious subtext unsaid.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by segasaturn on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:35PM (#42046219)
What non-AI solutions does Perplexity have to provide to NYT?
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by nusl on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @03:49AM (#42049798)
This is pretty much implied here. Perplexity is an AI-focused company. They're trying to make money off of a shitty situation. AI is a "cheap" tool to use for this purpose. It's really, really scummy.
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by micromacrofoot on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @09:43AM (#42051798)
why add "with AI" to the company named "Perplexity AI"?
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by dangerwill on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:35PM (#42046224)
You are either being wilfully ignorant or don't know how strikes work. Offering to "help" during a strike is scabbing by definition
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by lxgr on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:33PM (#42046698)
I'm not disagreeing with that assertion at all: He's clearly offering them something to sabotage the strike.

I'm just pointing out that "offering to help" does equal "offering to help with AI". Sure, it's somewhat heavily implied by context, but journalistic integrity means making it clear what's an implication and what somebody actually said.

TechCrunch even seems to agree: They changed the headline retroactively.

Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by __loam on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:49PM (#42046325)
Crossing the picket line like this is craven and opportunistic.
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by derektank on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:55PM (#42046376)
Pretty opportunistic to strike right before what is likely one of the highest traffic days for the NYT all year too
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by sealeck on Monday November 04, 2024 @06:53PM (#42047340)
That's also known as playing your cards effectively
Re:New York Times Tech Workers Go on Strike by mandolingual on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:34PM (#42046717)
Yes, workers will take advantage of opportunities for their strike action to be more effective, good point.