News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by komali2 on Monday November 04, 2024 @12:34AM (#42038794)
This reminds me of an anarchist article I recently read against voting.

https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/william-gillis-the-c...

> The argument for voting is very Kantian: “act so that if everyone acted so…” and “if no literally one voted then voting would matter again” but if literally no one voted the government wouldn’t maintain legitimacy. And in any case this is not an actual causality. When you vote you don’t magically cause everyone else like you to vote, you are a distinct agent with distinct internal thoughts. Your individual actions have only very weak externalities beyond the direct consequences of your choice/vote.

> Unfortunately the delusional thinking behind voting crops up in leftist inclinations in general. They want to build giant organizations, giant armies, with individuals all acting in low return-on-investment ways, in hopes of aggregate impact. They don’t search for opportunities of high impact individual direct action.

I was getting into an argument with some people who were yelling at me for voting third party in the USA federal election. Because I'm a Texas voter it's my fault the state won't turn blue. "If all Texas non voters voted, and if all third party voters voted democrat, the state would turn blue." And if only people would just stop committing crime, if only people would just not steal from their employees, if only people would just Do The Right Thing...

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by pixelatedindex on Monday November 04, 2024 @01:23AM (#42039022)
Thanks for the link. As someone who feels disenfranchised with a countercultural thread running through, a lot of it resonated with me. I do tend to vote third party as well (maybe not this election given the state of the GOP) — after all, it’s your vote, why give it to someone you don’t agree with?

Though I will say that if you didn’t vote, then you don’t get to complain about the system because after all by not voting you’re rejecting a core tenet of the system. I gotta read more things out of this library, this is fun to noodle on.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by ddingus on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:02AM (#42039795)
Comment below not intended as direct rebuttal to parent comment.

It is just a relevant riff on the tired if you don't vote, don't complain BS.

Soap box mode = 1

Yes you do get to complain same as anyone does whether you or anyone voted or not.

Never let anyone tell you otherwise.

In the US, voting is not mandatory.

Casting voting as a condition of redressing ones grievances with government is actually just a psyops version of manufactured consent.

If you are inclined to consent, and you feel a vote is worth casting, by all means vote!

Maybe you think the whole thing lacks legitimacy? And you want to vote indie or third party or maybe even participate in ratfucking by voting for the very worst candidate a given party could get stuck with?

By all means vote.

Otherwise you are not required to vote and not voting is just fine.

You remain a citizen. The Constitution still applies and all that stuff we know and expect is exactly the same whether we vote or not.

Encouraging others to vote for many other reasons is fine too. Don't get me wrong there.

I am very specifically calling out the idea of ones participation in this US society being predicated on a vote.

That is just not true, and I really dislike advocacy rooted in falsehoods like this kind of advocacy always is.

Soap box mode = 0

Maybe I will take a look at this library myself!

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by SllX on Monday November 04, 2024 @01:47AM (#42039139)
> Though I will say that if you didn’t vote, then you don’t get to complain about the system because after all by not voting you’re rejecting a core tenet of the system. I gotta read more things out of this library, this is fun to noodle on.

As a previous water-carrier for this form of “if you don’t vote you don’t get to complain” propaganda, it’s crap. If there isn’t one single person you want to vote for on the ballot, you’re fully entitled to not vote and complain loudly about it. Making the choice to not exercise the one right does not preclude anyone’s use of the other.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by tonyedgecombe on Monday November 04, 2024 @03:55AM (#42039751)
The thing to do is spoil your ballot. Otherwise people will think you are being lazy (and they will probably be right in most cases).
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by SllX on Monday November 04, 2024 @04:20AM (#42039869)
The thing to do is not blanket assign connotations to other people’s choice in how and when they execute their rights.
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by pixelatedindex on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:36AM (#42042495)
Of course, you can complain loudly about who’s on the ballot. But you don’t get to complain about the outcome of the election because you decided to opt out.
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by komali2 on Monday November 04, 2024 @11:06AM (#42042846)
> But you don’t get to complain about the outcome of the election because you decided to opt out.

Why not?

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by SllX on Monday November 04, 2024 @10:48AM (#42042627)
Nah. You can opt out and complain about the outcome too. That’s my point. Not exercising the one does not preclude the other, despite what wannabe gatekeepers may declare otherwise.
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by pixelatedindex on Monday November 04, 2024 @05:36PM (#42046735)
Sure, if you’re active in local government / community. To rephrase, what I meant was you can’t complain if you don’t partake at all because then you’re offering no solution or doing anything to make things better.
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by scarecrowbob on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @03:53PM (#42055065)
I mean, if you're not in a military committing atrocities, clearly you shouldn't have any voice in saying if that military should commit atrocities- because then you’re offering no solution or doing anything to make things better. Makes perfect sense to me. /s
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by troyvit on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @10:33AM (#42052260)
There's a write-in spot on ballots for a reason.

That said there are more than people on ballots to vote for, and some of those things (open space, conceal and carry laws, abortion restrictions, school choice) are possibly more important than the people at the top of the ticket because as local measures they have a higher chance to directly affect you.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by SllX on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @11:08AM (#42052597)
I am a seasoned voter who submitted his ballot several weeks ago in addition to prior-water-carrier for said propaganda. I know how ballots work.

All of that is irrelevant.

Choosing not to exercise your right to vote is a valid choice, and choosing not to exercise that right does not preclude you from complaining about electoral outcomes and the policies of the extant and future governments.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by troyvit on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @04:04PM (#42055149)
> choosing not to exercise that right does not preclude you from complaining about electoral outcomes

Sure. But it means I take you as seriously as I would any arm chair quarterback complaining about sports.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by SllX on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @05:19PM (#42055683)
In a vacuum, valid. You can do that. Depending on someone’s reasoning, I might do the same, but I don’t draw the line specifically at whether someone voted or not. It’s not decisive criteria.
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by BeFlatXIII on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @11:20AM (#42052752)
Then write in Mickey Mouse
Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by jrm4 on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @03:06PM (#42054732)
Current water-carrier here; I find it especially hard to believe that anyone could find a ballot where a few minutes of internet research would not reveal an at least slightly preferable candidate -- if not for you personally, for your community.

Ultimately, I find the supposed "principled non-voter" to simply just be selfish.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by SllX on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @03:31PM (#42054886)
Sure, maybe it’s selfish, but so is voting. That’s not a sin.

Voting someone into office is inherently about electing them into a position of power. Generally that means voters are going to prefer someone who is aligned with their interests. If you examine a ballot and determine that that is no one running, then it is fine to draw the conclusion that you would prefer to skip this election.

Voting also has consequences. If your world view is not developed enough to determine who that person would be, it is also fine to wait until you’re older before you begin voting in elections. Elections are recurring, it isn’t necessary to vote in every single one of them, and on every single item on the ballot until you have an interest in doing so.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by grahamj on Monday November 04, 2024 @09:19AM (#42041727)
Deciding not to murder and not to steal have measurable real-world effects. Voting in a way that results in no change does not. Voting on principle only works when you have proportional representation.

You should vote in a way that moves the needle the way you want it to move.

Re:Please just stop saying "just" (2019) by pixl97 on Tuesday November 05, 2024 @09:19AM (#42051630)
Anarchist: "If everyone would just stop forming governments"

>but if literally no one voted the government wouldn’t maintain legitimacy

This is why no one takes anarchists seriously.

Now, the problem is not voting for first parties. It's lack of mandatory voting, and FPTP voting. Change it to ranked choice and suddenly third party votes wouldn't be wasted votes.